Government option ?

Ok may sound a really stupid question. But why are labour and other parties not pushing for state owned companies (or if they are im just not seeing it) for essential service such as electricity, Gas, water and housing ect.

We are constantly told how it will cost billions in fees to renationalise everything. So my question is why bother ? Just create a state owned company to compete with the others. Were the responsibility is to us the tax payers as the share holders ?

We are constantly told but capitalists that the competition breads efficiently and innovation. So make them live by it. And we are constantly told how bloated and inefficient most solely state owned enterprises were, so in this case make them compete and give the customer the choice.

When it comes to essential services and utilities things being left in the hands in sole of private enterprise has allowed monopolies and duopolies to form were the private companies have either have no real competition and can do what they like or in effect work together to make the higher profits. And most egregious situations when it comes to essential services act like what can only be described as virtual protection rackets. If your run small business or just want to live there practically “making you an offer you cant refuse” your a cash cow to be milked without mercy !

Wouldn't a state owned company in these situation in effect get the best results and make capitalists live by what they preach

Posted Mar 11, 2023, 2:27 PM UTC

35
AutoModeratorMOD•

The labouring classes in this country are rising, will you rise with them? Click Here for info on how to join a union. Also check out the IWW and the renter union, Acorn International and their affiliates

Join us on our partner Discord server. and follow us on Twitter.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

Because they want poor people to die. That’s not a side effect, that’s the point. Their goal is to hoard as much as they can at the expense of humanity, of the planet, of anything longer term than their fragile egos.

1
therealzeroXOP•

that's the point from the Torie party. i just find it strange that labour & the greens are not putting it forward.

1

Red tories and green tories are still tories I’m afraid.

1
retrofauxhemian•

What you ask is probable/pcapable, but gets shot down as not 'muh free market' as state utilities have an unfair presence due to natural monopolies and bottomless liability. Something private companies in the same situation srtrangely never have.

Labour (TM) aren't calling for a change, because they are mostly liberals, and at best occasionally, social democrats that believe in the capitalist mixed economy. Which you could argue wouldn't be bad on paper, if it weren't only from the perspective of the Capitalist and managerial class. They find it very hard to argue against capitalist ideology, vested interests, and class solidarity (their) even when a revolving door job after isnt involved.

We are constantly told how it will cost billions in fees to renationalise everything. So my question is why bother ? Just create a state owned company to compete with the others. Were the responsibility is to us the tax payers as the share holders ?

Buying the state infrastructure back on the shareholder terms, will cost Billions, but still some cases actually be cost effective, such as the proposed renationalisation of rail by Corbyn in 2019. Replacing natural monopolies, would require even greater cost, and be reliant on duplicating all existing infrastructure, even when that is masssive beyond imagining. You could feasibly do it in places, but not everywhere.

This is where the rub of needed renationalisation hits a brick wall. It's not train companies, it's the track, not your electric company, but national grid and ditto for British Gas etc. If you introduce shell companies beholden to this infrastructure, you effectively just license pissing that money away, whilst taking the blame for the cost. Incidentally also exposes the game, and as a shareholder you couldnt make money off of the process for very long.

Wouldn't a state owned company in these situation in effect get the best results and make capitalists live by what they preach

The rules exist for thee, not for me...

1