Who is the greatest female athlete of all time? The GOAT of all sports?
Posted Jan 20, 2023, 11:50 PM UTC
Posted Jan 20, 2023, 11:50 PM UTC
My vote goes to Steffi Graf (tennis). I don’t believe there has ever been a more dominant female athlete in any sport. She single-handedly holds the vast majority of the biggest records in tennis and is the only player, male or female to win the Golden Calendar Slam, which has to be one of the greatest sporting achievements in history.
Serena Williams
Steffi Graf and Martina Navratilova would like to have a word, lol.
Serena is definitely top 5, but not the greatest.
Serena isn’t the greatest in tennis/ her own sport, so that pretty much disqualifies her from this debate.
In what way is she not the greatest female tennis player of all time?
I’m not arguing, I’m actually curious as to the argument against her being that
Quite simple. Compare her to Steffi Graf who is widely considered the GOAT of tennis outside of the United States (American media is heavily biased).
Weeks at #1: Steffi (377), Serena (319) Years as #1: Steffi (8), Serena (5) Titles: Steffi (107), Serena (73) Career win %: Steffi (89%), Serena (84%) Tier I titles: Steffi (26), Serena (23) Record against top 10 players: Steffi (79%), Serena (71%)
In addition to this, Steffi won the Golden Calendar Slam in 1988, which is the greatest achievement in all of tennis. She also had a considerably higher peak than Serena and was way more dominant and consistent throughout her career. She had 10 years with a 90% win rate, while Serena only had 5 such years. She had 5 years with 3 or more Slam titles, while Serena only had 2 such years.
The only thing Serena has over Steffi is ONE more Slam (23 compared to 22), but Serena played for 11 more years than Steffi. It took Steffi 12 years to achieve what Serena achieved in 23 years. And even then Steffi still beats her in pretty much every department.
Serena’s stats also don’t hold up well at all compared to other all time greats such as Court, Navratilova and Evert. Serena is definitely an all time great too, but realistically she is somewhere around #3 to #5 of all time, definitely not #1.
Ok, so first of all I’m British, so I’m not influenced by a biased US media (instead I’m being told somehow Andy Murray is the greatest male tennis player ever… no idea the logic behind that)
The issue with comparing stats between eras is you can’t affect for competition.
For example, Usain Bolt is the greatest sprinter of all time currently, in 50 years his times will be beaten and he would potentially not even qualify for the finals.
The same applies to all sports, with better training, playing conditions, coaching starting earlier, more investment etc the level of competition in every sport in the world is getting higher, so I’m taking nothing away from any of the women you listed, they were all incredible, talented and dominant in their eras.
But Serena’s record, in the most competitive era of women’s tennis so far, is absolutely astonishing.
You can look at the same exact logic at any other sport- Pele in football was great against defenders who would smoke cigarettes at half time and drink every night…
Wilt Chamberlain in basketball played against players who often had a main job, and played professional basketball for extra money on the side, and the love of the sport.
Even in chess we’re seeing players emerge now who would obliterate the former greatest of all times, because they can watch them as they grow up and learn and innovate and build ontop of their innovations.
So in essence, almost every top level athlete today is superior to almost every top athlete from a previous generation, because you develop learning everything they did, and have to compete against other people who have learned everything they did.
So you in essence, have to be able to beat Graff’s game today, in order to win titles, or you’d lose to the most accurate copycat
Babe Didrikson Zaharias
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Babe_Didrikson_Zaharias
[deleted]
Bruce Jenner
Simone biles
Tom Brady
Has to be Serena W, right?
Can’t be Serena when she’s not even the greatest in her own sport. Graf, Navratilova and Court all won more than Serena and had a higher peak and were more consistent.
My vote goes to Graf as both the tennis GOAT and the greatest female athlete of all time.
Fair enough. Don’t watch woman sports so that’s the first name that came to mind and I’ve never heard of Graf before. Just looked her up, she definitely was a beast.
But I would ask, was womens tennis more or less competitive in the 70s -80s or in this day and age??
I would say Serena probably had a lot more competition. But this is the problem with picking “the best ever” when it runs across different eras. Same problem with Jordan vs Lebron, or Pele vs Messi, etc.
Tennis is more competitive now at the lower level, but Graf for example is only 11 years older than Serena so it’s not like they were worlds apart. Graf dominated the strongest era and had elite competition in Navratilova, Evert and Seles, while Serena never played against all time greats.
Also, it took Graf 12 years to achieve what Serena did in 23 and she was more dominant and more consistent than Serena.
Serena will always have a place among the all time greats, but now that her career has ended, she is realistically #3-#5 of all time.
I see. Thanks for the insight :)