Elden Ring Cosmology and Gnosticism

Spoiler

Introduction

I was recently reading replies to another post about the Outer Gods, and after doing that I saw a TikTok video that introduced me to a collection of religious ideas that I hadn't heard of before. Gnosticism. Which turns out is very historied and controversial ideology with a large amount of "denominations" I could possibly account for, but there were a lot of core concepts within it that made me immediately think of Elden Ring's vast and confusing framework of Outer Gods, Gods, gods, mortals that become gods, the way mortality in general is handled, and the whole cosmology in general. Furthermore, after seeing all the connections with Christianity in the game, and Leyndell/Marika specifically, I felt compelled to share my novice—surface level—research into this religious ideology and the similarities I saw in Elden Ring. If you have some time, just google image the term and look at some of the artwork and think about Elden Ring, it's map, and even it's time of day UI. I won't link any images here that aren't in the Wiki, because I don't want to accidentally post copyrighted art. But it's just a click away if you'd like. So..

Here is my mostly ignorant recap of things in Gnosticism that made me immediately think of Elden Ring and how they could help inform our understandings of the The Elden Ring itself, the Outer Gods, Empyreans, and the cosmology of Elden Ring in general. After just a couple hours of surface level research on wikipedia, since I didn't find other sources that seemed scholarly and easily digestible in a short time. If someone knows of scholarly supported books or talks on this, I'm wildly interested. Please comment of DM me them. I love historical and critical study of religious texts and history. I'm 100% a hobbyist of consuming that material. Which is how I stumbled into writing this mini essay.

​

The Hook

What first struck me are the superficial similarities between the Elden Ring and Imagery related to the Plemora and Sophia (They will have their own sections). While the artwork on the initial video I saw was much more interesting to look at, the more grounded examples from wikipedia still elicited enough similarity for me to keep digging:

​

The Elden Ring

​

The \"Primordial\" Elden Ring

A Mystical Depiction of Sophia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sophia_%28Gnosticism%29#/media/File:SophiaMystical.jpg

​

Depiction of the Plemora

There are more artistic renditions of these concepts, feel free to google them, I just didn't want to accidentally bring in someone's Original Artwork. Lots of it resonates very well with Elden Ring. The images were just superficially reminiscent, but this is where I started so I figured it's how I'd introduce the concept. After doing a bit of digging, I now feel a lot more confident that, while not a one-to-one perfect match, I believe the concepts I found will help inform what is happening with the greater cosmology of Elden Ring and the Lands Between. My general hope is that applying this lense to lore and concepts that are not explicitly explored by these similarities, could help develop other existing theories, or cultivate ideas that could never really get off the ground.

Relation to Christianity

Beyond just the images, I learned really early on that Gnosticism—in many forms—is closely related to Christianity.

Contemporary scholarship largely agrees that Gnosticism has Jewish Christian origins, originating in the late first century AD in nonrabbinical Jewish sects and early Christian sects.[26][1][22][note 14] Ethel S. Drower adds "heterodox Judaism in Galilee and Samaria appears to have taken shape in the form we now call Gnostic, and it may well have existed some time before the Christian era."

I only include that because of the Byzantine/Catholic/Orthodox inspirations for many of the architecture and religious icons in Leyndell and Marika specifically (since she is clearly a christ figure and literally crucified). Also this:

Two of the most commonly paired æons were Christ and Sophia (Greek: "Wisdom"); the latter refers to Christ as her "consort" in A Valentinian Exposition.

Aeons will be explored further down.

Quick note: I will not be directly attempting to use this information to explain historical events in Elden Ring, I also don't go into specific Gnostic sects. I'm focusing on general themes and not yet delving into Gnostic borrowed roots (Platonism being one), or differences between things like Sethian versus Valentinian Gnostic thought. If anyone is more versed on a specific type of Gnosticism that they think more directly resonates with Elden Ring, please let me know.

Similar Gnostic Concepts to Elden Ring's Cosmology

The Monad

​

In many Gnostic systems, God is known as the Monad, the One.[note 18] God is the high source of the pleroma, the region of light. The various emanations of God are called æons. According to Hippolytus, this view was inspired by the Pythagoreans, who called the first thing that came into existence the Monad, which begat the dyad, which begat the numbers, which begat the point, begetting lines, etc.

​

Or as Hyetta might put it

All that there is came from the One Great. Then came fractures, and births, and souls

There is a singular central entity that not only gave rise to everything else, but composes everything else as well. Not only did the Monad start everything, it is everything still.

​

The Pleroma

​

Pleroma (Greek πλήρωμα, "fullness") refers to the totality of God's powers. The heavenly pleroma is the center of divine life, a region of light "above" (the term is not to be understood spatially) our world, occupied by spiritual beings such as aeons (eternal beings) and sometimes archons.

That on its own kinda works in two ways. If we ignore the "...(the term is not to be understood spatially)..." it could be the cosmos. Stars, etc. Which fits with Elden Ring, but even if we don't there is a spiritual world in Elden Ring. It's not explored very much due to being composed of mostly cut content, but it's definitely still there as it has a good amount of lore. But also:

Jesus is interpreted as an intermediary aeon who was sent from the pleroma, with whose aid humanity can recover the lost knowledge of the divine origins of humanity.

The Jesus figure as portrayed could definitely help shed light on Marika and other Empyreans' role in the Lands Between. Marika is completely full of Jesus imagery. While she may also draw from other sources, notably Boudica, her association with Jesus and Christian imagery is most important for this part. The Numen coming from "Outside the Lands Between" is also notable. Since Jesus could be seen as this intermediary sent from above, Marika could also fill that role. But what does it mean when it says they were sent to aid humanity in recovering knowledge of their divine origins? How exactly does Marika accomplish anything remotely close to that by heralding the Age of the Erdtree and conquering the Lands Between?

The Aeons

​

In many Gnostic systems, the aeons are the various emanations of the superior God or Monad. Beginning in certain Gnostic texts with the hermaphroditic aeon Barbelo,[62][63][64] the first emanated being, various interactions with the Monad occur which result in the emanation of successive pairs of aeons, often in male–female pairings called syzygies.[65] The numbers of these pairings varied from text to text, though some identify their number as being thirty.[66] The aeons as a totality constitute the pleroma, the "region of light". The lowest regions of the pleroma are closest to the darkness; that is, the physical world.[67]

Quick shout out to the Aeon Barbelo:

This figure is also variously referred to as 'Mother-Father' (hinting at her apparent androgyny), 'First Human Being', 'The Triple Androgynous Name', or 'Eternal Aeon'.

Marika the Eternal was both Marika and Radagon. She also shared divine characteristics with Jesus which is also said to be an Aeon in many of these traditions. She also shows many similarities with Sophia, but it gets a bit more complex from here and this is just conspiratorial ranting from me.

Summary so Far

The important aspects of these similarities so far are mostly superficial and are echos of other theories that already exist. The idea that all things in Elden Ring have emanated from a single cosmic being that is beyond touch or communication. An acolyte or piece of this being was sent to the lands between, and it bonded with and elevated a Numen (also from outside the lands between) to be a God. These Aeons, or pieces of the One, have a tendency to be dyads or hermaphroditic and they regularly take consorts. Nothing truly groundbreaking yet, but things do get a bit more specific from here. I'm a bit tired though, so I'm going to collect my thoughts, and if there is sufficient interest (or not, I might just get bored and do it anyway lol) I'll post a Part 2 that goes into how I think exploring real world Gnosticism can help inform our understanding of these topics and I will also attempt to answer these questions myself utilizing in-game lore and storytelling:

  • What exactly the Lands Between are
    • How it was created and by whom
    • Why Death works the way it does
    • What were the gods that inhabited the Lands Between during Ancient times (E.g., the serpent god)
    • What are the Ainsel and Siofra rivers?
  • Mysteries surrounding Placidusax
    • Where did Placidusax come from?
    • Who or what was the god that fled?

And arguably the most important questions to which I still haven't personally heard a satisfactory answer.

  • What is the Elden Ring?
  • What is the Erd Tree/Crucible?
  • What is the goal of all these higher beings?
    • and what was Marika's role?

I believe we can attempt to start answering those questions by looking at the story of Sophia, the Demiurge, and the creation of a material world.

​

So let me know if any of this sounds interesting, or if you've heard it before. If you read this far, thank you! I understand I didn't really get into connecting the dots directly just yet, but this was getting long and I figured I'd just test people's reaction before soldering on with the rest of the essay. I have my thoughts in a giant note taking box saved to my docs, I just need some time sort it out in a more digestible way. If you have any tips about writing style, or if any of this was confusing, please let me know. Always looking to better my writing.

​

Edit: Part 2 is up now if you're interested!

https://www.reddit.com/r/EldenRingLoreTalk/comments/10n1xpf/elden_ring_cosmology_and_gnosticism_part_2/

Posted Jan 25, 2023, 11:31 PM UTC · edited

1624

I've been looking at Gnosticism and Ialdabaoth for a couple of months now. I just...wasn't sure what to say. I think you're on the right track, because I followed you completely here, as far as terminology and concepts go.

The occult inspirations for this game and its story are overwhelming and amalgamated. I think it could be interpreted from many different perspectives correctly. That's the 'problem', it fits so well with so many mythologies, fables, parables, that it's basically a skeleton key.

That being said, I do want to hear what you have to say about Ialdabaoth.

8
thefallenfew•

The thing to remember is Elden Ring is Elden Ring. Viewing it through the lenses of world history or world religions can help you wrap your head around some of the concepts more, but it’s a work of fiction, and it possible to understand it purely by unpacking the text of the game. That’s essentially how all Lit Crit works.

4

Elden Ring is Elden Ring

That's kinda what I was unsuccessfully getting at.

I think it would be very difficult to parse the Marika/Radagon situation without any previous experience with the idea of an Androgyne. I couldn't even guess what some younger, less educated people think about it.

3
quirkus23•

Also GRRM does this type of symbolic storytelling were he is using our real world knowledge to flesh out concepts and characters in his stories.

Here is an easy one there is a character called Arthur Dayne who has a magical sword and is the best knight in the kingdom. We only get like 2 sentences about this guy but we have a pretty decent picture in our heads about what he might have been like and represents because of our understanding of King Arthur. GRRM does this all over the place. It's really cool once you start figuring out the references and it can help us understand the intention behind stuff.

It's not an answer but it helps illuminate what might be going on in the game.

5

The Sword of the Morning!!!!

I enjoyed ASOIAF, it's been a while for me though. The Ironborn and the Faceless Men are the most interesting to me.

3
thefallenfew•

Yeah, and idea of multiple emanations of the same divine being, or beings that have male and female forms, is something present in a lot of world religion. Even Christianity, the great monotheistic religion of the West, is based around the concept of the Holy Trinity - one God that has three distinct and separate persons. “Jesus is God but also the son of God” isn’t too far from “Marika is Radagon but also the wife of Radagon”.

1
thefallenfew•

Browsing reddit “Marika is Radagon” is definitely the thing that broke most people’s brains lol

4
quirkus23•

I love the skeleton key idea and will be stealing it lol. It really is a key to a ton of world history/mythology/esoterica.

3
SolarbroOP•

Ialdabaoth is what is taking the second part so long because I don't want to overstep and say "he could be this character in the game" because he could fit as an analog for a number of named entities, but that's not what I'm trying to do. I think the concept of what he is and his role in Gnosticism is vastly more important for the Cosmology of Elden Ring. So I'm trying to be careful with the wording. I definitely feel you on not being 100% sure what to say, because he also is different in subtle but important ways depending on who you're asking.

The skeleton key analogy is the most perfect thing I've ever heard, thank you for that.

2

I do like the idea of a Demiurge that thinks it's God, but is actually a fallible and malevolent being. All the problems on Earth can be laid at its feet, because it didn't really know what it was doing. It's a pretty hot take, and it explains the rift between Gnosticism and Christianity well.

3
SonOfAtlass•

Not sure if this comment will help, but wait for the Shadow of the Erdtree dlc to make any links to Yalda. I was getting into Gnosticism as I was playing Elden ring when it came out last year and am grateful that I stumbled on this post. The Pistis Sophia is what drew me to compare the two under the same light, especially because it mentions 5 great trees. Yet back to Yalda, after 5 playthroughs, IMO I link Miquella with Yalda. FallenFews comment below, rings true to my viewpoint of life after death, honestly it this post is such a blessing, wish I wasn't so late to the party.

2
SolarbroOP•

This comment helps greatly actually! The DLC and life did get in the way of my final part, but I think I finally have my thoughts in order and want to make the post this weekend. I hope you’ll like what I have, but I definitely know that the DLC will shake things up in a big way. They always do.

But I want to make predictions lol so I can look back on it. The problem is, as always, Miquella. And while he does play the same role as many demiurge characters (being a faulty descendent of a single god that attempts to create their own world) there is another aspect that always messes me up. The spirit/dream world. Most of my more in depth reading so far focuses on the cosmology, and I know very little about the ideas on the afterlife, I know some. But it’s vague. And because of Saint Trina, the existence of the spirit realm, and how certain I am that those aspects are keystones of the DLC, I need to do my homework. Because I can either just give where I am now and wait, or I can try some bold predictions lol

1
quirkus23•

So I made this post quite a while ago but left that train of thought. I'm ready to return to it lol. Great post and I would obviously love a part 2 because I agree this is a huge inspiration. I love how this game layers all these different real world inspirations onto each other illustrating the overlap that was always there.

https://www.reddit.com/r/Eldenring/comments/tyga3w/elden_ring_and_gnosticism/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android_app&utm_name=androidcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

4
SolarbroOP•

Thank you for sharing, I'll be sure to read this. I'm a little embarrassed, I searched Gnosticism on this sub and forgot about the main one completely when preparing for this post.

2
quirkus23•

No worries. I was more sharing because I'm relived someone else caught onto the ideas. My post was very barebones cause I'm a layman but I did find the connections pretty strong.

2

Also, investigate Let's Talk Religion and Esoterica on YouTube. They've both done tons of work on Gnosticism.

4
mildinthestreets•

Would love to hear more of your thoughts!

3
thefallenfew•

Some food for thought, how I see the answers to the questions you’re still pondering:

  • The Elden Ring is a physical manifestation of the rules thar govern the universe. It’s a really unique concept, one that I don’t think mirrors any world religions or even works of fiction. Holy texts can set out rules to live by, or systems to follow, but they can’t change the fundamental laws of the universe. The closest approximation is when the Catholic Church phased out Limbo.

Catholicism use to teach an idea called “Limbo”, which was a metaphysical plane of existence that wasn’t heaven, and wasn’t hell. It was a place where the dead would go if, say, they weren’t Baptized but never committed a sin outside of Original Sin (unbaptized babies, for example), or the Baptized would go if they died with venial sins. You could be temporarily separated from God with the offer of moving on to Heaven eventually. But a decade or so ago the Church decided Limbo wasn’t necessary anymore, and phased it out. Today it’s no longer taught or believed to exist. So, like, if you’re Catholic, essentially the fundamental structure of reality was altered by some words on a paper. Pretty wild stuff!

The Elden Ring is sort of like that. The Runes that comprise it are sort of like the foundational rules of reality, like the source code, and by removing or adding it can change the world. It’s pretty interesting to give that kind of thing a physical form that can be broken or mended or rearranged, especially considering that the Outer Gods who are behind each Rune don’t seem to have any form.

  • The Erdtree seems to be a natural reflection of the state and structure of the current Elden Ring. The Crucible is the natural processes of the world, what we’d refer to as natural selection, evolution, the circle of life, survival of the fittest, natural order, etc. Things are born, struggle, fight, survive, pass on their DNA to a new generation, then die. It’s a slow, violent, cruel refining process.

The original state of the Elden Ring, with all Runes intact, the Erdtree was a physical tree, and the Crucible was essentially what governed life. When the Rune of Death was taken out, the Erdtree became the source of rebirth and blessings, and the Crucible was ended.

  • The only two higher beings (Outer Gods) that seem to have a clear goal are the Greater Will and the Frenzied Flame. The Greater Will’s only goal seems to be mending the Elden Ring. It doesn’t seem too concerned with what shape it takes, just as long as it (Order) exists. The Frenzied Flame just wants chaos and the universe to return to its original state, sort of like the “Big Crunch” Theory of the universe, of everything eventually collapsing into the pre-Big Bang state.
3
thefallenfew•

Well done. You did some good research for only being introduced to the concept a few days ago.

2

FROM definitely infused their faith creation process with Gnostic cosmology. Tarnished Archaeologist points out that DS3's Cathedral of the Deep parallels Valentinian gnostic teachings of "The Deep" and as the supreme deity and his consort "Silence". This bit came out recently in their "Tarnished Holiday Special".

2

I'll be damned if the very center circle of that Sophia image doesn't have the 4 alchemical elements prominently and correctly displayed. There's also a Mercury/Aries pictogram below it to the right that is widely used in Royal Alchemy. It's damn near conspiratorial 😀.

2
SolarbroOP•

Straight up. I know the community has a lot of knowledge about Alchemy and how it can inform aspects of Elden Ring. I do not have that knowledge, but I did notice briefly that there appeared to be connections between different Gnostic thoughts and alchemy.

I just realized the breadth of reading there is on Gnosticism though so I may need to put a pause on attempting to understand the Alchemy implications. I’ll leave that for someone else. 😅

2

By our powers combined... haha. I'm about chest deep in Royal Alchemy, and still a little overwhelmed.

This all adds up though.

One the All, sensory/nervous array, corporeality, transmutation, blending Divinity and flesh, masculine/feminine, dissolution/coagulation...

2