[Spoiler] Need a bit of hint about the second puzzle of the puzzle book

SpoilerFrosthaven

Second puzzle is the one on Page 4 and 5. As mentioned, I assume these are letters. Since I'm not native English speaker, I have a bit of tough time grasping a starting point. I guess I want to confirm a few thoughts here to make sure I'm on the right track. Thanks.

  1. I assume all symbols are unique and each of them represents one letter in the English alphabet.
  2. If 1 is true, I guess the real starting point is that "E" appears the most.
  3. If 2 is true, then I feel the "/" with 3 dots is likely to be "E". However, this leads me to a problem that the first word is "_ _ E _ E" where it also appears that first three letter of this word "_ _ E" (appears second line and the last second line) is also a word...

^ can think of "piece / pie" and "there / the"

One extra question:

There's a few lines of these in the last page of GH Town Record book and the last chest of FC. They are not related for now?

Posted Jan 26, 2023, 8:48 PM UTC · edited

515
xContradict:FH_17_drill:•

Gonna spoiler this because it is easy to ruin someone's fun with this stuff.

!1. Yes. That is the premise of this puzzle.!<

!2. That is a great starting point, yes.!<

!3. You are on the right track, and your proposed solutions make sense. You aren't missing anything so far.!<

P.S. >!Maybe it would be worth revisiting any familiar looking GloomHaven components after solving this puzzle.!<

3
GarrettChanOP:FH_8_meteor:•

Thanks :)
Will keep in mind for the last one. I do think of something like this, but haven't gotten to that part yet.

1
dwarfSA:FH_13_fist:•

You're absolutely on the right track for your first word.

Once you solve this puzzle, you'll have the Unfettered alphabet. You'll be able to solve the two things you mentioned.

You can also (with some more effort because it's not straightforward) solve >!Gloomhaven Envelope A and use the word you learn in the lower right hand side of page 5, for a sub-puzzle.!<

2
GarrettChanOP:FH_8_meteor:•

Oh crap, I forgot about Envelope A. Thanks for reminding me.

It has been a while and I put these here and there and yeah... it's easy to miss them.

2
dwarfSA:FH_13_fist:•

Any time! Like I said - that one isn't a straightforward deciphering like the other two are. But it's solvable after you get your alphabet!

2
TiltedLibra:FH_15_Coral:•

You have to be pretty great at ciphers to solve that one, I'll say.

2
GarrettChanOP:FH_8_meteor:•

I see... but I have some ideas to try. Hopefully that's the correct idea, heh.

2
dwarfSA:FH_13_fist:•

It's short enough that you can brute force it once you have the basic alphabet. Translate into letters, then play around.

1
GarrettChanOP:FH_8_meteor:•

Yeah, I looked at the Envelope A one, and I have some idea to try tomorrow, but it seems hard.

Just want to make sure something. After the first page of the numerals, I'm getting both page 4 and page 5? The puzzle book uses the word "spread", so I assume I'll get both pages.

1
dwarfSA:FH_13_fist:•

Yep. A spread is two pages you see together.

2
TiltedLibra:FH_15_Coral:•

I really wish the break between words was more obvious on this one. It all just looked like one run-on word to me.

2
Inevitable-Ad5441•

Absolute kerning nightmare. Every time someone opens that page a type setter throws up in their mouth and isn't sure why.

2
pencilandpaper:14_Angry_Face:•

Having just solved puzzle 2, this line is brilliant.

1