Zigbee alternative to Shelly Motor controller
I've been looking for a Zigbee alternative to the Shelly Motor controller. I have found many "Tuya Zigbee" controller in Aliexpress but after reading some horror stories about lack of electrical certification, electrical shocks, overheating and even burning, I'm truly worried to hook up anything that is not CE / UL certified.
Do you know any reputable alternative to Shelly using Zigbee? Should I just go Wifi for this specific automation?
On the other hand, Sonoff has a good range of Zigbee switches (but not motor controller). Are
Sonoff products properly certified?
Thank you!
Posted Feb 27, 2023, 8:38 PM UTC
05
Is there something special about this Shelly that makes it a "motor controller"? Because it looks like a two channel relay to me.
If it really is just a two channel relay then Aqara makes the LLKZMK11LM that seems to be what you want.
It does power metering allowing software to detect the fully opened and closed position.
https://zigbee.blakadder.com/Xiaomi_LLKZMK11LM.html
This supports power monitoring as well, unless there's still something I don't understand about the Shelly.
The advantage for the Shelly 2.5 is that it's UL listed and has a current monitoring chip that's compatible with ESPHome's current based feedback cover. The current feedback cover makes it easy to setup for obstruction detection and stall detection.
https://esphome.io/components/cover/current_based.html
If the Aqara and its current monitoring chip is ESPHome compatible, it wouldn't be a bad thing to have in the bucket of parts.
My only concern (apart from electrical certifications...) is that the two channel relay would not have any protection on both relays being active at the same time and I the shelly does if you configure it to be a motor driver.
After some investigation the LLKZMK11LM can be setup to only have one relay active at time. The last feature shelly has is that it closes the relay when it detects no more current is consumed (i.e. the curtain reached fully open or closed)
Do you know if the aqara does it too?
I can’t say that I do