Empirical studies on efficacy/social value of modern policing?

Events of the last few years have led to me become, let's say, "increasingly skeptical" of the value of modern policing, especially relative to the huge amount of resources dedicated to it in countries like the US. I want to take a closer look at the hard evidence on questions around the efficacy of modern police (clearance rates for reported crimes, impact on overall crime rates, etc) as well as the social costs/benefits (opportunity cost of resources spent on policing, negative impacts of mass incarceration, etc).

Where should I start? A quick overview of the scholarly consensus (if there is one) would help, as would any specific articles that are worth reading or the names of scholars who write on any of these topics. Thanks!

Posted Jan 11, 2023, 5:03 PM UTC

146
john_the_fisherman•

The U.S. Department of Justice has a “what works” website for policy including crime where it rates policies as either effective, promising, or no effect. Each rating is typically backed by 1+ peer-reviewed sources

https://crimesolutions.ojp.gov/topics/crime-crime-prevention?ID=13

7
neur0•

Went down a rabbit hole recently and wanted to focus on a specific region given such as NYC since I thought this question had varying stats from area to area, but you're right the overall police budget has gone up across the nation according to the Bureau of Justice Statistics and there does not seem to be increase in overall public safety.

https://bjs.ojp.gov/library/publications/state-and-local-government-expenditures-police-protection-us-2000-2017#additional-details-0

Again, not really the whole picture you're looking for but the period leading up to, during, and after NYC's Stop and Frisk showing little success and ultimately ruled as unconstitutional is a good case study on the value of modern policing.

NYPD budget and revenue during that time period https://ibo.nyc.ny.us/RevenueSpending/nypd.html

Georgetown research on the impact to the community https://bridge.georgetown.edu/research/factsheet-nypd-stop-and-frisk-policy/

Columbia Law findings on actual crime from this policy http://www.stat.columbia.edu/~gelman/research/published/frisk9.pdf

Studies outside of NYPD and a look into the use of the above policy above stating the viability of this particular policy only if there's reform, focus on training, and selective training in Illnois

https://www.mdpi.com/2076-0760/10/6/230

3
ibluminatus•

Here's one on Police Violence against children and the impacts of police in schools original dataset and intended to lend more information to the 11 studies that discuss how police reduce kids education outcomes and even worse for low-income and Black kids who make up 86.9% of victims of School Police Violence from 2011-2021.

Report Available Here. #AssaultAt Police, Police Violence and School Aged Children

2
paceminterris•

This is not a scientific report. This was published by an advocacy group with a clear agenda in mind; not empirical fact-finding.

2
ibluminatus•

Acknowledged. While I think their methodology and the empirical research that inspired the report could be a pathway to someone to apply empirical research. The barrier to this at present is that there doesn't exist a federal dataset of instances of Police Violence against children in schools nor a recording mechanism for instances of violence involving police in schools. The Federal Civil Rights Data Collection Center has no requirement on educational facilities to report on Police Use of Force Against students. The lack of a federal dataset for these issues similar to the voluntary only reporting for the Federal Use of Force Database. The issue is under-recorded and under-researched alongside there being no route to study this empirically as there is no data-collection whether that it is for reasons of bias, politics or a simple data-gap.

​

Empirical Studies on the role of police and police violence in schools:

The Thin Blue Line in Schools: New Evidence on School-Based Policing Across the U.S. (Notes racial disparities in Police Treatment of Children and school discipline)

Students Police and the school to prison pipeline.

Testing the School to Prison Pipeline

School Resource Officers and Exclusionary Discipline in U.S. High Schools: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis

​

Patrolling Public Schools: The Impact of Funding for School Police on Student Discipline and Long-term Education Outcomes

Police in schools and student arrest rates across the United States: Examining differences by race, ethnicity, and gender

2
AutoModeratorMOD•

Thanks for your question to r/AskSocialScience. All posters, please remember that this subreddit requires peer-reviewed, cited sources (Please see Rule 1 and 3). All posts that do not have citations will be removed by AutoMod.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1