PracticalMind9OP•

Hi, OP here. I am comparing the Tatcha Classic Rice Polish to the SRB enzyme powder wash. I've been personally replacing most Tatcha in my collection in favor of AB products like CosRX, BoJ, etc. In doing so, I figured I'd put out some reviews for people who might also be looking for alternatives to Tatcha since their products are at a high price point for their benefits and also they are sketch with their advertising.

So, long story short: The SRB performs equally well as the Tatcha rice powder. If anything, despite the SRB appearing more coarsely granular, it actually foams/lathers better and does a better job of degranulating into a soft foam versus Tatcha and is like 1/3rd the price.The only downside to both of these products is that they can occasionally feel slightly stripping when my skin is in it's dry phase. I will be repurchasing the SRB powder.

Feel free to share any other rice powder wash formulations y'all like!

61
highlimerence•

Love this project! Keen to see what your alternatives are for their moisturisers — I started using the Overnight Repair mask recently and found it feels the same as Innisfree Orchid Enriched Cream for the most part (similar texture; product feel; level of skin hydration etc)

12
flrxo•

Do you mean their indigo overnight cream?? I’ve been dying to find a dupe, I’ll have to look into the innisfree!

5
highlimerence•

Yes! The Indigo Overnight Repair — I splurged on it hoping it would blow me away but... it didn't. I kept thinking I preferred the Innisfree Enriched Cream while using it.

4
PracticalMind9OP•

I may have to try the Innisfree as well! I like the texture of the Tatcha overnight cream a lot.

5
lhaluu•

I love this powder wash. I agree that they can be drying and for that reason I only use powder washes on days that I feel I needed it the most. 1-2 times per week. Now I’m trying Tosowoong Enzyme Powder Wash. it’s a bit more coarse than SRB, slightly fragrant doesn’t dissolve fast as SRB, but performs the same. Next I want to try is the Wishtrend green tea powder wash.

5
PracticalMind9OP•

I've also been interested in the Wishtrend. After I finish the SRB I might have to go for that or the Tosowoong. But at least now I have an inexpensive and very good powder cleanser!

2
YueRainBlogger | beautyfaceskin123.blogspot.my•

oh not the wishtrend green tea powder wash is so harsh on my skin.

1

Yes, I have found this kind recommended by some experts

0
salonpasss•

One time I went mad over these rice powders and tried a bunch- Tatcha, Junico, Dermalogica, Suisai, Amore Pacific and a Korean brand with a blue cap I forgot the name hah) I really like suisai but the individual plastic containers seemed so bad for the environment.

The best one was dermalogica enzyme powder- I felt and saw a visible difference in terms of softness and texture plus it didn't leave my skin dry after rinsing. Along with that, Sephora sells refill packet!

16
lhaluu•

Could be Tosowoong Enzyme Powder Wash

6
salonpasss•

Ooou yes! Actually, it was quite good give the price point. Tatcha needs to wake up with these prices because what in the world

2
fax5jrj•

Have you tried the Milkfoliant?

3
salonpasss•

No, not yet! Just the original Microfoliant

1

The best one was dermalogica enzyme powder

Which one did you use? They have 3/4 different types of powder

1
salonpasss•

The original one with the gray cap! I don't use it every day, maybe just 3x a month or before I do a clay mask. Remember to really massage the powder with water before applying it to your clean face

2

How do you find the Dermalogica one (which I think you liked best?) compares with the Tosowoong one? (I’m thinking of changing/upgrading but still on the fence)

2
salonpasss•

To be honest, I tried Tosowoong very long ago so I can't remember exactly how it was! For Dermalogica, I like adding it into my routine because I notice a visible difference! When I use a clay mask in conjunction, I find my skincare absorbs better too. During the pandemic, it was harder to get skincare from Asia, so being able to buy Dermalogica at my local Sephora without any wait time is a bonus as well.

2
FaceHobbyist•

SRB was one of the first AB products I found to replace Tatcha samples I tried way at the beginning of my start in skincare. I completely agree with your assessment - SRB grains dissolve better, lather better, and gave a better overall experience than the Tatcha.

8
PracticalMind9OP•

I'm really liking it and glad I tried it.

1
Noroeste•

Hi, sorry to drag up an old comment but I’m in the middle of researching the Tatcha powder and your extremely helpful post jumped out at me! Are you still using/liking the SRB powder these days (~3 months since you posted)?

1
PracticalMind9OP•

Hi! Yes, I still use and like the SRB. I plan to continue buying it.

2
suneesideup•

thanks for taking the time to review!! I was looking into both products actually but I think I'll pass on tatcha this time 🤔

6
PracticalMind9OP•

I'm currently all in for the SRB :)

2
drinkmaxcoffee•

What does SRB stand for?

6
PracticalMind9OP•

I think it's their brand name and it stands for "stabilized rice bran" which is the main ingredient in their powder cleanser. But I could be wrong!

4
kablammywhammy•

I preferred the SRB and Dermalogica powders over Tatcha.

3

Dermalogica powders

Which one did you use?

1
kablammywhammy•

Just the daily one. My skin tolerates occasional scrubs better than chemical exfoliants.

1
YueRainBlogger | beautyfaceskin123.blogspot.my•

Tatcha is so expensive. I am also using the SRB one too. the Tosowoong is a bit rougher. Suisai is also a bit harsh on my skin. The one i find quite good is the Comeitto rice powder wash which is a Japanese brand

2
slowbamboo•

Ooo I remember getting a SRB enzyme wash sample and loving it. My only issues is that they're kinda messy to use compared to a regular cleanser. Does anyone have like a solution for that or is it just part of it.

1
PracticalMind9OP•

I use a facial cleansing brush in conjunction with my cleanser for a little extra exfoliation, so I use a little bowl, pour the powder in, get the brush damp and swirl it in the powder till it becomes frothy, wash my face and rinse the bowl.

2
slowbamboo•

O thank you! That sounds a lot less messy than how I was doing it before.

1