Columbus officers speak out following assessment of police department
wtvm.com/2023/02/01/exclusive-columbus-office...Posted Feb 2, 2023, 12:28 AM UTC
Posted Feb 2, 2023, 12:28 AM UTC
As a former Officer at CPD for quite a few years as it was all rapidly sliding downhill, I will say a few things. STRAP IN, FOLKS. THIS ONE'S LONG.
The first thing I'll say is this: Chief Blackmon, while not a bad person per se, is a half-wit leader at the command level. He has the credentials, but they're not hard to get. They really, really aren't. It's like getting a college degree, just do the class work, pay your tuition, earn a C average, and voila, you got the piece of paper you can display to show everyone how smart and special you are. Sure, some of it isn't super easy, but if you take the time, you'll eventually get it.
A major fault with Freddie Blackmon is that there's a lot of talking about shit without being about that same shit. When he speaks, his speeches often seem unprepared (probably because they are). He wants to be off-the-cuff articulate and profound. He wants to try his best. One of his problems is that he is so obviously intrinsically unsure of himself, how to approach things, how to conquer the major issues, and how to persuade the city council and his subordinates, that no progress is made. He overwhelms himself and has no idea how to delegate or prioritize things. In effect, as much as he wants to try, the fella just doesn't have the gusto for the position. I can't speak on his abilities at the ranks of Captain or below, because I wasn't around for those years, but he must have done something right.
He is the type who not only wants to please everyone, but runs the fool's errand of trying to please everyone even though he isn't entirely sure how to please a whole hell of a lot of people. Means well, but can't perform well enough.
Freddie Blackmon was not awarded the position because he is, himself, black (that actually was a part of it), but because for years prior, he was the Major (now known as Deputy Chief) over the Office of Professional Standards (OOPS), which is the Bureau that oversees policy, administrative action, CALEA and other certifications/accreditation compliance, hiring/firing, and for some reason Criminal Intelligence, on top of a few other things. Likewise, a few city council members share similar political opinions with him. The city council also knows that he is not very good at debating, negotiating, or presenting proposals, so they would have the upper hand when even such conversations need to be had.
Chief Blackmon wanted the department to be more progressive in its orientation, pushing the affirmative action card as far as he could so as to force upon the community outside of the department that we were not racist, ethnocentric, sexist, or otherwise operating with undue prejudice... for which we were not under any particular scrutiny to begin with. So, he put some people in positions where they wanted to be, even though they may not have been in the top 25% of candidates for the position (this includes Sergeants, Lieutenants, Detectives, Command Staff, and even Patrol Officers trying to become Corporals).
From the inside, many of us could see the preferential treatment to force the perspective of diversity that was never an issue. This could be seen when patrol officers or detectives applied for different types of training, when promotion considerations came around, when suspensions and other disciplinary actions were considered, when equipment and vehicles were assigned out, and when they decided to take "random" surveys to inquire about issues.
I won't get too into the race aspect, but some of it is pretty obvious from within. It's not that the command is anti-white or anti-male, but many are certainly forcing diversity to happen or at least be on display, even at the cost of safety, investigative effectiveness, and morale.
Back to the Chief and his Command Staff.
While they are good and well-meaning people for the most part, better shoes could have fit the roles. Assistant Chiefs Kennedy and Dent-Fitzpatrick are strong women with strong work ethic in their roles, though some tend to debate the effectiveness and acumen of Dent-Fitzpatrick. Overall, though, Dent-Fitzpatrick is well-qualified, well-experienced, book and street smart, representative of Columbus altogether, understanding, tenacious, and sometimes stubborn, the latter two of which some folks don't love. Kennedy is methodical, caring, and inquistive; determined to improving what she can for the betterment of the department.
The Deputy Chiefs: Dent (Patrol), Hastings (Investigative Services), Graham (OOPS), and Deaton (Support Services) (there's currently a vacancy in Admin Services), are a mixed bag.
Dent seems like a mean fellow, but really isn't. He is, however, especially stern. He can be rather stubborn and hard-nosed when he has made a decision, even if it's probably not what is perfectly right. Generally, he's fair, but there's been a culture of not fighting back with admins at CPD because whatever decision they came up with isn't actually up for debate, though they make it seem like there is room for discussion and negotiation. Probably going to retire soon.
Hastings was very particular about a bunch of things. He was strict, very much by-the-book, and absolute about policy. A bunch of officers did not and still do not like him. He was a super picky micromanage, but has recently become a bit more laid back, apparently. Not inherently evil, but someone most of us wanted to avoid as often as possible. Probably an alright guy outside of work, but not many cared to test that theory. Does NOT like the Chief whatsoever. Probably going to retire soon.
Graham is... Not a bad guy... But he should certainly not be over Professional Standards as a Deputy Chief. He and Chief Blackmon are good friends. Graham isn't terribly articulate in speaking or writing, definitely not the sharpest guy in the room, but he's not wholly incompetent. He is personable for the most part, but seems to be unsure of how to mix in proper professional judgment. Most others in OOPS don't believe he's competent enough to be their boss. Another example of wanting to please everyone, but not knowing how to please pretty much anyone. Eligible to and probably should retire, but likely won't for at least 5 more years.
Deaton is great at what he does. He is personable, tactful, thoughtful, intelligent, and doesn't BS when he doesn't know or understand something. He loves the job, the profession, the people he works with and supervises, and his community. His openness and ability to learn is great. His grant-writing and negotiation skills are top-notch. As a supervisor, he was fantastic, always pretty fair, and fairly easy to work with. If he were to put in a bid to be the next Chief, he would be an ideal candidate.
— CONTINUED IN FIRST COMMENT —
The City Council desperately needs an overhaul. Especially at the City Manager position. To me, at least, it appears Chief Blackmon has stepped up to the Major Leagues, but still belongs on a high school varsity team. Isaiah Hugley seems to be buddy-buddy with him, but also walks all over him and the rest of the department. Hugley does not seem to understand how law enforcement works or what Columbus needs in terms of law enforcement and personnel. His main concern seems to be the dollars he can stuff into his billfold while putting on the façade of caring about social justice and police reform. And Freddie Blackmon just rolls along with it.
This is part of why Freddie Blackmon promotes the idea of 21st Century Policing. He LOVES that term and loves the theory of it, as does Hugley and most of the City Council. It's one of those million-dollar concepts, but none of them have even the slightest idea of how to teach it, train it, incorporate it, or otherwise implement it. In effect, it's a few $20 words bunched into a term, but has no real meaning or value.
Blackmon inherited a ton of issues. Few of these issues have been even slightly quelled. So people quit. More issues came along, so more people quit. There was a change to 10-hour shifts for patrol, and the schedule was actually an improvement, but the promise was that they would not consider 12-hour shifts; 14 months later, patrol was told to prepare to move to 12-hour shifts. More people quit. Spec Ops, Tact Squad, Traffic Squad, and some Detectives were told they would likely be all reassigned back to Patrol for lack of manpower. More quit.
The department put in a new pay and benefits proposal, but the city council rejected different versions multiple times. They paid a company to conduct a pay study... city council didn't like seeing that the study showed how underpaid and undercompensates the officers, 911, and all civilian employees were in comparison to the Georgia, southeast regional, and nation markets, and how much it was more budget we needed to properly pay people, recruit high quality personnel, and purchase top of the line equipment. So what did they do? They ordered another pay study and saw that they could give minimal raises to most people to be comparable the average among all Georgia agencies (wholly unfair), they could probably skirt the issue of better benefits and use leftover monies that should be incorporated into legitimate raises to instead give "bonuses" to their employees to make it appear as they're paying better than they are... Bonuses which would disappear when they hire enough new people. A pay proposal was ultimately agreed upon at the end of 2022 and it was absolutely terrible. It didn't address any of the issues except for some mid-to-higher ranking officers getting a decent pay increase, while everyone else received minimal increases amounting to maybe a 1-3%, even though a fair increase to keep up with inflation, cost of living, and fair market value over the previous 10 years would have been in the ballpark of 13-25%, since CPD received only three raises each between 1% and 2% over that past decade. More people quit.
The Chief has consistently deceived the public about how many officers are on the streets at any given time. There are 26 patrol beats. He had said before that all the beats were covered by their own officer (they were not), then that most beats were covered (while technically true 14-17 beats covered on average is despicable), then that we had enough officers on duty per shift to cover the beats (true only if you include Lieutenants and Captains who are not supposed to take calls or initiate anything in the field per their job description. Sergeants used to mostly be in the office too, rarely going out for calls, now they're regularly responding to any type of call for service). It's total bullshit that the city is covered by Police Officers. It is not.
Call volume is high. Super high. If you've had to wait for an officer for longer than 10 minutes, that because there was a lot of stuff going on. From the outside, you have no idea. If you've been in a wreck and have waited longer than 15 minutes, it's probably because there were a bunch of other wrecks before yours, maybe with serious injuries. There was probably a shooting, stabbing, fight, burglary in progress, robbery in progress, or something of the sort. We've had to hold a robbery and an accident with injuries for awhile because there were three shootings in three different places within a short time frame. We've held shots fired calls for other major calls because either one person called and didn't want to speak with an officer or there was nobody known to be injured or dead.
— One More Comment and I'm Done, I Swear —
911 doesn't have enough people to man the phones and dispatch, so they're often answering 911 calls AND dispatching over multiple radios at once. If you don't know how absolutely difficult their job actually is, it's pretty bad. And they get paid like absolute garbage. Their starting pay hasn't changed much since the early 2000s when it was actually decent pay. Not great, but decent. They don't get many raises if any at all and hardly anyone appreciates them properly.
The Department's command altogether cares so much about small bullshit things in policy that carry such little weight in the grand scheme of things that it ruins officers' career ambitions within the department, defeats morale, and often holds back great officers and great leaders from reaching anywhere close to their potential. Oftentimes, these officers resort to bitterness and just do the minimum so as to fly under the radar until they can retire or find a job they would be absolutely stupid not to take.
The constant dick-measuring contest between the Chief and the Sheriff needs to end. For the most part, there is no animosity between both agencies and the jail is too small and crowded to accommodate every offender out there. Even if the money to fix that issue could be immediately raised, it would take a long time for the jail to be ready to house more people or for a new and better facility to be built. The jail is a total shit hole altogether, but that's a topic for another time.
Ultimately in this contest, there is no way for the Sheriff to lose, because when it comes down to it, the Police Department is not required by law to exist, but the Sheriff's Office is. Each county must have a Sheriff. So there should be more effective communication, more professional coherence, more general cohesiveness, damage planning, and emergency preparation coordinated between both agencies. Doubt that will happen within the next decade.
Citizens, if it helps: the officers at CPD, for the most part, are well-trained, well-disciplined, and good workers. They are very limited by the command's objectives, manpower, and policies disallowing some proactive and proper reactive measures. Most of the FTOs who are training new officers are damn good at it and good officers are molded from them. However, the good ones are either being driven away or are doing the bare minimum and effectively retired on duty because they only have a short time left before they can actually retire.
Jensen Hughes did a decent job with this study. There are some things they missed, minor things they didn't exactly get right, and some things that are difficult to understand from the outside looking in.
There's a bunch of stuff (good and bad) that I deleted or didn't even bother to touch on in this mini-manifesto. So don't take it all as Gospel or as a definitive list. Rather, take it as food for thought; pay attention to who you vote for, who your leaders are supposed to be, and don't be afraid to ask questions or make suggestions.
If you can, though, do something to learn how Law Enforcement works (or should work). Do a ride-along or two, request to check out 911, join the Citizens Law Enforcement Academy at CPD, SOMETHING. No better way to understand it than to take a part in it. Even if you don't love the police, try it out. You can't learn it enough from classrooms and YouTube.
This is a wonderful reply, and a sad indictment of our city. Thank you for this response and your insight.
Whether Chief Blackmon was a Affirmative Action style hire or not is irrelevant at this point. His paper qualifications look like any other person you might hire as chief. With the city being pretty evenly split between whites and blacks, only some old school racists on both sides really care about his race at all. His incompetency at leadership and the continued "promote the chief from within" attitude continue to do the entire city a disservice. The bad thing is that his race will probably shield him from being fired until things really get bad.
CPD sorely needs outside voices to fix things at this point. Too many factions have cropped up inside the department to really garner full support for an internal candidate. And an internal candidate may not have enough experience in a department that actually works worth a damn.
Totally agreed. I always thought that the council should have hired an outside replacement to deal with the issues that were already starting to crop up under Boren and I don't think there's any real way of fixing things at this point unless Blackmon is replaced from the outside.
Part of the problem under Blackmon has been the promotion of cliques that have turned out to be toxic in leadership positions. But part of the reason for that is because of preexisting tensions between various cliques inside the department.
It's going to take someone who isn't preinvested in the mess with a side already chosen to sort things out I think.
I think it does have to do with race. He was not hired for his professionalism or competence but solely because he is black. It's part of the whole racial equality standards America is jumping on. Columbus has not had a black chief in quite sometime. No matter race,sex or religion a person of that position should be qualified for the job. Just look at the stats since he took office.
No need for the op to have to add an edit or get their panties in a bunch. Why is it that race can't be discussed logically without someone getting upset. As a lifelong member of this community and knowing many on and retired from the police force of Columbus this is 100% accurate. To place someone in a position based solely on their race is also racist. There were more qualified people for the job. Just look at this shithole in the last few years. Face it the man is incompetent.
While the man may be useless... it isn't like the department was a shining model of competency with previous leaders. This is just another in a long line of terrible leadership.
And we certainly can't take ANYTHING the FOP says seriously.
it isn't like the department was a shining model of competency with previous leaders.
It wasn't. But things have rapidly escalated from a department with issues under previous leadership to a department in crisis under Blackmon. CPD had retention struggles in the past, but it's reached a point where investigative units have been disbanded and it's not unusual for things to be so short staffed where there are fewer than a dozen officers on duty for the entire city on some shifts.
And we certainly can't take ANYTHING the FOP says seriously.
This is a 160 page report from an independent consulting firm who has made their name rooting out corruption and racism in police departments. They had people embedded with the department observing things for weeks. They used an FOP survey indicating that officers are unhappy with leadership as one data point in a much larger overall assessment. They saw and heard plenty - - that's documented in the assessment - - to corroborate the general results of that survey.
I think you're saying the same thing I am. I'm not making any comment on this independent report.
FWIW, race and the politics of race are absolutely a component in this story. I don't have a problem discussing that which is why I made a point of highlighting it as part of the problem.
Comments like "affirmative action do be real" and "the idiocy of equity" arent serious discussion, though. They're barely veiled in their intent.
It wasn't directed at you.
Affirmative action do be real
Now the biggest thing is to see IF anything will be done about it.
After all, insanity is to keep doing the same thing over and over while expecting different results but its even more insane to have issues highlighted and still do nothing hoping for different results.
God these comments. Columbus really hasn't changed a bit. Lived there late 90s through about 10 years, went to CSU before I moved away.
Just a sad miserable city stuck in the same political problems it's had for decades. Same miserable bitter people. It's like save for the gentrified downtown and a few roundabouts the place hasn't changed a bit since 1996.
It’s crazy to see subtle support for meritocracy on Reddit.
Are people finally opening their eyes to the idiocy of equity??
Context: a group of local businesses recently paid to have the same outside consulting firm that evaluated the Minneapolis and Louisville PDs in the wake of Breonna Taylor and George Floyd killings take look at the current state of police department operations and make recommendations on what can be done to improve officer retention, the overall efficiency of the department, and the relationship between the department and the people of Columbus.
The full report is a doozy and found massive failings in leadership pretty much across the board. There's fairly damning criticism of Chief Blackmon on nearly every front, whether it's managing his officers and morale, efficient use of department resources, or building relations with the community.
Chief Blackmon released a statement where he complains extensively about the assessment using a survey conducted by the FOP last year where officers expressed a lack of confidence in his leadership as inaccurate. He further minimizes and dismisses many of the issues raised by the assessment.
This quote is a bit of a money shot given many of Chief Blackmon's supporters, including City Manager Isaiah Hugley have long insisted that the criticisms of Chief Blackmon from the department's rank and file are rooted in racism:
The full assessment is worth a read, if this sort of thing is of interest to you.
Additional reporting:
Ledger (Paywalled -- open in incognito)
CNAW2 - includes more extensive excerpts of the assessment
EDIT:
Sigh.
While this is a conversation that will involve elements of race if discussed frankly, frank discussion doesn't require dog-whistling racists dragging out of the woodworks.
The point of calling out the quote from that particular officer was to highlight the frustrations many black officers have that their concerns about Chief Blackmon's leadership have been hand-waived away with "the FOP is racist" by certain figures in the community, most notably the City Manager. It wasn't there as a permission slip for some of y'all to let your dumbass flag fly.
I've read about issues with CPD's leadership for years. This is a pretty compelling article that further validates concerns of former officers. Facebook is what it is, but there are some really harsh testimonials in comments on CPD-related posts from former officers talking about how terrible leadership is within the department. Has nothing to do with race or sex, it's a personality and motivation issue.
Columbus is the largest city I've lived in that has such a minimal police presence. I've also spoken with officers from other departments that say CPD is the wild west and no one "in the know" really considers transferring to CPD because of these issues even despite the hiring incentives and relocation bonuses.
Take it as hearsay, that's fine, but it's worth considering that if knowledge of these issues extends beyond the reaches of the city the CPD will never get better without a heavy restructuring. And EVERYONE knows CPD could definitely be much better. We won't gain the talent that's needed. You can only do so much with a minimal unmotivated police force in a city that has a growing crime rates like we have.