Does the city have sidewalk plows working?

Large stretches of main road sidewalk completely unplowed risking injury as people are stepping in holes made by other footsteps and if someone steps wrong they could sprain/break something.

Great example (among many) is the northwest corner of King and Harmony.

Posted Mar 5, 2023, 3:07 AM UTC

025
LarryJr-K•

A lot of what people think are municpal walks are actually private.

People often get confused, frustrated and upset without even knowing...

A lot of condo complexes and town home complexes are like this...big long city sidewalks that the complex is supposed to clear.

Perfect example was my team at the Oshawa Hospital yesterday morning. At hour 22 the city had still not plowed Hopsital Crt or Parkwood Crt. My team had all the walks, parking lots, garages looking spotless and crunchy blacktop with salt and ice melt including all walks on both those streets and Simcoe.

They look like municipal walks but they are not. They are private and maintained by the hospital.

Only to have shift change, and all the staff losing thier minds on my team for the roads not being plowed.

"Do your fucking job", "We're front line workers you know", I'm going to complain to your head office"

We don't even look after the road. Infact... if I touch the road, I take liability for anything that happens after the fact. I'd not only lose my job but my commercial insurance due to my blatant negligence.

We try not to take it personal, We know your really upset with the city and not us. Not gunna lie though.

After a 22+ Hour shift, it hurts to be yelled at, especially for areason that your not responsible for.

Sorry to high jack your post OP with a story. I just thought it was an important one to share.

16
Karma_Canuck•

I always did my best to treat the snow removal crew well. To spite the fact that we were told to report you for even using the washroom...

It's not the chemicals that make that building toxic.

6
LarryJr-K•

Haha, I've never in my life... but I do appreciate you guys letting the team in to pee.

Even though it's against the rules.

Thank you for that.

3
Modal_WindowOP•

Are you guys supposed to be like Amazon workers and pee in pop bottles?

1
LarryJr-K•

Gross. No, we go find a bathroom. Tim's, McDs... it's a good excuse to buy the team a hot drink too.

1
Modal_WindowOP•

This is good, thanks for sharing. You also mentioned something that is interesting to contemplate too, municipal walks.

The sidewalks are owned by the municipality. A lot of people have the impression that their land goes up to the street itself but this is not so, the portion below the sidewalk is municipal yet the city has somehow the power to compel people to donate their labour to maintain those city portions by cutting the grass or shovelling the sidewalk. Nobody questions it because it looks better and it's tradition to do so.

It's just strange though. How is it that one can be ticketed for not mowing the curb in front of them but also not share a responsibility for the curb a street over?

My mother lives in TO and the city has a sidewalk plow that comes by for that subdivision's streets, it's not a main road. It's a nice thing TO has that we don't.

They sometimes but not always have windrow clearing. We definitely don't have that. Jealous. I know windrow clearing makes the job longer but sticking people with giant ice walls to break up and clear like I need to do today is not it either.

Thanks for the hours you are putting in, please be safe. 22 hours without sleep is too much.

5
JeffDavis4•

We don't even look after the road. Infact... if I touch the road, I take liability for anything that happens after the fact. I'd not only lose my job but my commercial insurance due to my blatant negligence.

Larry, thanks for adding that. Most people don't seem to understand that it is illegal not only to put snow onto a street but to plow a municipal roadway without a contract. Commercial insurance for snow clearing is unbelievably expensive and has taken many landscapers out of the winter business. You can't risk your livelihood, your entire business, to do someone a 'favour' or to help out an overburdened municipal snow crew..

Some contracts, some municipalities, include municipal sidewalks in their contracts. A lot of snow contractors don't want anything to do with sidewalks. It is hard to get good labourers that are willing to work the hours in crappy weather, consistently. The insurance risk is high.

Private contractors often work to a higher standard or expectation than municipalities. Often contracts will specify a minimum level of snowfall before specific actions take place, ex, at 3 cms of accumulation, but municipal action might not take place until after snowfall or after a larger accumulation, or the famous 'at the discretion of...' While there may be obvious differences in the parameters, it ultimately comes down to the management who are the decision makers.

And most commercial property snow contractors are not unionized, so they work around hours of work. Commercial trucks and unionized workers don't put in the number of consecutive hours that most property maintenance contractors do. So, we get the jump on the regulated municipal workers who are required by law or employment contract to park their vehicle even if the job isn't done.

My last job of the day yesterday was final clean-up at a residential complex. One of our big tractors had been in earlier in the day to 'open up' but I get to go back in with my more compact machine to do the finesse work. Residents will move cars in the hope that we will clear their parking spaces, some will clear the snow from the cars in the middle of the driving lane so they don't have to shovel it, etc.

I had the standard complaints that the big tractor left too much snow behind my car and I couldn't get out.... the big tractor pushed snow into my parking space... blah, blah, blah.. Just relax everybody, give me some time to make things right! MOST people are really good and thankful that we come back and try to do the best we can. They are even understanding of the 'half effort' to open up in the middle of a storm without being too fussy.

But there is always that one (in this case the driver of a Smart Car) that just isn't happy no matter what you do... Yes m'am, I see there is a foot of snow in front of your car. Yes m'am, that was my boss this morning in the big tractor that left that snow in front of your car, please call HIM and complain! Yes m'am, I will move that snow, but not right now, you see, I have a plan for how to do this lot.... No m'am, I don't have time to sit here and argue with you, and NO, arguing with me will not get your Smart Car out any faster... Yes m'am, I am indeed an asshole and for that, your Smart Car just went to the bottom of my priority list, but it is still on the list!

And she stood there in disgust for 30 minutes watching me until it was finally convenient FOR ME to clear that snow from in front of her toy car! I think it actually broke her face to come over and thank me for what I would have done 20 minutes earlier if she had just left me alone! lol

Then there is my 'regular' customer, who, regardless of the time of day, ALWAYS comes out to move his car so that I can have the pleasure of clearing his parking spot! He is very fortunate to have empty spots on either side of him, so it is easy for me to get in with the big blade and scrape it down to bare asphalt and back drag it to almost summer conditions. He had a 'little run-in' with my boss earlier in the day, who was simply too busy, too stressed, too uncaring to wait for all those cars to move at their leisure. Also, his equipment is massive in those tight spots, 1.5 times wider and 3 times longer than my machine. My regular started the conversation with "a big green....." Yeah, I know, he's my boss and he's always in a hurry... "But he pushed snow into my parking space against the concrete wall..." No worries, I will TRY to get it all out.
"How did you like that Polish beer I gave you a couple weeks ago?" That was damned awesome, thank you so much, I really appreciated it at the end of my shift. "Well, I have another one.." and he tried to pass it through the window. Ahhhh, these are the moments that make it so worthwhile!!

But I'm still just a part-timer. Can't seem to get the hours that Larry Jr gets. 17.5 hours straight this time. Two coffees to go. Two Gatorades. One fuel stop. No lunch breaks. While you are exhausted at the end, there is still a certain adrenalin rush until the end of that victory beer of thanksgiving!

I wouldn't want to work for the municipality with all their rules and management. But I absolutely love plowing snow! It has its moments, like any job, but we are FRONT LINE WORKERS that keep our communities going!

2
TTBoy44•

They might be a little busy.

9
Valuable-Bug-3447•

So let's get this straight, you expect everything plowed 12 hours after the snow has stopped?

6
Modal_WindowOP•

Snow started 24 hours ago, so yes. I expect some effort.

Former Husky gas site at Ritson and Bond wasn't plowed for 2 weeks. I think someone eventually did one side themselves a few days ago, but not the other side.

Basically, if homeowners are expected to be shovelling the snow within 24 hours as per bylaw, I expect that the commercial and city sections to have the same obligation.

It's not even that hard. You just sit in a powered vehicle and drive around. Homeowners have to use a shovel if they don't have a blower.

-5
Valuable-Bug-3447•

24 hours after snow has stopped, not from when it starts. Yea everyone thinks some one else's job is easy until they try it. Tell you what, let's double our property taxes so they can double the snow removal crews.

11
slingbladde•

No, they can keep mismanaging all levels of govt and contracts, the amount paid into govt pales in comparison to the services we receive nowadays, get those 4x4 trucks out there, and have more than 1 guy in the truck.

1
Modal_WindowOP•

They might as well spend it on something useful instead of awful crap like the spiral wrap lights they put up in the downtown core.

-8
formal-shorts•

The city doesn't plough sidewalks on private property so would they do the gas station lot?

2
JeffDavis4•

It's not even that hard. You just sit in a powered vehicle and drive around. Homeowners have to use a shovel if they don't have a blower.

LOL.
I would love to see you put in a full shift and see how your attitude changes!.
Unfortunately, I highly doubt my boss would let you anywhere near the controls of any of his equipment. Even though my 'machine' is 10+ years old, you wouldn't replace it under $120,000. But I am sure you could master it in no time and teach me a few things that my 25+ years doing this job hasn't.
There are always job openings in this line of work....
Unfortunately, your lack of experience is an insurance risk.
Any idea how much damage those powered vehicles can do when mis-operated?
Or how much danger a rookie is in??
One good hit to a curb can cause 1000's of dollars in equipment or property damage or injuries to the operator or bystanders.
But it's not hard work for an arm chair critic! lol

2
Modal_WindowOP•

To be clear, I'm not talking giant street plows, I'm referring to those little chair things with the little blade in front and a cover, no wider than the sidewalk itself.

1
JeffDavis4•

I am well aware of what you think you are talking about....

The city uses Trackless MT7 articulating all-season sidewalk plows. The last purchase record that I can find is from 2017, at a cost of $142,528 plus HST. (report FIN-17-79) It's a lot more than a 'little chair thing with the little blade in front and a cover'. It comes with a salt hopper and drop spreader, has an option for liquid brine or for a snow blower attachment.

It's not the toy that you think it is. I watched one go by my home last evening, and kudos to the operator, because that was a huge and difficult windrow to break through. I live on a one way street, so the full amount of street snow is on my curb/sidewalk, and I commend the operator from last night.

2
Chucks_u_Farley•

Not to be an ass, but shouldn't 20 Harmony clear that instead of the city?

4
Modal_WindowOP•

Sure, but the unplowed continues everywhere. Not plowed in front of Eastdale CI, not plowed from intersection past Kingsview United on Adelaide, etc. There's a lot of places not plowed.

1
Chucks_u_Farley•

Yup, fair enough.

2
PurplePanda1971•

The bridge sidewalk over the tracks just south of Olive on Ritson isn't cleared yet either. You can't walk on the street there so its basically uncrossable for pedestrians. This isn't anything new, I used to have to walk my kids to school-if the bridge wasn't clear they didn't go.

3
JeffDavis4•

Here's the city's map of the sidewalks, trails and paths they plow.

https://oshawa.maps.arcgis.com/apps/instant/basic/index.html?appid=74eff6bbdd6b4301910e7b0df7da2801

2
Modal_WindowOP•

Thank you for sharing this. It is a very informative helpful reference. I found it very interesting to see which areas are marked in black. I was out for a walk earlier, and made note of unshovelled sidewalks still, and according to the map the locations still undone as of tonight are not city responsibility. I wonder if some of them know that? E.g. one place where the house on the corner, the driveway and front door is on a side street, but the other long side which is unshovelled is on Harmony, etc. Or maybe they just don't care or are unable to do it because of the ice? That's possible too. It's the end of the season so it'll be gone soon anyway.

The areas I complained about before that are definitely red marked, have now been done, and I can tell a large machine must have come by, not just the Trackless MT7, because the snow has been taken away. It's not tall mountains anymore.

1

Blows were getting stuck, I doubt they had those little tractors out

1