Am I being Pedantic?

Twice today I explained to two different techs that forwarding a port is completely different from opening a port on the firewall. Even after the explanations, they were still asking me to forward ports x,y, and z for ip <blank>, not understanding why I was asking what ports they wanted each one forwarded to.

Note: These techs specialize in the equipment they are setting up, including firewall settings...

Posted Oct 17, 2012, 3:27 PM UTC

112
nonkn4mer[Han] Solo sysadmin•

Does your job have an ocean view? If so, I'd happily relocate and replace both of your techs.

3
jaywalkkerStandalone...so alone•

Did you try an analogy?
I don't know, I wouldn't acll your experience pedantic at all. These guys are apparently looking for the easiest configuration to make things work instead of the right way. Yeah, admin rights for everyone will also get stuff to work quickly, doesn't make it a smart f'ing idea.

2
telemecanique•

more like they still don't understand the difference and didn't listen to his explanation either.

2
MonsieurOblongSenior Systems Engineer - Unix•

explain it once, and move on.

2
richardtatasJack of All Trades•

The very nature of our craft is to be pendantic. Technology starts to go down the toilet if things aren't exactly as they're supposed to be. Common terminology is also crucial.

2
ex0sJack of All Trades•

ask them to take a look at any TCP/IP book. or any networking book...ROFLMFAO.

this is rudimentary stuff here..

0
[deleted]•

This isn't pedantry when it is basic fucking knowledge that involves two completely different concepts.

0
iamadogforreal•

Don't be "Mr Technically Correct - The Best Kind of Correct." Its obvious what they meant, you understood it, just do the work and save yourself the stress of correcting people all the time.

-1
anonymousme0805•

The flipside is, this is standard industry speak. I get not correcting users, but if you don't correct those that you work with, or those that work for you, then they continue to make these mistakes and it could actually hurt those people in the future, like if they go to interview for a job because they want to move on and try something different.

I would correct them and explain why I'm correcting them. I would do it 3 or 4 times. If they continue to mess it up, I would shutup about it unless there was a possibility that they really did mean forward a port/forward some ports, then I would verify their request.

6
itreferenceOP•

Honestly? No, I didn't know what they meant.

I wasn't sure if they were using the wrong words or if they were missing information that I needed to get the job done. I guessed what seemed most plausible for what they wanted, and it turned out right.

3
telemecanique•

guessing when it comes to firewalls is always a good idea :)

3
munky9001Application Security Specialist•

Sometimes it's not worth fighting over the details and just better to play the political game against those techs.

I find that when wrong people who will argue with you over and over like this just won't be swayed so you spank them so hard that they dont dare try the same shit again until they literally know they were right.

For example. I had this ERP vendor who was blaming just about everything except their product. Literally had an email where the vendor shows network and sharing center where it says 'no internet' for a minute before it does the check and they say the server doesnt have internet access. Literally they were saying that on that basis is why they were having the problem and it's my fault.

So i begin the spanking procedure. I literally form it into a 'why does this server need to access the internet? This is a security concern and shouldn't be accessing the internet.' they eventually admit that the issue was irrelevant and wrong. I then go further and run sysinternals against their app and proved they had installed their application wrongly.

They 'took this under advisement' but we haven't had them blame our configuration anymore without good reason. The flipside problem I suspect might be occurring is that they are unchecked and changing things in the environment without permission or scope. I am waiting for the instance to remove their power.

-1