Is a 3.1 setup possible without a sizable AVR?

Purchasing US

In our fairly minimal living room there's a frame tv mounted above the fireplace. I'd like to set up some sort of 3.1/3.0 arrangement because our top desire is 30 consecutive minutes of tv/movie watching without having to turn on subtitles.

I believe I can place three speakers in this it-must-be-minimal-and-attractive constraint, but I really don't want to have to have a big AVR box. Aside from the size, any input device switching is going to be pointless capability because it's always going to be the one streaming box connected through the television. I neither need or want the additional complexity of running something through an AVR.

Spending time going through old posts I find a lot of discussion of 2.0/2.1 setups using something like the Loxie A30 and that's really about the physical size of what I'd like to add here. But it lacks any center channel capacity - I presume because it lacks any surround decoding ability. I am not 100% adverse to going this way but I'd really like that center for speech clarity.

Discussion of 3.1 setups all talk about AVRs. Searching around I have come across stuff like this Pyle PFA540BT but I have no idea whether it's trash and I'd also prefer to just stick with the optical output from the Frame for simplicity's sake, rather than needing to have it inline . Perhaps that's a non-starter, but I was under the impression the optical was decodable into full surround. Am I wrong?

It seems like there should be some solutions out there, but perhaps there's just not enough market space in between folks who will accept a soundbar and folks who will just accept having a larger receiver? Am I wasting my time here looking for stuff that doesn't exist?

(I know there's a decent sized contingent that thinks 3 channel isn't a worthwhile improvement over 2 channel and I'm not super dug-in on this but that voice clarity is #1 with a bullet so I'm making this effort before giving up on the center channel)

Posted Feb 22, 2023, 5:54 PM UTC

113
jbmc00•

I can safely tell you anything Pyle is trash.

Slim surround sound receivers largely don’t exist (outside of some specialty and very expensive products). You might look for a deal on an older Marantz NR series.

Otherwise go with 2 channel or a quality soundbar.

7
rickra7.2.4: Arendal 1961 | Hsu VTF-15H | Epson LS12000 | Onky TX-RZ50•

There are a number of generic DACs on Amazon that claim to decode Dolby 5.1 via optical, but buy at your own risk. I wouldn't trust any of them. You could pair them with powered speakers if you are looking for a science project. Volume control will be extremely janky,, but let us know if you find something that actually works reliably.

The unfortunate state of things is there isn't an affordable, reliable, and compact solution for your situation.

3
phearlezOP•

Oh well, I knew that was a good possibility. I'm definitely not interested in a science project because every ounce of complexity here increases the likelihood I get called on to do family tech support. The time my wife or kids are watching tv should be when I can get other things done, not unfucking the sound on Paw Patrol or whatever stuff the kids watch.

1
401klaser•

put the AVR in a closet / basement

2
phearlezOP•

Not a bad idea, though doing the cable runs would be a hassle and it doesn't solve the complexity issue. I'd like to avoid introducing one more thing for which I'd be tech support for the family.

1
AutoModeratorMOD•

99.9% of the time Soundbars or HTiB (Home Theater in a Box) systems are not a good investment of your time and money. It is the general consensus of r/hometheater not to recommend these things and instead simply steer a user toward a 2.0 or 2.1 system made of quality, Audio-Centric name brand components which are easy to assemble and cheap enough for low budget or space conscious buyers. Most can be expanded to 5.1 if you buy the correct items in the correct order. For further explanation please read Why You Shouldn't Buy a Soundbar Please be aware r/Soundbars exists as well as you will be met with opposition to posting about soundbars here.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
AutoModeratorMOD•

All you need to know about Wireless Speakers - Please read here )

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
phearlezOP•

I'm getting the message here that of my list of ideas I may as well just accept 2.1. For which this buying guide is a big help, so thank you!

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
slackinfux•

If you're going to buy Pyle, you might as well just get a 3.1 soundbar and be better off for it.

1
HelvenOP•

Not sure I can add much, more, but I was in the same boat for a while. I found to really get the best use for the 3.1 I HAD to go to an AVR. Then I just kept going down the rabbit hole and now am at a 5.1.4.....

For small amps I have heard some good things about Fosi Audio da-2120a. But again, it's not 3.1 but 2.1....

However, my stop gap I have found that good tower speakers that are positioned correctly do serve, at times better than stand-in for a dedicated center, until you go full surround. When I run my SVS prime Pinnacles as L/R and my powered sub, the dialogue is VERY CLEAR and sometimes when I am just watching Netflix or regular TV I prefer a 2.1 system to a poorly mixed, poorly compressed 5.1.4 Atmos setting.

Good Luck 🤞

1
MurrayTDang•

The PYLE receiver is only a good option if you are buying cheaper lower end speakers(and at this point I would just buy a sound bar lol), otherwise you would be ruining the capabilities of a higher quality speaker. In your case, If you don't want to deal with a hassle of a large AVR and want higher fidelity audio capabilities then I would highly recommend a good set of powered bookshelf speakers. For example my brother in law got a set of Klipsch fives(HDMI input, very loud, tons of bass, enough clarity for dialogue) but many people have said the SVS prime pro and Elac Debut Connex are even better(and more money of course).

0
phearlezOP•

I am officially warned off Pyle now. The powered bookshelves with HDMI are a thing I wasn't aware of. I'm not sure it's the way for me but I'll look into it, thank you.

1
sfdude2222•

You should look into the powered speakers with HDMI. Your tv remote will control the volume and it makes it very user friendly.

1