Regarding a moral dilemma
Hey there, I just wanted to know if anyone knows about a particular moral or ethical dilemma similar to this one:
An ill patient visits a doctor. The doctor has the cure. The cure could give 10-20 years of life to the patient, but the doctor will only provide for 2 years. The doctor also tell the patient that they can die at any time, that even if they change their lifestyle to the most healthy path, the patient won't live more than a year. All statements are true. What would you do as the patient?
Posted Mar 8, 2023, 8:45 AM UTC
I’m confused about how all of those statement can be true. If the cure will give them 10-20 years how can they have at most 1 year to love with the healthiest life style? How can there be a cure that will give them 10-20 years if the doctor will only give it to them for 2 years? Wouldn’t that make it a treatment me not a cure?
Yeah, technically it would be a treatment not a cure what the doctor offers in this example.
Without any treatment, the disease or illness will inevitably kill the patient within a year, maybe even a day, there is no way of knowing, but the more exercise and good habits the patient does, the better chances the patient has to live a little longer.
The cure or treatment would technically give a long life, but the doctor will only offer 2 years of it, even if he logistically could do it for longer. For whatever reason, he just offers 2 years.
The main point is how people would react given they know all to be true. The cure or treatment won't make them sick, other doctors would also offer 2 years, it's not about asking for a second opinion or something like that.
But, for instance, the patient could choose to use their time to find a cure or treatment for themselves, for example, since it doesn't go against the statements of the dilemma itself. The patient options are not limited to take or not the cure is what I'm saying.
Okay. Sounds like the moral thing to do is for the doctor to not arbitrarily stop treating her patient after 2 years. At least assuming a standard quality of life.
But you are the patient, not the doctor. As a patient, you can very well question, attack, try to bribe, go to the newspapers,... As far as you know, the doctor may do it for money, for obscure reasons, for giggles, or for unknown or even known reasons, that you may or may not agree with.
The reason I'm looking for similar dilemmas is to check if in these kind of one-sided situations if the common behavior would be to just take the 2 years. I have ask several people this dilemma, and all but one person out of twelve ended up just taking the 2 years. But I haven't found any similar dilemmas, to see if there is some research regarding the outliers and general distribution of answers.
I mean the self interested thing to do would probably be to take the two years of life, at least if we presumed that there is an interest to stay alive for as long as possible. But this seems more a pragmatic than an ethical question. The only person in this scenario that’s doing something with any moral weight here is the doctor. As far as I can tell the patients options are all morally neutral and the only reason to discern between them are self interested ones.