I need advice on in game consequences for a player using multiple concentration spells
Last session started with the party halfway through a fight with a powerful dragon. Over the course of a couple turns one of my players cast Haste, Heroism, and Spirit Shroud. I did not catch that all of these were concentration spells, and only found out because one of the other players informed me about it after the session. Having all of those up was a major turning point in the fight and led to the second half of being substantially easier. I would rather not retcon the session and start them back at the fight, instead having in game consequences for the character that far over extended themselves. Any thoughts?
Edit: Just to address some comments/concerns that I have noticed, will try to also respond
- They are not a new player, I brought them into 5e about 6 years ago. They have mostly played in my games and dm'd a couple of their own
- Yes, I will be talking to the player as well. Out of game problems are addressed by out of game conversations. In game problems are addressed with out of game conversations and in game consequences.
- Players are expected to keep track of anything relating to their character (effects, abilities, encumbrance, if their spell is concentration) If I need to check one of these things, it is because something sounds off to me or they have a question.
- Yes, the above points were addressed in session 0 and they have been reminded more than once since then. As well as this is how I run all of my games. Obviously our new player gets loads more leeway on these things as they are still learning
- The player is playing a level 10 character that is 5 Artificier(Battlesmith)\5 Wizard(Transmutation), the game started at level 1 over a year ago and everyone still has their original characters.
- I appreciate everyone looking out for good DM-Player communication and reminders that new people need time to learn, but this is neither of those. I used poor wording when I put "Advice" in the title as I am really looking for ideas other than my own on in game consequences.
Posted Feb 14, 2023, 9:45 PM UTC · edited