Brooding in winter when there is warm weather.
New beekeeper here in central USA. This is more of a what if scenario as I am not sure if it is a thing.
We have a warm stretch of temperature that will be in the low 50s for a few weeks at least.
Do colonies ever try to create brood in these types of scenarios? We have at least another 2 months of winter temperatures before spring really starts to hit. If they do have brood should you really worry about it?
Posted Jan 3, 2023, 7:23 PM UTC
I'm in Texas. We pretty much have some amount of brood all year around ... even when we have (momentary) really cold weather. Mine will have 1-2 frames with a little 4-6inch circle, but not much.
If there isn't sufficient pollen and thin nectar coming in... they seem smart enough to keep their brood small. If you were to start feeding them, however, they would likely brood up quite large and likely peak before your spring nectar flow starts.
Your worry comes if the hive starts getting light weight. For me this can happen February/March. I try to hold out on feeding them, as once I start, they brood up and I pretty much have to continue.
When do you start feeding them? I'm in 9b and wondering when to start. I know there is going to be a huge nectar flow in my area with acacias about to bloom.
I'm in 8A. As in u/drones_on_about_bees's case, mine basically never stop brooding.
Your nectar flow dynamics in somewhere in the foothills in CA are going to be quite different from ours. Suffice it to say that if you're about to have a huge nectar flow, you won't want to feed.
Springtime feeding serves two purposes. As Drones said, you do it early in the spring season if one of your colonies is light and you're afraid they'll run out of stores.
The other reason to feed is if you're deliberately stimulating a colony to brood up. This can be a good thing if you want to make vigorous splits as early in the year as you can, for example, or if you're trying to get a colony booming because you're going to graft and raise queens as early in the season as possible, or even because you want the colony to be as strong as possible when a major nectar flow starts (more workers = more honey).
But either way, feeding syrup in the spring will induce a colony to start raising brood. When they brood up, you need to have plans in motion to manage their swarming impulse. Splitting is a good way to do that, provided your daytime highs are high enough to permit mating flights for new queens and your inspections show plentiful drones inside the colony (new queens generally won't be mating with their brothers, but if there are drones in your colonies, there will be drones elsewhere, and those WILL mate with new queens from your apiary).
If you know that you're about to get a massive nectar flow, you should be scratching together extra supers for honey production, and you will want to start looking at the details of when you should expect to be seeing drones.
Really appreciate these deeper explanations. Thank you!
My challenge is that my Spring can be really inconsistent. It can warm up and be in the 80s and 90s for a few weeks, then snap back to a frost. I am finally learning my lessons to not fertilize my garden too early and hold off till March now (it took years to learn to hold off). I don't want to do the same thing with bees where I feed too early and throw them off with a frost. Yes, we are about to have a huge flow but then we'll go back to having cold weather periodically till around late March early April where it's very reliably flying temp so I am hesitant to add a honey super.
I'd like to make a split. My colony is strong, I like their characteristics, there is another beekeeper .3 miles away and I think a wild hive or two so I would think they'd make it to the breeding area at the same time. I two deeps ready to go for them as well as some nuc boxes with plenty of frames that are drawn and some have honey.
Spring is inconsistent in my area, too, but it's noteworthy that my weather can be extremely variable across a short span of time. For example, last year in mid-March, I split a hive because the nectar flow had started and I wanted to prevent it from swarming.
A week later, it snowed. Just slush, and it melted within 36 hours of falling, but it snowed. That did my bees no real harm; there were plenty of drones in evidence before and after, and in fact the queenright end of the split went ahead and swarmed anyway in early April. I missed the prime swarm, but I caught one of the cast swarms off that, hived it, and ended up with three colonies where I'd had just one.
If your local climate is such that you can get a spring bloom, then a cold snap that lasts a week or so, and then it warms back up, I would argue that it's really no big deal. If it can stay cold for longer, then maybe exercise some caution. But this general kind of inconsistent springtime weather is possible in lots of different places, and it isn't something that's going to wreck a colony that has some food stored and has a decent population of workers. Even if they're booming and it gets cold enough so that they have to cluster, at most you'll lose a couple of frames of chilled brood that might be on the outside of the cluster. It's a setback, not a catastrophe.
But again, I'm keeping bees in a wildly different ecology than you are. The best way for you to get answers is to consult beekeepers who're active in your area--I'm not at all knowledgeable about California's flora and geography, but I have driven through enough of the state to be extremely aware that you have lots of diversity based on latitude, elevation, and where you're orientated with respect to various ranges of hills and mountains.
I go by weight. Some years I don't feed at all. But if they are feeling light, I start feeding.