Can I post an anonymous thinkpiece about The Whale here?
The Whale total spoilers ahead
I liked this movie a lot. I like all of Darren Aronofsky’s movies a lot. I am not fat and I never have been. But I have my own eating disorders that have had to be addressed and monitored by doctors and nutritionists and it’s a constant struggle and an always on my mind thing. My obsession with food is different than binge eater’s but I feel a great deal of sympathy towards anyone with food issues.
I like the show my 600 lb life. And I guess one question I have would be, Is that show fat-phobic? Maybe it is and maybe so is this film. I’m not the one to say so. But I like to watch that show because I can relate with a lot of the people who appear on it. I don’t feel that the show is ONLY about fat people becoming skinnier. I feel it’s more often about inactive people becoming more active and eating healthier. Often on that show the people featured will say they feel depressed and want to change. I have felt the same way. And eating healthier and becoming more active has helped me to cope with some of my own depression.
I feel like Charlie’s eating disorder is handled in a pretty nuanced and interesting way. He’s a guy who has always been big and who has always liked food. The movie says this plainly but I’m just going to repeat it. Charlie’s partner Alan died from suicide. Before he died Charlie, who is a cooking hobbyist, would cook for his partner who was starving himself because of his own depression. Charlie tried to cure Alan’s depression with food and it didn’t work. He doesn’t realize that that didn’t work and he tries to cure his own grief and depression in a similar way.
I know not every overweight person has a sob story about why they are. But the character in the whale does and often this featured on my 600 lb life will to. Maybe that’s part of the problem for some people.
But for me the thing that I really connected with in this film was Charlie’s attitude in spite of his destructive behavior. I’ve been accused of being annoyingly positive just like Charlie is in this movie. Even when I’m overindulging in all my worst habits I still rarely say anything bad about anyone or anything but me. The Whale made me feel seen in that way. I feel this movie is less about fat guy being miserable that he’s fat and more about a person who wants the best for and sees the best in others but can’t do the same for himself. A feeling I don’t think is exclusive to overweight people.
But this movie is what it is. It is about a fat guy being sad but it’s also more complex than that. Aronofsky is oft-criticized for his movies being obvious and hardly metaphorical. mother! Is pure metaphor but also really really obvious in its metaphor. I’ve never personally had a problem with the obviousness but I get it if that’s not what you like.
Also I think the ambiguousness of Ellie’s personality is really interesting and really the point of this movie. Charlie says over and over how amazing and incredible she is but we never see her be that way. But I think the movie wants you to at least entertain Charlie’s idea. It also wants you to doubt it.
How many times have you been kind towards someone who might not deserve it while being unkind to yourself. Seeing the best in others and only the worst in yourself. It’s a curse that some of us depressive people pleasers have and it can be really dangerous.
So similar to my 600 lb life I found this movie to not be about an overweight guy who wishes he wasn’t but a movie about a depressed guy who wishes nobody else is. It’s about someone who can’t help himself. And I think that’s a message a lot of people can hear and understand.
Anyway I just saw a movie I liked by a director I like and I feel odd that my positive reaction towards this film might be considered hateful. I hope someone might wanna talk abt it. The good or the bad of it. Let me know what you thought about the film and what you think about my thoughts. Thanks for reading.
Posted Jan 16, 2023, 7:27 AM UTC
Honestly, I just found the whole experience frustrating. I can see why the play and the movie have very mixed reactions, especially when it comes to Charlie's views on his daughter.
It would've been better to make Ellie a fully-rounded character, but instead all we see is a hateful, resentful, borderline sociopathic brat who is absolutely NOT a good person. Therefore, Charlie's insistence on his daughter being a good person comes off as annoying, self-deluded and pathetic.
It completely ruins what could've been a heart-warming tragedy.
Hi I don’t mean to be a total hater and I don’t think all ur takes are stupid or wack. I thought they were interesting and so I shared your response here with my sister who saw the movie with me and also liked it.
Her response was that this is a very sexist take. That claiming Charlie is delusional for loving his daughter might be rooted in a discomfort one might have in seeing a man be emotional and expressing feelings of love.
And that claiming a teenage girl is two dimensional for being angsty and hateful is also sexist. That girls don’t need to be nice to be complete.
Could you admit that there is any truth to this? I don’t think you’re wrong or that she is but I thought she had an interesting and different response to you than I did.
Tell your sister that her "sexist" argument is nothing but a sorry strawman approach.
There is nothing sexist about this. I'm saying that the issue with the story is that Charlie believes his daughter to be a good person who's forgotten how good she is and we never see any hint of that goodness in his daughter's character. So instead of coming off as heartwarming, his belief in her "goodness" comes off as deluded and pathetic. Charlie never seems to acknowledge his daughter's terrible behavior, so how are we supposed to believe in what he sees? And what's his source for believing that his daughter is a good person? An essay she wrote as a little kid? PLEASE.
So, no. There is absolutely no truth to what your sister wanted to say.
An essay she wrote as a kid and the captions on her social media posts and her accidental haiku. Plus all the things we can assume he saw in her while he was in her life. Its not a lot but it is something. It’s not a straw man. She just noticed that your only stated desire of these characters was for Charlie to be more rational (stereotypically masculine) and for Ellie to be nicer (more stereotypically feminine)
I don’t think any or every criticism against this movie is necessarily sexist and I get it’s not fun to hear that word. But I agree with her that characters ought not be more stereotypically perfect for their story to be worth telling.
I don’t want you to like this movie or think any more about it than you want to.
I deeply appreciate your respectfulness, but it doesn't change the fact that the sexist argument is a strawman. What I posted has nothing to do with gender roles. It's all about how badly written the characters are.
Interesting. I had a similar feeling when she was first introduced. I thought, “wow this is a pretty unflattering and uninteresting role for this young actress. just to play a teenage bitch.” How would you have made her more well rounded? Would the story have worked better for you if there were scenes of her being kind to the pizza guy or something like that? I think what made her character well rounded was her father’s view of her. And her mother’s. I never acted just like she does but I wasn’t a happy teen either.
I didn’t think it made Charlie seem delusional that he could see the best in his daughter. It made him feel real. I’ve met bullies and people who are never anything but unkind to me. But I know that other people love them and probably not for no good reason. I liked that Charlie could see the best in her even though it was hard to.
Even writing this response now I’m thinking, “wait but didn’t she maybe kill that bird? Wtf!” But still I don’t think Charlie having patience and affection towards her made him feel pathetic or delusional. To me it made him feel like he was capable of love that’s hard. An admirable trait and not a pathetic one.
Thanks for your response. Too bad you couldn’t dig the flick.
It's funny. The entire time through The Whale, I kept thinking about Aronofsky's other movie, The Wrestler. They're insanely similar.
The Wrestler makes the smart decision of showing that the daughter character isn't a bad person. She's troubled, sure, but she's trying to do her best despite the trauma of being abandoned by her father and then having him try to come back in her life.
The Whale doesn't do that. If I had adapted the script, I would added enough to the daughter character to show that, deep down, Charlie is right about her. But that's not what we got. What we got was a mean-spirited brat with no redeeming qualities whatsoever. And we're supposed to believe Charlie when he says that she's a good person? And why, because of an essay she wrote when she was a kid? It's like when a high schooler thinks his crush likes him just because she sat next to him in class. It's sad and pathetic.
I noticed the wrestler similarities too. Would you have found this daughter character better if she was in a relationship or was going to school? Those are the things you are referring to about the wrestler daughter trying her best, right? Those things make her different from the daughter in the whale. Can you say what kind of scene you might’ve included or what attributes you might’ve given the character in the whale to show what she’s like deep down?
I kinda don’t think we’re supposed to know for sure what she’s like deep down. But if that’s what you were looking for I’m curious what type of scene could’ve been included to satisfy that want from you. Would it have made the point that she’s good deep down if she was a good student and had a gf?
No, a relationship and going to school is just surface stuff. I'm talking about the actual character. I would've changed a lot. For instance, instead of her possibly killing a bird, I'd have her find a bird with a six-pack plastic holder on its neck and help it out of it. Kindness towards animals may be cliche, but it's a solid way of showing a character's good side.
I also would've shown that although she resents her father, I'd have made it clear that part of her DID want to reconcile with him. The ambiguity in the film was completely to the movie's detriment. I felt nothing from the daughter character except cruelty. It was awful.