r/Geico•
programmerq

Can I directly request a supplemental as a claimant?

tldr; bad bearing that wasn't included in the original claim. The shop is booked for a long time. I want to get the supplement paperwork sorted. The adjuster told me that the supplement paperwork is completed by a shop, and wasn't aware of a way for me to request it directly. Do I have any options?

---

A Geico policyholder hit my parked and unoccupied van in a parking lot. The rear left wheel was pushed into the curb, and popped the tire off. That bearing is now bad. The adjuster can't see the bad bearing, so he added a rear suspension alignment to the initial claim, and explained that a supplemental could be requested.

Well, the bearing sound is getting worse, and shops are super backed up. It's pretty straightforward to swap out the hub assembly myself. Many online shop estimators put the hub assembly job at about $360-$450 for parts and labor for my vehicle. It's like a $140 part with shipping included or $260 from the local dealer.

I asked him if I could just... request the supplement. I figured it'd be a matter of punching into the adjuster software "bad bearing" and it'd populate with a part cost estimate, and some number of hours of labor and that'd be that. I even offered to drive out to meet him to show him the bad bearing in person (jack up the rear end and spin both wheels and it's pretty obvious it's a bearing)

He wasn't sure if there was a process for the claimant to request the supplement directly rather than having a shop do it. He suggested that I could find a regular shop that isn't as backed up as the body shop to deal with the supplement paperwork. He even brought up a rental vehicle while the bearing was being dealt with. It seems silly for it to be easier and cheaper for Geico to pay for a rental and make me drop off my car at a mechanic just for some paperwork on the supplemental. alas, large companies with rigid software systems are not always the most efficient in every case.

Is there some form I can download to get it dealt with?

If I order the part and do it myself, can I just send Geico the receipt for the part?

My regular mechanic shop doesn't deal with insurance issues, so they aren't able to help with the paperwork.

Thanks!

Posted Jan 1, 2023, 3:24 AM UTC

09
UptakeTheSun•

Here’s why you need to take it to a shop: You’re claiming the bearing is damaged, the damage cannot be visibly seen, and any insurance company would need/want a shop to show us why it was damaged in this loss and is not just a bad bearing. The adjuster can’t see it, you can’t show it in photos, and they’ll need proof from a professional. You can claim it’s damaged from this accident, they’ll need an independent professional to show them how and why.

It’s possible your bearing is related, it’s also possible that it’s not, or that something else is damaged. They won’t just pay to replace a bearing because they suspect it’s damaged, you need to prove damages. Since photos can’t show it then you can’t prove it being damaged or related, that’s where a shop will come in.

Take your vehicle to a shop, tell them exactly what happened in an accident, have them inspect and write up how the bearing is damaged and why - they should be able to do this is a service ticket, most shops could write it up. However, if you take it to a shop and they won’t put it in writing then I’d reasonably suspect it’s either not from this loss or not the bearing because a shop won’t want to put their name on something they can’t stand behind.

17
dontsettleforlessorGEICOUnited.org Supporter•

Yes you can.

It's called a I want a little bit more money letter.

It's kinda like a letter to Santa.

10
programmerqOP•

Like this? 😂

Dear Santa Sexy lizard,

Please give me more money.

Kthx, ♥

2

Use a different shop you little hoe

5
GEICO-AnonymousLibiddy (Verified Geico Employee) Bibiddy•

Libiddy Bibiddy.

5
Mangomama619•

Neither geico insureds NOR claimants can directly request supplements. These requests HAVE to come from a body shop.

4
josh42390•

That’s not necessarily true. Plenty of insureds and claimants during my career did the work themselves. They had my direct line and would call when they found more damage that they could prove was accident related. I would call my supervisor and have him assign me a supplement. I would then go out to their house, take whatever photos I needed to verify accident related and issue the supplement payment.

7
Doraylia•

To my knowledge it has to go through the body shop. In 13 years I’ve never seen a claimant directed supplement. In fact, when they call asking how to get one, we tell them to take it to their shop and have them request it. Is it possible? Maybe, but the only people I know who have access to the supplement form are the auto damage adjusters.

If you do the work yourself you may not get reimbursed because all work has to be approved by an auto damage adjuster. They need to see the damage and confirm that it’s actually related to the loss and not something unrelated that you’re trying to pad the claim with. Your best bet is to contact the adjuster directly. There are photo estimates but I don’t know if that applies to supplements. They can give you clear instructions and direction.

1†
programmerqOP•

Thanks for confirming.

I guess I was hoping that I could go the faster diy route since the holiday is pushing things out.

I am mildly surprised that there's not a way to make this happen since going to a shop and getting a rental will cost geico way more, but this case isn't terribly common.

My adjuster has been super cool so far. I'm just nervous since the car I thought was "drivable" may not be totally safe since bearing damaged in the crash is getting worse.

1