What I Think WotC missed with the OGL thing: Content Creators.

Discussion

It's kind of been covered to death but there's this attitude Wizards figured they could get away with this because no one would take them to court and they'd have enough people who are ride or die for them. And wizard calculated that those ride or die people would be big content creators who focus on D&D.

So many content creators ran million dollar kickstarters for 5E supplements of the back of their own clout and D&Ds. These "Brand ambassadors" (free advertising) WotC thought they had all under control actually as it turns out all have a HUGE vested interest in keeping the ogl as it is.

Ginny Di has been an absolute badass during this whole situation, going from the person who wizards asked to help announce one D&D to posting her canceled DDB subscription and urging her fanbase to follow. Mad respect!

And I think that's going to play a huge part in this not going away in 3 months. The general public might forget about the Fiasco but the content creators whose livelihoods were threatened and were put in the crosshairs of a Draconian policy are not going to. They're going to move to other games.

I hate the term "Influencer" - but this is a good reminder that that word actually might mean something sometimes.

Posted Jan 14, 2023, 12:59 AM UTC

9221
MiraclezMatter•

I mean, most of the content creators in the TTRPG space are incredibly reliant on D&D content in order to be any semblance of successful, and there’s a myriad of metrics to back it up. People were legitimately far less interested in content by these creators if it wasn’t about D&D. Undertaking this boycott is a huge risk for a bunch of these creators because their livelihoods are at stake here.

49
Cat_Wizard_21•

There is historical precedent for creators in the D&D ecosystem to break away and take sustainable fanbases with them. Paizo originally made products for 3.5, but when the 4e shitshow happened they just split entirely and made their own 3.5 with blackjack and hookers.

If someone like Kobold Press, the Dungeon Dudes, MCDM, or Critical Role announced a proprietary non-D&D game system right now they'd have more preorders than they knew what to do with.

Heck, Paizo's official rules wiki is currently borderline inaccessable due to the massive interest spike blowing up their servers.

The idea that the D&D ecosystem is strong enough right now to hold people captive is pure illusion. We'll see at least one 3PP become the second Paizo before this mess is over, maybe more than one.

21
JLthekingDM•

Well, MCDM and Kobold Press did exactly that ;)

3
herdsheep•

It will be a shift in the ecosystem. With 5e we had one mega company (Wizards of the Coast) and hundreds of 3rd party publishers.

With the system splintering, the biggest 3rd party publishers will sustain their own systems, but those systems won't sustain additional 3rd party publishers (any more than Pathfinder 2e does now; there's some, but most still published for 5e in addition to make that viable).

So what we'll end up with is one greatly weakened mega company (Wizards of the Coast), and maybe half a dozen independent games stewarded by the largest 3rd parties, but none will have the vibrant ecosystem of 3rd party content 5e did.

It's not a directly worse thing. Some people will prefer the choice of game over the choice of content within that game. But it's also not a directly a good thing. A lot of people aren't going to want to relearn the rules every few months to hop between the new games, and I think we'll see a combination of an explosion of new systems while having a contraction of players, meaning that it'll be a somewhat smaller pie that's getting divided.

In the end, it's a big risk for the biggest 3rd parties as they strike out on their own, but it's also a big die off of the midrange publishers as there won't be any ecosystem to work off. 5e was uniquely suited to be that being enormously popular, relatively modular, and somewhat underserved by official 1st party content. Even if was an audience for PF2e content, you're much more directly competing with the 1st party that cranks out a great deal of content their own system there, combined with a more specific play style, there's a lot less room for 3rd parties and a lot smaller a pie.

It's complicated. We'll see some 3rd parties grow and a lot die.

2
Cat_Wizard_21•

I think Critical Role is going to be the X factor. If campaign 4 starts with the big unveiling of a new system, whether it's developed by Darrington Press or just an existing D&D alternative, that game will explode in popularity, maybe enough to sustain an ecosystem.

Whether us D&D grognards like it or not, Mercer is basically the pope of the new generation of ttrpg players. Brand loyalty for many people onboarded in 5e rests with CR more than it does WotC or even D&D as a brand.

3
DBSTKjSDM•

And inversely, D&D only has that reputation because of the OGL and how it has allowed 3rd party content creators to make what they do. You take that away, and you get 4e and the rise of competitors like pathfinder. You reintroduce it, and you get 5e. DnD is not the haven of 3P content because it's D&D, it's because of the OGL.

8
Th1nker26•

True, although if you look historically at successful youtubers, many of them change branding over time. I'm sure (for example) XP to level 3 will be fine making jokes about anything nerdy. Though more hardcore DnD channels might suffer.

8
thenightgauntDM•

Originally yes. But once you have a follower who's interested in your content, it becomes less about the brand of content they were talking about, and more about following the Influencer because you like their content.

That's how someone becomes an "influencer". They talk about content people want to hear about to initially bring in the viewers, then when the viewers get attached to watching that creator, they can then steer the conversation away from that original content and to something else.

4
Im_awesome_AMA•

It is symbiotic though.

1
herdsheep•

Undertaking this boycott is a huge risk for a bunch of these creators because their livelihoods are at stake here.

This is the mistake of the OGL 1.1. Their livelihoods were put at risk either way. Most content creators are dependent on 5e, but the OGL 1.1 made it so they couldn't survive off 5e. It backed them into a corner and convinced them to go for maximum revolt.

This is still a somber hour though. While a lot of people are applauding the sudden interest in diversifying the industry, the fall of 5e will be the end of the road for a lot of content creators. No other system can support even a fraction of the ecosystem 5e has, and other systems simply have different (and less) demands for content.

0
NerdBigEnergy•

Mad respect for Ginny Di.

38
marsgreekgod•

I think they saw those and assumed people would spend all that money on them if they stopped them making content

5
sinofonin•

I spend more time watching 3rd party D&D content like CR or Dungeon Dudes than playing the game. It fuels my interest and means I end up buying more books. They are basically free advertising for D&D.

Clearly management at WotC or Hasbro don’t get it.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

0

The OGL doesn't cover kickstarters, patreons, actual plays, etc, though?

-2
Drasha1•

It can. Anything someone publishes that they choose to put the ogl on is covered.

2

The OGL specifically states what it covers. Not my fault you haven't read it.

-2
Drasha1•

Can you provide a quote from the OGL? I have in fact read the 1.0(a) OGL and do not recall anything that would make it not apply to content on kickstarter or patreon.

2
bertraja•

Ginny Di is a social media person first and foremost, i wouldn't put them on a pedestal of moral superiority. After publicly cancelling their DDB subscription, it's "well, let's wait and see" now, and refers to the "actual, final terms of the OGL" that "will matter to content creators". It's what social media people do, get a good understanding of the mood of the hour and act accordingly.

-9
BlueScatterShieldOP•

I wasn't putting them on a pedestal though? I was respecting a person who put principles over career advancement. she actually probably had more to gain bootlicking for WotC; but didn't.

10
bertraja•

put principles over career advancement

And that was, more or less, my point. Their career is in TTRPG based social media. By amplifying the outrage, and later by advocating for moderation they advance their influencer career. It's less principles, it's more reading the room, continuosly.

-8