Struggling to Shift from Two-Player Magic
For most of my Magic-playing career, I have only played 2-player forms of the game, typically Limited with the occasional Constructed formats, with Cube drafts as a near weekly Casual format for several years.
I recently moved to a new city, and it seems that EDH is the primary format played nearby, and I am struggling to adapt how I think about the game. Part of that is multi-player card evaluation, since the relative efficiency of cards which trade one-for-one such as removal and counterspells seems completely different, yet eschewing them completely definitely spells doom. There is going to be some Game Theory at play with regards to how they should be included in decks and played during the game, given that three players at the table are usually invested in certain threats not existing, but I am not sure I can readily process that without a lot more experience of the gameplay.
The other aspect of this is that I am typically a fan of 'Small Games' of Magic, enjoying cards like [[Liliana of the Veil]], [[Dark Confidant]], [[Gravecrawler]] and other grindy low-resource strategies, and spent years curating multiple cubes in which careful resource management was encouraged. My impression is that EDH is not particularly conducive to that sort of strategy, since it is difficult to grind down 3 players at once, though I did have a go at putting together a decklist using [[Tinybones, Trinket Thief]].
While feedback on that list would be great, I would much prefer feedback on the viability of trying to bring 'small game' strategies to Casual EDH tables, or just general advice on how to think about resources in a multi-player game.
Posted Mar 19, 2023, 12:30 PM UTC