[General] Gem choices are one-dimensional at this point in the game. What changes would you like to see?

Armor pieces > Primary stat or vitality.

Helm > Ruby or vitality, some people use topaz.

Weapon > Probably 90% of players use emeralds.

I would like to see more meaningful choices for what you can put in a socket. The armor pieces make more sense because each class uses a different color gem, but for helms and weapons the unique bonuses are really lackluster.

Here is what I would like to see changed:

Weapons

-Emeralds are fine, I think they are the best current choice for most players, and they should stay at their current level of power.

-Amethyst: I would like to see these receive a buff to 900 or 1000 life on hit. My reasoning for this is the fact that you can roll up to 100% CD on a weapon as well as gem for 100% CD. LOH on weapons I have seen up in the high 900's for rolls, why does the gem counterpart fall so far behind?

-Topaz: Thorns? Really? Maybe changing them to an attack speed bonus would be more fitting/useful. There are 14 gem levels in the current game, would a 1-14% attack speed bonus be too much to ask for?

-Ruby: Comparing 30 average weapon damage to 100% critical damage it is pretty easy to see which would give you the most bang for your buck. I would like to see rubies either give a bonus % to your base weapon damage OR to the weapons DPS. A straight buff to +weapon damage would result in people running around with 200 dps level 5 socketed daggers or something ridiculous.

I'm not really sure what I would change about the gem bonuses for helms, I have to give it some more thought. The amethyst bonus is great, while emeralds are pretty useless. Rubies and topazes have a limited shelf life due to paragon levels now, and I feel that they should receive some sort of stat bonus that could be used permanently. Maybe buffing NV stacks to 20% per and changing topazes to give all resist would be something. Emeralds could give dodge or armor or maybe even move speed.

Thoughts? Suggestions? Criticisms? Please share!

Posted Sep 21, 2012, 10:32 PM UTC · edited

1011
alienangel2Americas•

I always thought they should have prismatic gems (made by combining one of each of the base colors), which give you Resist All when socketed. It's weird having to rely purely on gear to give you RA, when chests/legs for instance have 3 sockets and are fine if they have RA + one of Vitality or a primary stat, but nearly worthless if they just have Vitality+Stat but no resists. Being able to socket 3 prismatics in there for 30 Resist All each would make gearing better, and open up more decisions. Do you want to stack DPS in your gems? Resists? Vitality?

They'd have levels just like other gems, so making the 10 RA gems would be cheap, making the 40 RA gems would cost millions.

Similarly, armor gems would be nice too.

10
impostaOP•

But then you have the issue of RA vs armor being more valuable under certain circumstances. A character with 1200 RA and 4k armor would get MUCH more benefit out of a gem that gives 400 armor, which is what 40 RA is equivalent to. On that note I would like to see a new gem introduced to fill that role, say diamond for example, that could give a bonus to RA as well as armor.

ie: A max level diamond gives 31 RA and 310 armor for a slot, and some % based value to both for helms. Weapons are a different matter entirely though, maybe some kind of debuff applied to enemies you hit?

1
alienangel2Americas•

I don't see how this is a problem, so long as you have gems that give only RA and gems that give only armor - keeping track of how much of each you have and balancing them is fun for the people that care that much.

If you don't have gems for both and only add the RA gems I described, it's not as interesting, but still better than what we have no (no pure mitigation gems).

1
PergatoryAmericas•

The weapon/helm mods are fine, it's the other slots where the options are lacking. You either pick your primary, or vitality. That's it. There is no other choice.

I'd like to see rare/legendary gems that give the following in any slot:

Crit Chance +

Life Per Second +

Resist All +

Melee/Ranged/Elite Damage -

Max Resource (Mana/Discipline/Fury/AP) +

These special gems don't even need to be upgradeable, necessarily, they could just have a fixed size.

3
impostaOP•

Yea but at least there is equal demand for the different color gems in armor slots because different classes have different primary stats. Emeralds are expensive because they are far and away the best gem for a weapon for 95% of classes/builds. Rubies giving xp bonus to helm makes them extremely valuable right now, while topaz is generally not used for either slot at this point in the game.

2
alehar•

And once used in an item, you can remove them but don't get them back.

0
SolomonGrumpy•

More gems.
Sapphire: Armor - life regeneration, offhand or Helm - resource regeneration, Weapon - skill cost reduction Diamonds: Armor - All resist, offhand - crit chance, Helm - ? , Weapon - bleed

2
Ozy-dead•
  • Some gem needs to be resist all in helm. I'd say emerald should be it (iirc it's currently GF)

  • Topaz - give IAS in weapons

  • Ruby - give % raw damage boost (easier to balance than flat min-max numbers).

Also, more colors. Sapphires, Diamonds - all with unique bonuses in slots.

2
ABaldWookkee•

I would love to see more colours. Some different stats other than a base stat when put in armour pieces (all resist, crit chance, maybe even thorns)

1
triangleman83•

I would like to see some way of obtaining them without having to spend millions on the auction house.

1
MyNameIsX•

Runes. That is all.

-3