overweightvoidOPDBN - EOD•

Sinn Fein

That Dáil Éireann:

notes that:

— the State remains in the midst of a housing emergency;

— the Government has chosen to end the emergency ban on evictions on 31st March, 2023;

— the Government, in making this decision, has increased the stress and insecurity experienced by the 750,000 people, including working families, living in private rented accommodation;

— the Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage has admitted that homelessness will increase once the current eviction ban ends;

— according to the Residential Tenancies Board 7,539 eviction notices were issued from January to September in 2022;

— only a handful of tenant-in-situ purchases were completed in Dublin in the last year;

— emergency homeless accommodation is at breaking point; and

— the Government has no contingency plan in place to deal with the increase in homeless presentations when the current ban on evictions ends; and

calls on the Government to:

— extend the emergency ban on evictions until the end of January 2024;

— expand the tenant-in-situ scheme for both social and affordable cost rental tenants;

— use emergency planning and procurement powers to target vacant and derelict buildings and new building technologies to increase the supply of social and affordable homes above the existing 2023 targets; and

— urgently commence the biggest social and affordable housing programme in the history of the State so that people can access secure, affordable housing to buy and rent.

No sign of the Gov amendment yet.

37
Elbontaking a sip from everyone else's tea•

new building technologies to increase the supply of social and affordable homes

That's a nice way to say prefab

23
DuckyDublin•

Nothing wrong with prefabs. They would be more than sufficient as a multi year stop gap till we got our shit together.

48
pastey83•

I live in an Eastern European communist-built panelak (panel house–ours is an apt block), and I can safely say it's better than any Celtic Tiger apartment I ever lived in. It's reasonable soundproofed/insulated/organised and I'm surrounded by greenery. However, our balcony's shit.

I live near a Sidliste (housing estate–think Ballymun, but with more flats and no crime) that's f*cking massive and yet you're always a short walk from shops/health/public transport.

There's a case to be made that if the commies can do prefabricated houses (on a vaaaaaast scale) to a reasonable standard—with adequate facilities—then we should be able to do equally as well, if not better.

49
WarningAble6077•

There's a case to be made that if the commies can do prefabricated houses (on a vaaaaaast scale) to a reasonable standard—with adequate facilities—then we should be able to do equally as well, if not better.

The only thing was communists were not driven by a profit-motive,

clowns here will probably want to put extra tax on anyone in a higher floor for excessive use of lift/stairs

17
DuckyDublin•

Exactly this.

1
Action_Limp•

There's a case to be made that if the commies can do prefabricated houses (on a vaaaaaast scale) to a reasonable standard—with adequate facilities—then we should be able to do equally as well, if not better

When have we ever demonstrated that we would be better than the commies at infrastructural development?

-1
NoseComplete1175•

Stop gaps and temporary in government speak are a pseudonym for permanent. Particularly in terms of tax

4
Champz97•

There's nothing more permanent than a temporary solution

1
DuckyDublin•

So true in Ireland unfortunately.

1
CalRobert•

Better than some pile of crumbling blocks.

3
litrinw•

I would love nothing more than to be able to rent my own affordable 1 bed prefab.

1
Elbontaking a sip from everyone else's tea•

Why rent when you can buy https://www.donedeal.ie/caravans

0
Ambitious_Handle8123Palestine 🇵🇸•

What's the issue with prefabrication? Modular homes need 1 dry day of construction. Perfect for our climate. R values are higher. Environmental impact is lower.

1
svmk1987•

Better than homeless.

1
PaleolithicLure•

The last two points are key:

​

— use emergency planning and procurement powers to target vacant and derelict buildings and new building technologies to increase the supply of social and affordable homes above the existing 2023 targets; and

— urgently commence the biggest social and affordable housing programme in the history of the State so that people can access secure, affordable housing to buy and rent.

They're asking for a temporary a temporary extension to an emergency measure in an emergency situation, and have proposed long term solutions. It's an entirely sensible proposal given the ongoing housing crisis. I'm sure the "poor landlord" brigade will completely ignore that though.

18
CaisLaochach•

Are you serious?

Let's look at one aspect of this in clear terms - vacant and derelict buildings.

  • What is the definition of a vacant and/or derelict building?
  • Who determines their status?
  • How many such buildings are there?
  • How many are fit for habitation?

Nothing in the motion suggests a repair programme.

Let's take issue number one.

https://revisedacts.lawreform.ie/eli/1990/act/14/revised/en/html#SEC3

3.—In this section “derelict site” means any land (in this section referred to as “the land in question”) which detracts, or is likely to detract, to a material degree from the amenity, character or appearance of land in the neighbourhood of the land in question because of—

(a) the existence on the land in question of structures which are in a ruinous, derelict or dangerous condition, or

(b) the neglected, unsightly or objectionable condition of the land or any structures on the land in question, or

(c) the presence, deposit or collection on the land in question of any litter, rubbish, debris or waste, except where the presence, deposit or collection of such litter, rubbish, debris or waste results from the exercise of a right conferred by or under statute or by common law.

Where are these sites? In 1990, large swathes of Dublin were clearly derelict, especially in and around the areas that are now the IFSC and Grand Canal Dock. This akin to saying the problems with the HSE today are due to a lack of leeches.

As for a vacant site:

https://revisedacts.lawreform.ie/eli/2015/act/33/revised/en/html#SEC5

5. (1) In this Part, a site is a vacant site if—

(a) in the case of a site consisting of residential land—

(i) the site is situated in an area in which there is a need for housing,

(ii) the site is suitable for the provision of housing, and

F2[(iii) the site, or the majority of the site is—

(I) vacant or idle, or

(II) being used for a purpose that does not consist solely or primarily of the provision of housing or the development of the site for the purpose of such provision, provided that the most recent purchase of the site occurred—

(A) after it became residential land, and

(B) before, on or after the commencement of section 63 of the Planning and Development (Amendment) Act 2018.]

and

(b) in the case of a site consisting of regeneration land—

(i) the site, or the majority of the site, is vacant or idle, and

(ii) the site being vacant or idle has adverse effects on existing amenities or reduces the amenity provided by existing public infrastructure and facilities (within the meaning of section 48 of the Act of 2000) in the area in which the site is situated or has adverse affects on the character of the area.

(2) In this section—

“site” means any area of land exceeding 0.05 hectares identified by a planning authority in its functional area but does not include any structure that is a person’s home;

“home”, in relation to a person, means a dwelling in which the person ordinarily resides (notwithstanding any periods during which the dwelling is vacant) and includes any garden or portion of ground attached to and usually occupied with the dwelling or otherwise required for the amenity or convenience of the dwelling. 

So empty sites in Dublin >0.5 Ha. Interestingly, sites which include a house are not on the list. Most large sites in Dublin that remain extant would be the grounds or gardens of a large house. That's one hell of an easy dodge.

But it gets better. According to the motion SF want to "target vacant and derelict buildings." What does that mean? Threaten them with a punishment beating? Targeting as a verb means to select as an object of attack. What form of attack is envisioned?

Do people really fall for this sort of empty rhetoric?

12
AmckinstryGalway•

Registering a site as derelict essentially requires the council to CPO it. And then renovate. In many instances this doesn't work as the councils don't have the money to do so.

It works well in places where the council has sufficient funds and buys up a neighbourhood for renovation. Think Leeds, canal zone.

In the Irish context it mostly works with an "agreed CPO": ie the council and landowner agree to the CPO. While this sounds like a contradiction in terms, often a landlord doesn't have clear ownership and can't act -- eg land registry issues or probate. Often this can leave properties in a mess for decades - the CPO route gives a clean legal route to sell up and for the property to be renovated or developed.

But there are limits to what can be done on the "derelict building" route as it stands. Better vacant property / site value taxes are the answer here.

1
CaisLaochach•

I'm not even touching upon those issues.

I'm asking how SF plan to identify these sites and what they intend to do to them.

1†
popcorndiesel•

It's nothing more than a proposed land grab. Probably sites will be sold off to cronies of SF for development. Finding properties is the easy part, just walk around Dublin City centre and look up at any building, most are derelict or empty shells from the 1st floor up. Will these be "targeted"?? I have no doubt that any SF land grab will be from a local governments level where properties can be targeted under the guises of doing in in the interests of the local community.

0
CaisLaochach•

How so? They don't even have a plan to grab land.

2
EJ88Donegal•

target vacant and derelict buildings." What does that mean? Threaten them with a punishment beating? Targeting as a verb means to select as an object of attack. What form of attack is envisioned?

Good lord, clutch them pearls harder Cais

-1†
CaisLaochach•

Odd, do you not know what they plan on doing?

1†
slamjam25•

Temporary like the USC?

9
jcirl•

Temporary like Mosney

2
Fargrad•

How long is temporary?

3
overweightvoidOPDBN - EOD•

The issue being that would be a money bill and must stem from government.

1
karma-toes•

Which emergency is this? Is this the pandemic or housing or are they just rolling one into the other? How about some actual legislation on tenants rights instead of arbitrary bans lads hah? Contracts, co-ownerships, housing associations like, some balance of rights instead of just senstationalising the absolute shitshow that is the Wine Gaelers

-5
Inspired_Carpets•

Can someone educate me about Dail motions, what is the purpose of them? If SF manage to get the votes and this passes, what happens next? Is there some obligation on the Government to follow though or is just a statement by the Dail that it wants XYZ to happen that the Government can ignore?

21
overweightvoidOPDBN - EOD•

They can ignore anything that costs money, even if it passes a vote.

Private members Motions are kind of like an easy summary of positions. They don't need legal review.

Fundamentally they put down the current party position and move on.

Saying that they can form a platform for committee review and policy change, albeit any motion needs to go through legislative gateways to become a law.

Government motions will generally be used to co opt non legal policy, and or define agreement with EU legislation.

18
Inspired_Carpets•

Thanks, I appreciate you taking the time to respond.

4
danm14•

They can ignore anything that costs money, even if it passes a vote.

And the Government currently (maliciously) interprets this as "costs any money" - treating it as an outright veto on the decisions of the Dáil, because every bill costs something to implement.

1
Briancl12•

I really doubt they expect this motion to pass, probably just to raise question marks about the coalition, since Neasa Hourigan of the Greens said she’ll vote for it. They’re trying to put the coalition on shakier ground.

1
Inspired_Carpets•

Yeah, I get the political reason for doing it I just didn’t understand the process if a motion is passed.

1
TwinIronBlood•

I think this is more of an election stunt than anything else. They want to extend the ban till January so people will face a winter eviction again.

Tenant insitue purchase mean buying adhoc houses and apartments with different management and maintenance needs but the councils don't have tye people to manage it.

Using procurement is something good but its miss directed. There are plenty of boarded up council housed. Get the back into use. They don't need to be A rated B3 wod be fine. Rewire replumb insulated new windows and doors. Click flooring.

One thing is you often here of people getting a council house and destroying it. If you do you have to fix it. Or leave. No sympathy.

12
slamjam25•

They’re an opposition party, literally everything they do is an election stunt. That’s the job.

4
TwinIronBlood•

No it's to hold the government to account

1†
gadarnol•

Independents voting against govt. The group with the keenest sense of danger in the Dáil smell trouble……for their seats. Time to bank some credibility.

9
DrOrgasmDaycent•

There's an awful lot of people sniffing which way the wind is blowing at the minute.

4
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
Irate_Alligate1•

And it's gone

0

Brilliant.

Current phase "Building" : We'll pull all the builders off site from the A+ energy rated housing estates they are working on (that are mandatory nowadays) and get them to start erecting inefficient port-a-cabins with kitchens in them.

Securing the current supply : We'll have no new private landlords in the most restricted market the world has ever seen and we'll be left with a country that resembles a halting site. The people in the port a cabins will claim they are discriminated relative to those in lovely warm houses and they'll be right.

Future "sustain" : Once they hike up the corpo tax to pay for their shanty towns, and the 280,000 ex multinational employees join the housing list we can enter phase 2 of Sinn Fein's master plan "Operation Mud Shack".

-2†
niall0•

What’s that about the energy rating ?

1

Every new house built in Ireland has to be built to an A rating. You wont get A rated emergency prefabs with air to water heat pumps, underfloor heating, triple glazing & solar panels etc.

The state owned sites they are proposing putting these prefab estates in aren't zoned for development i.e. they aren't on bus routes, train routes, arent serviced by shops or hospitals & don't have any access to services

1
niall0•

I see what you mean now, to be fair If it’s modular homes your talking about that contains a massive variety of construction types, from timber crane to precast concrete to the old shipping container type prefabs

1