Why would a secret organization use Thieves' Cant?
One of my players is an assassin that belongs to a large secret organization. They were given a mission and sent out where they met the rest of the party. Now the organization wants updates on her current situation. So the question is, why would the organization use Thieves' Cant instead of something like sending?
I would like to use Thieves' Cant for communication as my player is a rogue and it just seems more flavorful and fun, but this secret group is large and powerful enough to do things like scrying or use multiple sending spells a day.
The reason I came up with to not use scrying is that to remain absolutely hidden, the organization refrains from using scrying on it's assassins / targets. If a target can see invisible objects, the orb scrying makes would be a dead give away to a cautious target.
As for sending, the only thing I could come up with is that the secret organization may want more detailed reports sent back to their headquarters, so doing 50 sending spells could be tedious.
Any other reasons to use Thieves' Cant over more powerful magic?
Posted Jan 4, 2023, 7:21 PM UTC
This goes double for wanting to avoid people having direct knowledge of who the bosses are, and said bosses may also want to not have to trust their underlings to accurately report all incoming information.
That's exactly what I was going to say. I feel there is a disconnect between DnD 5e's assumption about magic users and OP's ideas.
In a normal 5e world even a large secret organization (if it's not supposed to be absolutely top level, which it doesn't sound like in the post) would maybe have one or two people who can scry.
Sending would also probably not be in the arsenal of the people in the field and you can hardly have a bunch of wizards just randomly cast sending throughout the day to the field "agents" to see if they have an update.
I like those first three and I'll remember to incorporate 1 and 3 into the organization background / structure. As for the 4th, I agree with it. The organization would be big enough to have higher level casters doing that, but it seems like a waste of resources to be a magical carrier pigeon for your job