I do not agree with the idea that abortion is murder.

General debate

Obviously from the title, and from my user flair, you can tell that I am pro choice.

I believe that whether or not somebody has an abortion is THEIR choice. It should be between them, and their doctor.

The government should not be meddling in a woman's ability to choose to abort a pregnancy, nor should anybody else. It is her business.

Having children is not a good choice for some people. Maybe they can't afford a child. Maybe they would be a high risk pregnancy. Or, maybe they just simply don't want children.

Whatever the reason (or lack of reason) somebody has for getting an abortion, I believe it's their choice, and their business, and they should be free to do as they wish, without any restrictions, and without anybody sticking their nose in their business.

Now, to get on with the point of this post -- as the title says, I do not believe that abortion is murder.

You hear this argument quite frequently from the pro life community.

First off, at the time most abortions are performed, the fetus is no more than a clump of cells, unrecognizable as a human. To say that removing a collection of cells is equal to murdering a human being is insane, in my opinion.

But even for abortions that are done on pregnancies that are further along, even at the point where the fetus IS recognizable as a human, I still do not believe that abortion is murder.

You can not murder someone (or something) that hasn't been born yet.

Without birth having occurred in the first place, there is no murder.

Abortion is simply preventing birth from occurring -- it is not murder.

Posted Jan 3, 2023, 4:42 PM UTC

32179
drowning35789Pro-choice•

If PLs really thought abortion was murder they wouldn't be fine with former abortion doctors and women who have gotten abortions representing them. Either that or they're fine with murder

20
coedwigzPro-abortion•

This is a great point I’ve never thought of. They say abortion is murder yet welcome reformed “murderers” with open arms?

13
Talking_It_OverAgainst convenience abortions•

If PC's really thought denying abortions was rape and slavery, they'd certainly be a little more active in opposition. Is their passivity a quiet acceptance of rape and slavery?

-5
parcheesichzpartyPro-choice•

Lol Citation needed for PC being passive.

12
TheInvisibleJeevaspro-choice, here to argue my position•

If you legislate anti-abortion laws, you deserve jail, yes.

12
drowning35789Pro-choice•

PCs are active, and they don't have rapists and former slave owners representing them

5
ghoulishaura•

Characterizing a woman or girl removing an unwanted mass from her own body as "murder" is shockingly misogynistic, to an extent that it's hard to truly fathom. The only way that even makes any kind of "sense" is to reduce women and girls to object status.

18
mesalikeredditpostPro-choice•

Which is why many of their attempts at analogies aren't analogous.

4
NavalGazingGestational Slavery Abolitionist•

It's never murder to remove someone or something from inside your body, even if it needs your body for its survival.

You also can't murder a partially developed body that can't sustain its own life. The ZEF dies because it doesn't have the necessary organ functions for life. It doesn't have lung, liver, kidney, waste removal or endocrine functions. It literally can't survive without parasitizing from the woman and using her body's organ functions for its survival.

18
Roach_ScientistPro-life•

It's never murder to remove someone or something from inside your body, even if it needs your body for its survival.

True, but you can murder your infant by neglecting it.

You also can't murder a partially developed body that can't sustain its own life. The ZEF dies because it doesn't have the necessary organ functions for life.

I wonder about hospital serial killers. They kill patients on respirators amd such. They go to jail for murder, even though their victims' bodies cannot sustain life. Which means your argument would have to hinge on development.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Cullen

-1
Striking-Hand5434•

An infant isn't a fetus. No one is 'murdering infants'

5
Roach_ScientistPro-life•

Oh yes, people do put infants in dumpsters to die. Thankfully it is rare.

1
Striking-Hand5434•

Yep

And what does that have to do with abortion exactly? Nothing. So what's your point here?

All you've done is prove the point that access to abortion is necessary so infants don't end up in dumpsters.

So thanks!

5
Lets_Go_DarwinSafe, legal and rare•

Even PL proponents don't really believe abortion is murder, they just like to use this word for emotional manipulation. If they did, they would treat women who had abortions and medical professionals who performed them accordingly. Instead, once one of those publicly declares they are now PL, they are given a platform to preach PL ideas.

Can you imagine this happening with any other type of murder?

13
drowning35789Pro-choice•

They literally worship former abortion doctors who are pro life as if they're some religious convert.

They keep comparing abortion with genocide, would they forgive a former prison guard? Even people over 100 are being convicted for war crimes that happened decades ago.

They are for 'forgiving' women who had abortions then that means they would have to forgive those prison guards as well and the person who started a genocide

16
Trick_Ganachepro-choice, here to argue my position•

When they can get you to believe absurdities (objective moral absolutes, stuff about minorities, women, people who don't bow down to an esoteric ultimate authority, stuff that they do all the time and project onto others, etc), they can get you to commit atrocities (... and say the most bizarre conspiracy theories out in public. I'm sure they're totally not going to do something about the content of their rants/s).

9
RedditorWithClassOPPro-choice•

Unfortunately, too many people believe that it is murder, in my experience.

I see this argument online frequently, but I've even had in person conversations and debates with PLers who have fought tooth and nail saying that abortion is murdering children, which simply isn't correct.

9
ghoulishaura•

For the most part, they're lying through their teeth. "Abortion is baybee murdurrr" PLers frequently get or finance hush-hush abortions. Most high profile PL women have had multiple (known)abortions.

12
Lets_Go_DarwinSafe, legal and rare•
6
Talking_It_OverAgainst convenience abortions•

Can you imagine this happening with any other type of murder?

The first search result on my end: From murder to ministry, reformed Long Beach pastor preaches redemption

-2
Lets_Go_DarwinSafe, legal and rare•

Search again, maybe the second result will give you a murderer who didn't serve time for their action and was made celebrity by some anti-murder movement.

10
Trick_Ganachepro-choice, here to argue my position•

To say that removing a collection of cells is equal to murdering a human being is insane, in my opinion.

But even for abortions that are done on pregnancies that are further along, even at the point where the fetus IS recognizable as a human, I still do not believe that abortion is murder.

You can not murder someone (or something) that hasn't been born yet.

Afterall, if they are going to call you a murderer, they better get that ZEF away from you before you abort the pregnancy...

But no, in pler minds the safest place for a potential murder victim is yo always be in reach of the murderer who assures everyone they will end the pregnancy early. How long before they simply arrest you and make you sleep on jail cell floors for months?

Well, that was quick!

11
WatermelonWarlockPro Legal Abortion•

First off, at the time most abortions are performed, the fetus is no more than a clump of cells, unrecognizable as a human. To say that removing a collection of cells is equal to murdering a human being is insane, in my opinion.

You're gonna piss off some PLers by calling it a "clump of cells".

11
RedditorWithClassOPPro-choice•

Sometimes the truth hurts

16
rapsuliPro-life•

Nah, most are probably not pissed off, this is par for the course, sadly.

OP simply made it clear how little they have really looked into the topic.
So not many PLs will bother to respond. Too bad, but it's just not really worth the effort.

0
milbro0813•

And a lot of women who have had miscarriages...

-1

Fellow pro choicer here. I’m also not convinced that abortion is “murder” (as in, a wrongful killing). And I think pro lifers are convinced that it is murder because of black and white thinking with a flawed ethical premise. Like for example, “It’s a biological human life! And it’s wrong to kill biological human life, so therefore abortion is murder.” But we kill biologically alive humans when we take brain dead people off of life support or harvest their organs for donations. And that’s not considered wrong. So there has to be more to it than that. Clearly, having a functioning brain with a mind of your own is important, and there’s scientific evidence that fetuses aren’t sentient until around 20-odd weeks of pregnancy, which is well past when most abortions happen. I think this is where a lot of pro choicers aren’t convinced that fetuses are “people” who can be killed wrongfully.

If you find the sentience argument interesting I recommend googling Nathan Nobis and erin_nurse_practitioner on tik tok. They do a good job explaining the sentience argument.

9
strongwill2rise1Safe, legal and rare•

Very well put. It's like screaming that someone killed a whole chicken every time they eat an egg.

3
[deleted]•

Taking brain dead patients off of life support is a much different situation than ending the life of a fetus.

Brain dead patients are legally considered dead as they will never gain brain function ever again.

Fetuses are not considered by definition unconscious. They will gain consciousness at some point, just like you regain consciousness when waking up.

You can't justify aborting a fetus through the fact that dead bodies must be taken away from life support. If nobody intervenes, the dead body remains dead. If nobody intervenes with the fetus, it remains alive and developing.

-1

If we define clinical death as when someone’s brain dead and no longer sentient, then that implies that you die when your mind dies. If you end when your mind ends, then that means you don’t begin until your mind begins.

Which is why I think abortion is generally permissible assuming it’s within the earlier stages of gestation, and also in conjunction with rights to bodily autonomy.

1
BrutalOutTherePro-choice•

Abortion isn’t “murder” because it doesn’t fit the definition of the word. Pretty simple.

5
todas-las-flores•

The only way abortion=murder is if we accept the exceedingly flawed premise that a zygote, embryo or fetus is exactly equal to a newborn. The majority do not accept that flawed premise, given fetal personhood has been voted down in 100% of the cases when put to a vote, including in Colorado, North Dakota & Mississippi. Even the nutjobs on the Supreme Court don't buy the flawed premise, as of 10/11/22.

Clearly, the abortion=murder argument does not work after 50 years of the same, tired argument. They need to go back to the drawing board to come up with arguments that are actually convincing.

3
AutoModeratorMOD•

Welcome to r/Abortiondebate! Don't be a jerk (even if someone else is being a jerk to you first). It's not constructive and we may ban you for it. Check out the Debate Guidance Pyramid to understand acceptable debate levels.

Attack the argument, not the person making it.

For our new users, please check out our rules and sub policies

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
Striking-Hand5434•

So why bring up newborns in dumpsters if it has nothing to do with abortion being legal/illegal?

A fetus is not an infant.

Like a teenager is not a toddler

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
kazakhstanthetrumpetMODPL Mod•

Removed for rule 1. Please use the terms pro-choice and pro-life unless otherwise indicated by a specific user.

1
poordlyPro-life•

You can't murder someone who hasn't been born?

So you would be fine if a 40 week "fetus" is killed in the womb because the parents change their mind?

-1†
i_have_questonsPro-choice•

I am fine with any elective abortion that is performed by medical professionals for a consenting pregnant person that is safer for the pregnant person then birth would be.

I don't think there exists any elective abortion performed by medical professionals that is not safer for a pregnant person then birth would be, however.

9
poordlyPro-life•

How much safer?

So if I can prove that X makes me ANY amount safer than I would otherwise be, I'm justified to kill a complete stranger in order to be slightly safer?

-2
i_have_questonsPro-choice•

How much safer?

When it's the safest way.

I'm justified to kill a complete stranger in order to be slightly safer?

If they are inside your body and using your biological organs/systems against your will and that is the safest way for you to stop them? Yes, always.

10
poordlyPro-life•

So if I can prove that killing you makes me 0.01% less likely to die, I'm justified in doing so.

That is your standard you want to go with?

-2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
kdimitrakPro-choice•

does this happen? do you have an example of a woman killing a 40 week fetus rather than just giving birth to it?

8
poordlyPro-life•

Yes, women abort healthy, viable babies in America.

It's why Kermit Gosnell is in prison.

Do you want to answer the question or no? What about ,39 weeks then? 38 weeks? 37?

0
kdimitrakPro-choice•

to answer your question, i’m fine with any decision made by a woman and her doctor. it’s none of my business.

but i’m still waiting for an example of a woman literally killing a healthy, 40 week fetus before birth.

9
poordlyPro-life•

Nah. I'm moving on now.

-2
Excellent_Fee2252•

Until the birthing process (water break etc) begins 👍🏻

5
poordlyPro-life•

So 40 weeks is okay.

That's a yikes from me, chief.

-1
ALancreWitchPro-choice•

Please provide evidence that women are aborting healthy foetuses past viability….

5
OceanBlues1•

So you would be fine if a 40 week "fetus" is killed in the womb because the parents change their mind?

Last time I checked, 24 weeks was the general cutoff point for ELECTIVE abortions to be done. Meaning, a doctor wouldn't perform an abortion at 40 weeks just "because the parents changed their mind."

6
poordlyPro-life•

There are seven states with no abortion restrictions.

You would be fine with abortions at 40 weeks or not?

Yes, late term abortions often happen for reasons like the parent didn't know they were pregnant and didn't avail themselves of abortion earlier, race selective abortions, or the parents financial or romantic situation changed.

0
OceanBlues1•

You would be fine with abortions at 40 weeks or not?

For MEDICAL abortions at 40 or more weeks, necessary due to serious and/or life-threatening to the woman, YES, I would be fine with that.

I don't believe ELECTIVE abortions (those done for "just because" reasons) take place at 40 weeks or more.

8
poordlyPro-life•

I didn't ask whether it happens or not.

I'm asking whether your moral principle permits killing a baby in the womb because it's in tbe mothers body and violating her bodily autonomy.

-1
drowning35789Pro-choice•

First of all 40 week abortion aren't even done, they will have to induce labour, there is no place for abortion there.

Also does being a 40 week old fetus give it the right to another person's body? Why does it have the right no one else has?

5
BrutalOutTherePro-choice•

Pregnancies are aborted, not fetuses. Fetuses are viable way before 40 weeks. 25 weeks last I checked. Killing a viable human isn’t an “abortion” any more than an appendectomy is.

What you’re describing is “murder” and it’s already illegal.

3
kingacesuitedMOD•

This comment is flagged for rule 3, Cite Your Sources.

It contains two questions and no assertions.

With no assertions or claims being made there is nothing to support.

The comment is approved without further moderation.

1
possum_eaterAnti-abortion•

Same song and dance. You'd swear I'd be talking to the same person 20 different times.

-1
BrutalOutTherePro-choice•

It’s the “same song and dance” because the definition of “murder” hasn’t changed in centuries, and it STILL doesn’t apply to abortion procedures.

3
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
maxanderson350Pro-life except life-threats•

"You can not murder someone (or something) that hasn't been born yet."

- Are you using the word "murder" in the legal sense or as a stand-in for the word "kill" (and its variants)?

-7
i_have_questonsPro-choice•

Either way, how does one end the life of someone/something that doesn't have anything of their own that gives them life to begin with?

10
maxanderson350Pro-life except life-threats•

Either way

- Ok. If the former, I agree. If the latter, I do not.

​

how does one end the life of someone/something that doesn't have anything of their own that gives them life to begin with?

- You seem to be asking how we could die prior to birth if we are not alive prior to birth. Is that a correct reading of your question?

-1
i_have_questonsPro-choice•

You seem to be asking how we could die prior to birth if we are not alive prior to birth. Is that a correct reading of your question?

Correct.

If you have nothing of your own that gives you life, how can your life be ended?

You have to have your own life in order for it to be ended.

In order for you to have your own life, you have to have something of your own that gives you life.

A pregnant person has their own biological organs/systems that gives them life.

Their pregnancy doesn't have any of these, which is why it would not remain alive once removed from the pregnant person's body via abortion.

The pregnant person's own biological organs/systems are keeping their own pregnancy alive because their pregnancy doesn't yet have anything of it's own that gives them life.

6
maxanderson350Pro-life except life-threats•

Great. Thank you for clarifying.

As you don't believe we are alive prior to our birth, do you believe that we become alive upon birth? Or after birth? Or shortly prior to birth?

0
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
CounterSpecialist386Pro-life•

Your abortion doctors are pretty frank about who they are killing.

A BBC interview with abortionist, Leroy Carhart. Late term abortionist Dr. Leroy Carhart, who does abortions through the third trimester, told reporter Hilary Andersson of the BBC that he believes he is killing babies. Here is the transcript:

Carhart: To the fetus is makes no difference whether it’s born or not born. The baby has no input in this, as far as I’m concerned.

Hilary Andersson: But it’s interesting that you use the word baby because a lot of abortionists won’t use that. They’ll use the term fetus because they don’t want to acknowledge that there’s a life.

Carhart: I- I think that it is a baby and I tell our- I use it with the patients.

Hilary Andersson: And you don’t have a problem with killing a baby?

Carhart: (Pause) I have no problem if it’s in the mother’s uterus.”

BBC July 22, 2019 program:

“America’s Abortion War”

Watch the whole piece in full here...

https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m00071k9

“It is hard to describe how it feels to pull out parts of a baby, to see arms, and bits of leg, and finally the head. […] Given the nature of this experience, it greatly concerns me how lightly some of these decisions are made.”

-Dr. Vincent Argent, British abortionist in an interview with The Telegraph


"I have angry feelings at myself for feeling good about grasping the calvaria, for feeling good about doing a technically good procedure that destroys a fetus, kills a baby."

  • From the article "Abortion Providers Share Inner Conflicts" which appeared in the July 12 1993 issue of AAA News, a publication of the American Medical Association

"I have taken the lives of innocent babies, and I have ripped them from their mother's wombs with a powerful suction machine"

  • McArthur Hill, M.D. From "Abortion at Work: Ideology and Practice in a Feminist Clinic" by Wendy Simonds. New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press, 1996

Pro-choice activist and filmmaker Julia Black, daughter of Tim Black, who heads up Britain’s largest abortion provider made the film, My Fetus. In an interview with Tony Jones she said, bluntly:

"[The idea of] dismembering a baby and pulling it out in pieces … is obviously horrific. But at the same time, it is easy to get caught up in that emotion."

Ed Vitagliano “Murder: So What? Film Reveals Growing Callousness Toward Abortion” AFA Journal Nov/Dec 2004

An article in Social Science & Medicine discusses the things abortionists feel they cannot say about their work, for fear it will hurt the pro-abortion cause. One topic the article covers is how abortionists acknowledge abortion is killing. One abortionist says:

“[A]bortion is life and death and I think for me it’s about providers saying, “Yes, we end lives here,” and being okay with that … I had a woman wake up in the recovery room and say, “I just killed my baby.” And I said to her, “You did, and that’s okay.” And just, being okay, to say that…. That’s what I feel we’re doing here. And I’m okay with that.”

Lisa A. Martin, PhD, Jane A. Hassinger, MSW, Michelle Debbink, MD, PhD, Lisa H. Harris, MD, PhD “Dangertalk: Voices of abortion providers” Social Science & Medicine 184 (2017) 75-83


In the section on Abortion Counseling, you can read stories from former Planned Parenthood workers and former Planned Parenthood patients talking about how PP denies that a pregnant woman is carrying a “baby.” Instead, they use words like “products of conception” or “fetal tissue.” But in a video on YouTube aimed at teaching children about sex, PP admits they knew it was a baby all along. The video narrator says:

“With younger children you can keep it simple and direct. For example, you can say “A baby grows in a parent’s belly and comes out of their vagina.” That may be all it takes to satisfy their curiosity. If they ask, “How does the baby get in the belly?” You can say something like, “Most women have tiny eggs in a special part of their belly. Most men have very tiny seeds, called sperm. If sperm and egg meet they can grow into a baby.”

Planned Parenthood video “How Do I Talk With My Kid About Where Babies Come From?”

https://youtu.be/QE2kMLyQP-A

-8
TheInvisibleJeevaspro-choice, here to argue my position•

Good thing killing =/= murder. The word “murder” doesn’t appear in any of your quotes.

18
Forever_ChangesPro-choice•

Sure, but this is down to whether the killing is justified or not which is the whole purpose of the debate. So it's begging the question to say it's not murder; although I do agree it isn't murder.

7
CounterSpecialist386Pro-life•

That's what genocidal regimes and slaveholders said too..."our actions are not against the law, therefore it is not murder".

You are deliberately killing a human being who has done nothing wrong to deserve their death. That is a fact from which you cannot escape.

-4
ghoulishaura•

You are deliberately killing a human being who has done nothing wrong

It's in her body when she doesn't want it to be. You might as well characterize chemotherapy as murder by your logic.

13
CounterSpecialist386Pro-life•

Chemotherapy doesn't kill another innocent human being. False equivalency.

-3
parcheesichzpartyPro-choice•

Hi! How can the nonsentient deserve anything?

Here's the definition to get you started.

de·serve /dəˈzərv/ Learn to pronounce verb do something or have or show qualities worthy of (reward or punishment). "the referee deserves a pat on the back for his bravery."

11
Environmental-Egg191Pro-choice•

That's what genocidal regimes and slaveholders said too..."our actions are not against the law, therefore it is not murder".

Slaveholders and genocidal regimes also outlawed abortion. So using them of a yard stick of whether a supposition is right or wrong seems pretty irrelevant in this case.

A murder is an unjust killing. There is two types of justice in question - justice based on laws which may be fair or unfair based on the prejudices of the society that builds them, and moral justice which generally tries to separate itself out from prejudices.

We know you can't gamble use of your body or your organs, nor can you be compelled to give them to someone else to do so would be morally unjust. To think you should be able to would be to get into bed with the slaveholders. So someone trying to take these things from you could be justly killed at least from a legal stand point.

Now would it be morally just to kill someone who was trying to take use of your body or your organs without your permission? Well what is the impact to them? They cease to exist which they wouldn't have anyway without use of your body without your permission (your egg is yours). They feel nothing in the process and have no awareness they ever existed at all.

It seems therefore morally unjust to prevent someone from maintaining their bodily autonomy and morally unjust to force someone to become a slave to the new organism. Abortion is a just killing.

8
JulieCronepro-legal-abortion•

That happens when you cancel a blood donation too - a human who would have lived had you kept a promise will die. Shall they be tried for murder?

8
falloutfan2067•

That could actually be a valid legal argument for breach of implied contract if done in the right situation but not murder (expect maybe if the donator is forcibly barred from donating by a third party but then the third party would be on trial not the donator) in most cases.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

7
kingacesuitedMOD•

Comment removed per rule 7.

We have a moratorium on references to certain atrocities. In this example the Transatlantic slave trade is mentioned. Please mention slavery in the abstract or use a different example to get your point across.

The comment may be edited for approval.

1
CatChick75All abortions free and legal•

Since when is having sex a crime?

7
RedditorWithClassOPPro-choice•

I genuinely could not care less what any of the quotes you have provided say.

Without birth, there is no murder. You can not kill a person who hasn't been born yet. It's really as simple as that :)

13
CounterSpecialist386Pro-life•

You can not kill a person who hasn't been born yet.

Gotta love those classic freudian slips lol.

-2
parcheesichzpartyPro-choice•

It's totally reasonable to think a fetus is a person and still think no person gets to use someone's body against their will.

You should stop guessing what people mean and start asking them. It makes you look like you're debating in bad faith.

20
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
maxanderson350Pro-life except life-threats•

You can not kill a person who hasn't been born yet.

There is a lot baked into such a claim and it would be nice to explore how you reached that conclusion. But first, could you clarify the following regarding your opinion?

  1. Do you agree with the following statement: "We are not alive prior to our birth."
-4
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
CatChick75All abortions free and legal•

That still doesn't make it murder.

8
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
SailorENCPro-life•

You can not murder someone (or something) that hasn't been born yet.

Without birth having occurred in the first place, there is no murder.

these assumptions seem like premises that are very central to your overall conclusion... most of the rest of your statements seemed to indicate why we shouldn't care about the potential murder but dont really offer a reason as to why its not murder.

maybe you should start by defining murder and defining abortion and then comparing the definitions and justifying your choices.

if you wanted to make it more difficult on yourself you would define murder and define abortion reasonably but in such a way that abortion falls under the umbrella of murder. this can be an effective argument so long as you are "steelmanning" it and not "strawmanning" it.

good luck!

-10