AE Higgins Mill - better than expected

Review

​

picture I failed to upload initially

Short version: I ended up liking the Higgins Mill more than I expected to.

My Allen Edmonds Story: like a lot of people, I suspect, AE was my first "real" shoe. I'd wear them on job interviews or other special occasions. I still have them, and they've held up well -- been resoled twice -- classic black oxfords. There's been a lot of talk about AE's quality decline, and I experienced that myself a couple of years ago when I bought a pair of AE chukkas and was disappointed by both their quality and the customer service.

I'd been eyeing the Higgins Mill boot for a while, though. And the sub helpfully pointed me to the Grant Stone Diesel as an alternative (more on that below), which led me to pick up a pair of those in Color #8. But, while holding a sleeping baby I was absent-mindedly scrolling through eBay and found these for only $150. I'd been debating between natural cxl and color #8, and who was I to argue with such kismet. Besides, at that price I figured if I hated them I could resell them without much of a loss.

These are Higgins Mill Weatherproof Natural Chromexcel Boots (https://www.allenedmonds.com/product/mens-higgins-mill-weatherproof-boot-with-chromexcel-leather-3023473/natural-chromexcel-leather-ec4021633).

Fit, Finish, and Leather: AE says they are true to size, and that's my experience, even a little on the snug side (though the laces they came with were probably not helping). The finishing is ... pretty good! More discerning eyes will find more issues than I did. I'll post pictures of the welt joins (that the right terminology?) that are ok, I think. They're not immaculate like 2 out of 3 pairs of Grant Stones in this house, but I'd say well within tolerance.

https://preview.redd.it/e4xlymng8nea1.jpg?width=4032&format=pjpg&auto=webp&v=enabled&s=728dcf1e75cd1ad15148875d60c77c5c00c6cde8

​

https://preview.redd.it/mtlpq2qj8nea1.jpg?width=4032&format=pjpg&auto=webp&v=enabled&s=30a0595d3f2ca179efe62a743a684850d6fd7df5

The leather is smoother and a shade darker than my other natural CXL shoes. I asked about it in the Questions Thread and it might be some coating or treatment AE does to their shoes. And granted, this is a data point of 1. I thought it might be something to do with the "weatherproofing." Beats me. While I prefer the lighter color a little bit, as long as it patinas to that rich burnt sugar that's what really matters to me! And this color isn't bad at all. Incidentally, it does mean that AE's pictures on their website are quite accurate colorwise. Others have remarked on the lace holder seeming flimsy, and it feels that way to me, too.

​

compared to natural cxl Oak Street oxfords

Is there a place for the Higgins Mill? Part of why I wanted to write this review, besides showing off my lucky eBay find, was that I see questions regularly asking about AE shoes. AE and especially the Higgins Mill is in a tough spot. Grant Stone, along with Parkhurst, Oak Street and the rest are right there. The GS Diesel is virtually identical to the Higgins Mill. The GS Diesel is even be a tiny bit sleeker. Really the Edward is the direct comparison since it's got the smaller eyelets and hardware (and the Captoe is the same as the Edward, just with the captoe). While the sticker price of the Higgins Mill is higher, they are regularly on sale and there's a big second hand market, so the price will often be a wash.

Higgins Mill / Diesel

Higgins Mill / Diesel

All that being said, I am surprised to say that there is some place for the Higgins Mill. I wouldn't begrudge someone getting them. Basically, this is what it brings to the table over something like a Grant Stone Diesel based on:

  • Weight -- the Diesel is clearly heavier than the Higgins Mill, which could matter over the course of a long day. Though I find the Grant Stones to be comfortable boots.
  • Genuine Dainite sole -- I can't tell any real difference (if someone is interested I can look into this more), but if it makes a difference to you.
  • Physical stores -- most major cities in the US have a place to buy Allen Edmonds.

The last one might be important, especially starting out as one is figuring out sizing, preferences, etc.

I hope that's helpful to well ... somebody.

Posted Jan 27, 2023, 8:18 PM UTC · edited

8436
Loading comments…