Phantom chlorine

Help/Advice

Sorry if this is a little long winded:

I've been losing my mind for the last week trying to chase this down. My 10g tank has been "cycling" for a month. It's heavily planted with a deep substrate. It's got a nice heavy algae bloom going on and my new neocaridina are diligently nibbling on the slime. I noticed the other day that my test strips were triggering for chlorine, which made no sense. The water I used to establish the tank was fully free of chlorine, and the water changes have been done with chlorine free water as well. The only thing that ever touched chlorine was some of the gravel in the substrate and the driftwood, which was previously soaked in tap water. So when I set up the tank I dosed with Seachem Prime, and everything was just fine for 3+ weeks.

So all of a sudden the test strips are turning green and I panic, so I dose with Prime again and in 10 minutes the strips are more yellow. The problem is that there is so much algae in the tank that it almost feels like the chlorine strips are "stained". So I google this, and turns out a lot of people suspect that diatoms react with the chlorine strip. So I think "great I'm in the clear."

The next day I break out my Hanna chlorine checker and the instant the potassium iodine hits the water I see pink - don't even need the checker to tell me that there is significant chlorine. So while the test strips may be getting "stained" or whatever by diatoms or algae in the water, they are definitely not leading me astray (unless the Hanna checker is similarly fooled by those??)

And this is how it's gone for the last week. I test, see chlorine, dose, test, go to sleep, and wake up to new chlorine.

Does it make any sense that the driftwood or the gravel could still "leach" chlorine after weeks of repeated exposure to Prime? Everything I've read suggests that this is highly unlikely. I really REALLY don't want to break this tank down. Should I just keep doing this dance until it stops? Is there any risk to the fauna in the tank by getting exposed to the dechlorinator? Has anyone else ever fought an ongoing battle against mystery chlorine?

I feel like I'm taking crazy pills.

Posted Jan 18, 2023, 12:22 AM UTC

22
No-Confusion-9990•

I’ve had the exact same problem in one of my tanks before. I also had a deep sand substrate (way too deep like 6 inches) And no matter how much de chlorinator I used it would never go away. I called my LFS and told them about my situation and they told me to stir the substrate. After that the chlorine went away in a couple days. I think you just may have faulty chlorine tests though because if there was actually chlorine in the water it would kill the plants and shrimp

1
bconstantOP•

That's interesting, do you have a theory as to why stirring up the substrate would have helped?

1