Not guns but still arms: Knife Rights sues to end CA's switchblade ban
kniferights.org/legislative-update/knife-righ...Posted Mar 17, 2023, 7:21 AM UTC
Posted Mar 17, 2023, 7:21 AM UTC
#I want a switch blade katana because it’s my fucking right BONTA
and soon after i will want my lefts, because my severed rights will be on the ground!
While we are at it the baton ban law needs to be struck down as well
Yeah, it’s idiotic that I can walk around town with three loaded handguns on me but keeping an ASP in my glovebox is a felony.
I don't understand how using a less than lethal tool rather than KILLING SOMEONE is worse. I will never understand this dumb fuckin bullshit
Less lethal*
NY had a nunchaku ban before it got struck down with the 2-step approach
Ninja stars too! They are currently illegal.
But we can get drunk and throw hatchets indoors or carry throwing knives on our belt as long as our shirt doesn't cover the handle.
Ballistic knives too.
Still no nunchucks or throwing stars?
RACISTS!
Still no cane guns?
Ableism!
Cane sword— also denied.
Ageism!
It would be nice to be able to carry a Microtech and an ASP out of the house.
Microtech does make 1.9 inch models for the CA market. The exocet has a surprisingly useful amount of blade for being so small
LA county law limits carry to 3in blade, and state law limits to even smaller on campuses. Just going to pick up your kids from school or drop off a package at a university could make a lot of people felons for carrying a swiss army knife. That shit has to go away!
The limit on LA county is for open carry. You can legally conceal carry a folding 16” katana if it fits inside your pocket.
It's complicated. https://knifeup.com/los-angeles-california-knife-laws/?amp=1
It would seem to be the case that a folding assisted opening pocket knife would qualify under "spring blade" and possibly under one of the other catch all provisions.
In any case since state law requires you to display fixed blade knives on a belt sheath, and LA law makes that illegal, it's illegal to carry a fixed blade knife anywhere in LA county. So that's gotta be against the second amendment since fixed blade knives are "in common use for lawful purposes"
Also the state provisions on no carry on campuses of blades longer than 2.5 inches is also unconstitutional it does not make sense to say that the entire campus of UCLA is a "sensitive place" perhaps certain administration buildings or the campus police office or something but not the entire campus
The problem is that we have entered an era were everday objects people want to own can be banned by laws. That is what must end.
We entered that era 100 years ago when they banned alcohol
Switchblades are legal to own and keep in your home, regardless of length.
"The right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed."
Unless they are dangerous and unusual in terrorem populi. I must note that Heller’s dicta said that one is banned from carrying them, not outright possessing them.
I always felt that at bare minimum we should be able to keep our rifles set up normally inside our homes like how we can own switchblades but cannot take them outside the house.
Switchblades are legal to own and keep in your home
The complaint cites a 2009 case on Page 6 where a defendant who was being searched at home was charged for possessing a switchblade.
In at least one instance, a California appellate court has held that the State’s Knife Ban extends to possession even within a private residence. See In re S.C. v. S.C., 179 Cal.App.4th 1436 (2009) (police discovery of a switchblade in defendant juvenile’s pocket during a search conducted at a private residence could result in defendant being found to have violated then-Penal Code § 653k1 even though defendant did not possess the knife in a public place or place open to the public). As such, under the Knife Ban, there is a direct threat of criminal prosecution for the mere possession of common automatically opening knives with a blade length of two inches or more even in one’s home.
Here is the case in question and the "holy shitballs they actually went there" language:
Construing the language of section 653k, we conclude the statute is violated anytime a person carries a switchblade knife on his or her person, regardless of where the possession occurs. We therefore affirm.
[deleted]
Balisongs being illegal is even more silly. Like if you can carry a locking folder and you can carry a fixed blade, literally what is the reason for balisongs being illegal other than scared ignorance?
Have you ever seen a Chinese martial arts movie or similar? The lawmakers did
Like all power and control hungry laws, its starts with oppression of a race.
Ever played Team Fortress 2? Butterfly knives are scary.
Think about it it is kind of dumb. Just banning something because it looks scary. But it’s perfectly legal to open carry a Rambo knife…
2A rights protects all arms.
Brass knuckles has entered the chat
Nice
[deleted]
They should sue California’s restrictions on the manner of carrying.
Sweet! I love and collect knives and there's quite a few I'm not technically allowed to carry. Hopefully they can just remove the ban of any type of knife. Be it double edged, butterfly, auto, etc. they are tools first at the end of the day. Most the ones that are banned are not exactly all practical either... Like no point in banning a butterfly knife they are the slowest to open... Just flashy when you do it!
Finally
This is going to lead to a rise in Greaser vs Socs violence.
It’s so weird I know gun laws like the back of my hand. But I don’t know shit regarding knifes and etc.
It’s time to get those other weapon bans struck down.
I carry a Kershaw launch 4 1.9" CA legal blade every day. I purchased the nicer Launch 11 that just hangs out in my house to open boxes. It's a scary 2.75" blade. It would be amazing to be able to carry that. I never understood the issue here. Pure ignorance on the part of lawmakers.
Say it with me people all arms are covered under the 2nd amendment
Thank you, Caetano v Mass.
Under Caetano: Guns are protected, knives are protected, halberds are protected, yet-to-be-inbented laser weapons are protected.
If I'm being candid though, I think that is likely to change if we ever see a challenge to the NFA. I wouldn't be surprised to see a 2 tier definition of militia-relevant arms vs all other arms, where those useful to an individual in a militia get maximal protection, while other weapons are more open to time\place\manner restriction.
So you’re saying the two tier system would have halberds made harder to get while laser weapons remain readily available, as they’re more suitable for use by the militia, which is all of us? Interesting idea.
I think that would follow most closely with the Text. Individual self defense isn't mentioned, so what we have to work with is that the purpose was to be able to raise together for localized defense of our communities. The text says "State" but I think it's reasonably applicable to the County, City and Neighborhood levels. Black Panther cop-watching to defend their neighborhoods seems like a fair example of what I mean.
Hell yeah I wanna carry a halberd
Since it's a fixed length blade I don't think there's anything preventing a person from open carrying a halberd or broadsword. I'm not a lawyer and this isn't legal advice.
At least where I am, you have to keep a fixed blade visible and sheathed at the waist, so wearing a sword is fine (I've even used one as part of a costume). I think a halberd would fall under the same laws as an axe though
One can’t carry concealed, which is stupid. This needs to be struck down.
Hand grenades.
Ok I get it. But do I need to cover my legs too?