I’m so tired of Western Redlibs baselessly calling Russia an “anti-communist country” from inside the West.

Posted Feb 15, 2023, 3:24 PM UTC

Posted Feb 15, 2023, 3:24 PM UTC
Imagine the conservative leader of a neoliberal Western country saying that to their national Communist Party leader.
Every leader of neoliberal western countries are busy in photo ops with their hero Zelensky, head puppet of the banderite Kiev regime.
i wouldn't say that russia is a country that we should generally support, but still, westerners have unnuanced takes on russia. it's not black and white.
Welcome to Dongistan comrades... Check out our Discord server: https://discord.gg/9WuSEwvh
☭ Read Marxist theory for free and without hassle on Marxists.org ☭
Left Coalition Subreddits: r/ABoringDystopia r/WackyWest r/noifone
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
Russian ML here. The KPRF (Zyuganov's party) are mostly soc-dem reformists and conformists in practice who pander to nostalgia for the USSR. There are genuine communist subgroups of it, but it's careerists at the top who won't do anything major out of fear of alienating their mostly left-liberal base. They aren't anti-communist, yes, but they don't exactly advance it either.
Still, it is the second largest party compared to UR, and if/when Putin eventually fucks up enough to lose, just leaves politics from being old, or a more competent and further left party leader replaces Zyuganov, it might have greater potential. Maybe china's success and influence will lead to it gaining traction.
As for Putin? He's... something of an odd figure in politics. His political stance is whatever gets him the most support and success over his political career as opposed to a fixed ideal or ideology. He's flip-flopped on Stalin/the USSR, the monarchy, and moved from trying to integrate with the west to cooperation with newly rising powers out of circumstance. China to him is simply a very useful and predictable ally against the west and he can't risk striking at the KPRF and creating major political disunity that could be exploited for a color revolution, even moreso during an active war.
How is the KPRF liberal? Russian liberals are literally antiPutin and have been protesting the SMO and supporting Zelensky and the west since day 1. Your antiKPRF position sounds much more liberal to me, they attack the KPRF as sellouts to "excuse" its supposed "pro russian imperialism stance" and then proceed to shout "no war but class war", "fuck Putin", and "Putin must stop its war on Ukraine". We have had several russian "leftists" repeat this position to us here (not saying you are one).
Oh no, the war is entirely justified.
I'm using liberal in accordance with how it's used in theory; to describe those that support the idea of capitalist democracy/dictatorship of the bourgeoisie.
The simple truth is that the KPRF leadership is not one that seeks revolution or a complete removal of capitalism at the current time.
What, the KPRF isnt procapitalism, which would make them liberals. I think the word you are looking for is reformists, meaning they support socialism but not revolution, aka Karl Kautsky.
I dont believe they are reformists imo, they were at the forefront of revolutionary struggles against Yeltsin in the 1990s, and today still are leading struggles in unions and against the anti worker policies of the Putin administration. Sure they have moderate themselves in the last 10 years, but thats imo the correct position, they are promoting a united front with Putin and United Russia to fight off the western imperialist attack on Russia. Increasing class struggle at this time would only benefit the US imperialists by dividing russian society and weakening the Putin administration which is currently engaged in a war with the west. Once the west is completely defeated and Russia is safe then they will surely do that, when its appropiate.
Ohh ok, nice to see you support the SMO. We have had too many russian liberals pretending to be communists here, so everytime i hear "KPRF is sellout" i automatically think they must be antiSMO liberals. Sorry my bad.
From a russian communist POV (and I am one) the actual policies of the KPRF smells too much of social democracy. But theoretically they still are a revolutionary party. We just all agree that a lot of leaders of the KPRF are quite comfortable as legal opposition and renounced to seek revolution, while other smaller communist parties (who also support the SMO) stand out as more revolutionary, but are politically irrelevant.
Is this a position which they make explicit? If so, how do they theoretically justify it?
They’re not a real communist party. They’re kept around for Soviet nostalgia, Russian nationalism, and boomers. Like Putin unveiling a Stalin bust to reference defending the motherland. All the Russian political parties are a scam.
From a russian communist POV (and I am one) the actual policies of the KPRF smells too much of social democracy. But theoretically they still are a revolutionary party. We just all agree that a lot of leaders of the KPRF are quite comfortable as legal opposition and renounced to seek revolution, while other smaller communist parties (who also support the SMO) stand out as more revolutionary, but are politically irrelevant.
Why is this simplistic tripe being upvoted? This doesn't conform to reality at all.
What is that even supposed to mean? CIS, BRICS, SCO & full spectrum cooperation, all point to a completely different picture.
Yeah, some bizarre reductionism and myopic analysis in that post.
if you analize over 20 years of Putin's rule you would most certainly agree that he was overall much more west-focused in his economic policy. The russian oligarchy is ideologically westoid, there's no way around it. If you think about it, it's quite strange that a lot of very needed economic and military agreements with China and Iran started only after the 2014 Ukrainian crisis. Russia was forced on the path of multipolarity by the western hostility, but that isn't the dream scenario of the russian elite.
Putin is a whatever the fuck keeps me in powerist