if AI replaced 50% of occupations, what would the replaced people do all day?
Posted Feb 12, 2023, 8:26 AM UTC
Posted Feb 12, 2023, 8:26 AM UTC
Starve
Historically when half of occupations become automated, people start doing other things they didn't bother with before.
This is also true, there would be a slow shift in priorities to other things
what i mean is, what if AI suddenly exploded and 50% of occupations were replaced over a short period of time, like a year?
obvi this is a sci-fi scenario, i'm just curious about what people think.
In that case it's the same, but with a depression until they find the new jobs. Maybe UBI would get passed.
I’ve had a UBI it doesn’t just pass out of your system.
we'd need to resurrect Thomas More and get him into the senate :D
My exact thoughts. Most people aren't unemployed because farming got mostly automated.
Long term that's true. But in the short term, those whose jobs suddenly disappeared would suffer.
Like sitting around scrolling their phones becoming more and more angry and depressed.
If we didn't live in a capitalist hellscape then we would be able to work less and have more leisure time but probably wealth disparity would increase as people get into more debt trying to get educations that should be free to be eligible for jobs where they wont be paid fairly and the rich will become richer because they own all of the institutions we rely on and the means to develop the technology. And if you are not capable of getting an education you will end up in a minimum wage job where it is cheaper to utilise human labour than pay for automation and be chronically mistreated until you die. Probably early.
If we didn't live in a capitalist hellscape then we would be able to work less and have more leisure time
i don't understand, can you explain that further?
but probably wealth disparity would increase as people get into more debt trying to get educations that should be free
well...not "free", but tax-funded. i definitely agree with that plan.
to be eligible for jobs where they wont be paid fairly
i don't understand this part either. education is generally the gateway to a better life with higher salaries and more options and opportunities, and statistics show that.
as education increases, salaries increase, and each tier of education increases it.
how do you mean "won't be paid fairly"?
And if you are not capable of getting an education you will end up in a minimum wage job where it is cheaper to utilise human labour than pay for automation and be chronically mistreated until you die. Probably early
yeah, well...no argument there. the minimum wage laws are medieval in the US right now. it should be bumped up big time, plus all employees, even part-time and contract, should be guaranteed medical insurance through their employers.
Ok take self check outs as an example. The store had 20 employees then fired 10 and replaced them with machines. If the company wasn't driven by profit (capitalism) but was focused on providing better lifestyles for workers (socialism) they could have kept all 20 employees and reduced their hours by half giving them the same pay and a better quality of life. This is obviously a primitive example but you get the idea.
Lots of jobs now require qualifications that are so unnecessary for the roles and aren't equivalent pay to the money spent on Education. A scientist in the UK could spend 60k plus on Education and then only be eligible for 23k. Nurses, teacher etc all need degree but in my country are living off of food banks. Administration roles which 30 years ago would have been a job you get straight out of high/secondary school need a degree as a minimum requirement. To get into the top tier of jobs: lawyer, doctor, etc it's normally a requirement to go through months/years of unpaid labour so you are essentially locked out from those jobs unless you come from money.
Probably be homeless and die
do you really believe that would happen?
Yep.
that's scary.
globally, or just in the US?
Definitely in the US; it's actually insanely expensive to be poor here, but I imagine other places as well, though I imagine the severity would vary from place to place depending on what kind of safety nets any given government has for the poor.
When automation replaced a lot of manual work the service industry grew proportionately
Likely we'll all have jobs but do less and less outside of the scope of that job, we already have people making food for us then other people bringing it to our doorstep, can't wait for someone to chew it for me and feed me like a baby bird because it's not my job to chew food thank you very much
Amazing how much fear there is for that!
Over time, technology has replaced all kinds of jobs for sure, but history suggests that, for every job that vanishes, there are at least two new types of jobs (usually higher paying) created.
Some of the new jobs will not have been possible before the technology existed, but others will appear in ways that most people in those jobs can't even imagine.
interesting. i probably should have specified that i meant "if AI suddenly exploded and replaced 50% of occupations in a short span of time, like a year".
Different industries have different lag periods before a change is adopted.
Construction, for example, has an "adoption" period of between 50 and 75 years, often taking over 100 years for a "new" method to become normalized. Computing is usually less than a year; it took fifteen years for office secretarial pools to disappear after a couple of hundred years of prominence; but programing (extremely rare in the 1950 and 1960's, although present) virtually vanished (or at least changed drastically) in something like 10 years -- old fashioned programmers/coders are no longer needed, and systems analysts are virtually unemployable (in the way they were needed in the seventies and eighties).
So, overall, even with AI speed, it'll take maybe 5 years before jobs will start disappearing, and the replacement will start about a year before the jobs start disappearing -- it's already happening: 60% (maybe more) of the jobs university students are aiming for will be vanishing before the students graduate or shortly thereafter!
Ideally, you tax automation and give everybody UBI, and let people pursue their interests.
This!
We are at a point in human history where we have the technology to automate most of the work that humans currently do.
This could either be the greatest boon, ever, to humanity, or the point where oligarchy destroys all of us.
It's up to us to make sure that the former is the case, and not the latter.
This will be a test for humanity; there is no way that society will keep functioning with 50% unemployment, unless we make the corporations which run with 90%+ robot workers pay taxes high enough to give everyone a living societal wage; otherwise half of humanity will be homeless and go hungry, and will not be able to buy the crap the robots make. We cannot have completely robotised industries in private hands, at least not paying the existing corporate taxes. Simple as that.
Die - it's what the WEF say they want.
Andrew Yang's book, The War on Normal People (published in 2018), talks about this topic. His solution is UBI and I am not advocating for that (make up your own mind on that one). At least he is raising awareness that AI will replace many blue collar jobs and we need a plan to address that. This isn't talked about enough!
If we are smart about which we aint gonna be than they'd be doing nothing because they'd have that general purpose ai also generate income for them.
What a wonderful question i wish like... any government would ask itself as well.
sell AI.
Look for new jobs, oversaturate the job market, and massively reduce everyone's wages
Reddit.
The change we are going through now is probably like the change from agricultural society to industrial revolution. Jobs will be lost, new jobs created and people who are flexible and willing to learn something new have the best chance at surviving the transition.
[deleted]
More of this probably.
Go fishing
AI support, AI technician, AI product owner, AI developer, AI marketing team, AI legal support team....
But seriously the next generation will be working jobs that don't exist now, same as my father's job does not exist now and my job did not exist when my father was alive.
Hopefully looking to space. I wanna be an asteroid miner
Have you seen the expanse
Yes, only the first season though, want to read the books first!
It's so good
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BVn1oQL9sWg
[removed]