Why would a secret organization use Thieves' Cant?

Need Advice: Worldbuilding

One of my players is an assassin that belongs to a large secret organization. They were given a mission and sent out where they met the rest of the party. Now the organization wants updates on her current situation. So the question is, why would the organization use Thieves' Cant instead of something like sending?

I would like to use Thieves' Cant for communication as my player is a rogue and it just seems more flavorful and fun, but this secret group is large and powerful enough to do things like scrying or use multiple sending spells a day.

The reason I came up with to not use scrying is that to remain absolutely hidden, the organization refrains from using scrying on it's assassins / targets. If a target can see invisible objects, the orb scrying makes would be a dead give away to a cautious target.

As for sending, the only thing I could come up with is that the secret organization may want more detailed reports sent back to their headquarters, so doing 50 sending spells could be tedious.

Any other reasons to use Thieves' Cant over more powerful magic?

Posted Jan 4, 2023, 7:21 PM UTC

012
sunesi9•
  1. Thieves' Cant is a language, able to learned and used by non-casters such as rogues, thieves, and assassins. Unless this is a large magic-based organization, they can't operate on the assumption that everyone has access to magic.
  2. Sending is a short message, not suitable for longer conversations.
  3. Sending requires that the caster be familiar with the target. A secret organization may want to avoid that level of familiarity between operatives.
    This goes double for wanting to avoid people having direct knowledge of who the bosses are, and said bosses may also want to not have to trust their underlings to accurately report all incoming information.
  4. Sending is a third level spell. I don't know about your setting, but in mine it's not common for casters to reach third level spells, and those who do may not want to be stuck devoting their higher level slots to Sending.
8
Version_1•

Sending is a third level spell. I don't know about your setting, but in mine it's not common for casters to reach third level spells, and those who do may not want to be stuck devoting their higher level slots to Sending.

That's exactly what I was going to say. I feel there is a disconnect between DnD 5e's assumption about magic users and OP's ideas.

In a normal 5e world even a large secret organization (if it's not supposed to be absolutely top level, which it doesn't sound like in the post) would maybe have one or two people who can scry.

Sending would also probably not be in the arsenal of the people in the field and you can hardly have a bunch of wizards just randomly cast sending throughout the day to the field "agents" to see if they have an update.

2
Rushnik72OP•

I like those first three and I'll remember to incorporate 1 and 3 into the organization background / structure. As for the 4th, I agree with it. The organization would be big enough to have higher level casters doing that, but it seems like a waste of resources to be a magical carrier pigeon for your job

1
captive-sunflower•

I run it as Thieves' Cant is less a language and more a code for talking with someone in a public place where the guards might overhear you and have it not set off any ears.

"Hey, Johnny! Grandma wants me to bring back a few bottles of beer. The cheap stuff."

"Wait is this your dad's ma or your ma's ma?"

"Neither, my wife's."

"Oh, yeah, she likes the dark ale, right?"

"She does, but she'd like the pale this time. 3 bottles. Can you deliver them next week?"

"Oh sure. That'll be six silver."

And we just successfully put a tail on the countess for the next week and we'll get a report back.

3
FogeltheVogel•

That is indeed how thieves cant is intended.

It's basically job specific jargon for the Maffia (that's what our real life Thieves Cant is/was)

2
CognitiveBirch•

TC is more a mix of coded slang, cryptic signs and body language rather than a language per say. For example, talking about the weather with the right hand under your chin would mean you're a sword for ire, wearing a purple scarf on the left wrist = pursuing a target, etc. Characters can talk business using TC and it would sound like a genuine conversation to someone eavesdropping on them.

A PC who knows TC could also use sending and convey a crypted message only understandable by people with the same key codes. In 25 words or less it becomes a telegram that reads like gibberish when in fact: 1st word = key used to encrypt the rest of the message; 2nd word = ID of sender; then message in a sequence of words and numbers that will make sense once the receiver deciphers it.

Every day during a rest, the assassin may "go to pray" or say they do something that is agreed upon with the GM as the moment they use sending to make their report.

2
-orangejoe•

The caster needs to be familar with the recipient to use sending. With Thieves' Cant you can have people work together without ever even knowing who they are, which can be extremely useful for criminal enterprise (ex: how Keyzer Soze operates in The Usual Suspects).

I'd imagine they would still use scrying or sending because they're great spells for espionage, but different tools for different tasks.

1
Rushnik72OP•

That's a great point. It makes sense that everyone wouldn't know each other in the organization

1
Humanmale80•

Same reason they talk to each other at all instead using Sending for everything: it's easier.

Plus it may well be cultural as much as it is practical. A way to tell "the right people" from "the straights".

Plus security - anyone can use sending, but only those in the know can use cant.

1
matthew0001•

Something that wasn't mentioned already about thieves can't is that it comes across as a normal conversation. This can be super important as say an agent is being tailed or investigated and being watched closely. These conversations will appear completely normal to someone who isn't familiar with it. This might allow agents to get information without risking thier contact and may even make the investigator feel like they just have a normal life and it's a waste of time to keep following them.

1
mredding•

You have a problem, and that's magic. You're right, with magic, there's no need for using the thieves cant.

What makes dicy, secretive organizations fun and mysterious is just how they are visible to the players. There are agents, informants, spies, plants, fences, and all sorts of actors all around. Messages are passed along through a network. It's not fun, it's not interesting receiving a fantasy telephone call. What's fun for the player? How about they're sitting down to a pint at the tavern and they overhear a conversation THAT WAS MEANT TO BE OVERHEARD, and it's in the thieves cant?

Remember, the language is designed to hide the actual message in a plain message. It takes 4x as long to convey the same meaning as compared to just saying it plainly. Two guys are at the tavern talking about their exploits at the brothel. YES, THAT WAS MEANT TO GET THE PLAYERS ATTENTION. But hidden in this conversation only the player will know that he's being fed information.

Likewise, if the group wants an update, they've got a guy pedaling basic travel goods. Perhaps he's talking about how his mother had sewn these bags herself. He's not talking about the god damn bags, hidden inside is the request for information. You sort these sorts of things out, but this is where the player engages in some RP with the NPC that represents the update itself.

This is just so much more interesting and engaging than magic. It really reminds the players that he's in deep, and there are agents of the organization all around. You never know who, or what their role or task is. Is it just a messenger or is that a boss?

Another way to communicate is through the written cant. The rogue ought to make it a regular priority that when they enter civilization, there are places to start looking for information that will direct them to more specific bits. A small hamlet will likely just say who the regional lord is and who has good food and comfortable beds or free hay lofts. A bigger settlement is going to have more direction, more about the people, and random notes about the important locations. Often the rogue should make a quick trip "around the block" to check building corners and fences for marks. All this is a Gather Information roll, that the rogue should always end up knowing a little something about where he is when in civilization.

That said, there's a way of communicating. Imagine a rubbing on the trees along the trail. Again, only the thief would notice a smear on the tree as anything more. Or perhaps there are marks in the dirt of a common road that don't seem like much more than different draggings of a foot. The rogue can leave such messages as he walks out of a town, taking up the rear of the pack order, and leaving such a message for his handler who is pacing behind the party. There's an interesting opportunity to run into such people. There's also opportunity for a message to get partially stepped on, ran over, or washed out.

Powerful enough to afford phone calls, sure, but magic is still rare, still expensive, and who is this magic actor? A trusted member or a mere utility? How much are you going to rely on powerful spellcasters who might have ulterior motives? Maybe they want to be boss. There's reason enough to have the power but not use it all the time. If a boss is hiding in plain sight, having the power and money to use that much magic might draw attention.

OOH! There it is. The wizard is just the hired help. The boss is obscuring the message from him! He's sending something to someone about the local market or how that nearby siege is going on, when really he doesn't want the wizard to be suspicious. Still to dissuade suspicion magic probably shouldn't be used too often. This will imply a merchant or lord might be a crime boss hiding in plain sight.

I would stress that magic is supposed to be rare. It's certainly powerful. What can you do with it? Literally anything. That makes is extremely valuable. Now matter how plentiful it is, it's squandered making a mere pedestrian phone call. Those wizards and spell casters are all otherwise very busy and fetching a premium for their commissions doing other things - at least most of the time. So you want to ask a guy how he's doing? That's what the network is for. You want to murder the king and stage a coup? Probably send a message.

The cant over the phone call is still worthwhile - either something outright coded, or something to help obscure the fact that a message is being exchanged. Who might be eavesdropping?

1
comedianmasta•

Why is thieves cant used?

  • To write confusing or seemingly innocuous notes with hidden meaning or a secret message.
  • To mark locations or give coded directions to secret locations, hideouts, or targets.
  • To keep coded records.
  • To hide maps / messages / signs in plain sight without drawing suspicion.
  • As a means to identify yourself or a stranger as being "in the know" or "trustworthy".
  • Thieves Cant is accessible to non-magical folk and is not detected with "detect magic" and cannot be dispelled as it's a coded language, not illusionary or magically hidden. Also it cannot be deciphered with comprehend languages or any other magical spell similar as it's not a completely different language in and of itself, but the way languages are used and symbols that are given meaning by knowledge of the cant. This means it is an entire clandestine "language" kept from arcane eyes. In theory, only those "in the know" would recognize it, and these individuals are rarely "let go" recklessly enough to endanger the cant.
1