r/cfs•
brainwise

Question on consistent exercise for long-term CFS sufferers

Hi, I am new to this subreddit and want to ask a question to those who have had cfs for a long time and their exercise habits. I am 43 and had cfs since I was 15 (yep, that's nearly 30 years....) and while I have learnt to manage my condition quite well over the years I haven't been able to get a exercise habit going consistently.

I find that when I am 'well' (the periods of time when I really have energy and am able to live my life mostly normally, with careful management) I can do regular exercise (nothing really strenuous), however, when I am in a 'low' phase I can't do any additional effort (other than work and sleep) so my exercise habit goes out the window.

Now that I am older and gaining weight faster than I like, I would really love to be able to exercise regularily, but I can't seem to keep to any routine.

Any hints/ideas fellow cfs people?

Posted Sep 22, 2012, 1:55 AM UTC

511
OortCloud•

Same story for me (age 54, 8 year sufferer). When I have some energy I prefer to get in some cycling or whatever will get my heart-rate up. When I'm down I'd like to exercize but I've learned that forcing myself despite what my body says causes more harm than good.

I've had problems with weight too. When I first got sick I ballooned up 20 lbs. That disappeared but I still have swings where I gain or drop 5-10 lbs over a period of a few days only to return to normal. All this despite no changes in diet. I've found that most of what goes on re symptoms runs counter-intuitively to what I should expect given diet and activity level.

3
gorpie97•

Aerobic exercise is baaaaad for people with CFS - it's actually anaerobic and so your cells are starved for oxygen.

There are "safe" ways to do it - this is one explanation.

3
OortCloud•

Winter is setting in, the page you provided is saved under my CFS reading resources; time to try something new.

2
throwawayCFS•

Just read that page. It's written by someone who has no idea what aerobic and anaerobic means. I wouldn't use that page as a basis for anything, sorry. That's not a statement about the scientist mentioned, that's a different matter.

1
gorpie97•

I'll find a better source.

The CFIDS Association has published about analeptic exercise for years. I didn't really look into it, rather than exercise for 30 seconds and rest for 1 minute, rinse and repeat, I just avoided aerobic exercise (well, I avoided any exercise for a long time, aside from walking short distances).

1
gorpie97•

This is old (2004), and the other links I clicked just referenced this. The CFIDS Chronicle included similar information prior to 2004.

1
Kromulent•

[Sorry for the delay in posting, it got caught up in the spam filter for a while].

The best description I've heard for how this works is that we can exercise at a 'sustainable' level, with 'sustainable' defined as 'not having down days anymore'. If you are still on the good day/bad day cycle, it probably means that you are overdoing it when you feel well.

In practice, I've found I'll have good days and bad days no matter what my level of activity is, and furthermore, an especially low level of activity seems to actually make things worse. I also believe that the illness has a cryptic rhythm of its own, and tends to slap us around a bit for it's own schedule, no matter what we do.

That said, it's still really crucial to avoid overexertion. This always has to be the first rule, it's just that it can be a tricky rule to apply correctly.

I've had the best luck by maintaining a low, consistent level of activity. I have dogs that need attention, and that means walks. I walk them around the yard, a few hundred meters at a time, three times a day. Some days the walk is slower, some days the walk gets cut short, but I do it every day, for their sake as well as my own.

The key here is that I'm not really pushing myself. These walks are comfortably within my capability most of the time. If they were a little more strenuous, they would be poison and they would be making everything worse. It's a fine balance. I will admit that if it were not for those pleading eyes, I'd be doing it a lot less consistently.

Sadly, this level of activity, while arguably good for my health, is essentially useless with regards to weigh control. I'm afraid we are stuck with the unpleasant prospect of managing our weight strictly by limiting intake, which is hard for anyone. I think we are all chubby, it just comes with the territory after a while.

I wonder sometimes how much effort I should put into weight control. Simply being overweight (as opposed to being seriously obese) is not nearly as bad for your health as was once believed. For most people, that extra 20 pounds might make you look bad, but it causes no real harm. I alternate between trying to deal with it, and deciding I have bigger problems to focus on. I think it's just going to be a constant, nagging problem for almost all of us.

Maybe we ought to put our effort into becoming really skilled at making low calorie food that tastes good. I'm lousy at this.

2
dbt4949•

I've been sick for six years. I've gotten progressively worse and have never exercised. I use days I'm feeling less like death to do chores or run errands. I've lost weight since getting sick but eating worse and worse. Lately I've noticed I don't feel like eating or I'm too tired to eat and I've gone as long as two days without eating anything and just drinking water.

2
gorpie97•

I only started exercising 2 years ago, and after a couple months saw a trainer to make sure I was hitting all the major muscles I could. I told her that I needed exercises I could do at home, and that it needed to take no more than 20 minutes.

So I now have a set routine (10 reps and 3 pound weights). There are some days I'd rather not exercise, but I do anyway since I may feel worse tomorrow. On days when it seems hard to do, I just go more slowly. I've also decided that doing fewer reps (if needed) will be better than not doing anything.

But that's what works for me - you may need to think of other things that work for you.

EDIT: I started at 6 reps and worked my way up when I felt like I could.

2
Astro_nauts_mum•

One of the CFS challenges (for me, but everyone else too probably!) is what can you plan - and what can't you plan?

I can plan exercise: I plan it to be non aerobic, mostly lying down, stretching all different parts of my body, can be done at home, doesn't cost, and a type that I can easily moderate to suit how I am on the day. Hooray I found some yoga dvds that suit all these requirements.

I can plan my life to fit in that exercise: ie I mustn't be doing too much that would lead me to not have enough energy, or to have got so sick, that I can't do my yoga. This is very difficult but I keep getting better at it. It is a good plan, just hard to bring about.

They are like the micro plan and the macro plan.

But the other half of it is the balancing act. I have to gauge each day whether I am well enough for my yoga, how much to do and how much to moderate. If I get it right, my quality of life and level of health go up, if I get it wrong they go down.

I can plan a little. I know to do it every second day, rather than every day, unless I am very sure of myself. I know to start slowly and increase slowly with small increments. I know to listen to my heartbeat and slow or stop if it is beating fast.

I am constantly on a journey towards better fitness, but it isn't like the exercise plan a healthy person would have: it is an intricate, tricky balancing act that involves all my skill and insight. Planning is just one part of it. Will power has nothing to do with it, being responsive and flexible around what my body is telling me is the key.

I also want to add about putting on weight. I have had a horrid decade putting on so much weight: as if CFS isn't hard enough without carrying around extra kilos. I finally figured out that sugar was stuffing me up badly: best information here. Sugar is part sucrose (sending messages to brain that I was hungry when I wasn't), and part fructose (that liver converts to fat). Because I have to be so inactive my body was prey to those unhealthy consequences. Cutting out sugar has been hard, but what a relief to see those kilos drop off, and life is so much easier! Ask me more about this if you like!

Good luck and best wishes

1
brainwiseOP•

Thanks everyone for your comments, they have been helpful. In the past two weeks I have limited my food intake strictly (within correct calories) and are starting to feel like that may lead to weight loss if I keep it up as everyday habits. I have cut down on sugar but think I need to really make a go at losing it altogether from my diet. I also think yoga and weight training is the way to go for me, it doesn't require cardio fitness and it creates muscle mass. In regards to micro and macro plans, I think it sounds like a good idea. Thanks Everyone!

1