Do you think less of games without a setting?
It always seemed obvious to me that the inclusion of a setting in a RPG was unnecessary, and any such setting was generally an indulgence for the creator. I don't hate games with settings, far from it! But I always think a game is better without baked in worldbuilding. However, I've learned over time that more than a few people seem to prefer systems with a setting- even a very strong setting- and I'm not sure I understand why.
There are exceptions, of course: the Dune RPG, Alien, Star Trek, etc are built around the setting with the express purpose of exhibiting their worlds, but I'm really only talking about games without a preexisting setting adding one in to an otherwise independent system.
No one needs to justify their reasoning of course, but as I'm working on a few different RPG projects it's probably important I understand more about what value settings bring to any potential audience.
Alternatively: if you also don't like the inclusion of settings, I'm also interested in those reasons; Strongly "set" systems tend to get in the way of whatever it is I want to use them for at the table, and usually require more modding than systems without, but your reasons may differ!
If it helps:
Games I generally consider setting-dominant:
Stars Without Number (the Scream, Tech classifications, historical assumptions)
Blades in the Dark (Duskvol, and Dishonored theming)
Games without strong settings:
The Burning Wheel
Apocalypse / Dungeon World
(both games explicitly direct you to create your own setting)
Posted Mar 26, 2023, 12:10 AM UTC
Personally I use the implied or explicit setting to gauge the tone of the game, which is much more important to me than the actual setting. That tells me how to run the game, versus just giving me a bunch of lore.
Ooo that's a good point. I realized shortly after posting that I should've differentiated between setting and theme, but there's definitely at least one more axis for tone.
Do you think that purpose could be served by play examples some games include (which I've always hated for other reasons)?:P
Maybe? I don't like play examples myself, but they can be helpful.
I'm trying to think of alternatives to play examples (which are universally terrible, in my experience) and setting documents; I'm almost wondering if more simple things like references to outside media that inspired the system might help, sort of like Fabula Ultima. It uses very little in the way of explicit text to convey its tone, but still manages to get "dramatic, heroic, romantic" across to the reader through visual rhymes with Final Fantasy tropes.
More to ponder :)
There are many different types of DMs - and they are the people you are selling your system to - but you could make broad subgroups:
People who buy systems based on the mechanical nuances, the things that are mechanically unique or how tight the math is.
People who buy systems based on how much the flavour, setting - and to an extent, the reviews - inspire them to run a game in that system.
It's a broad pair of categories - and there are going to be exceptions - but you can cover nearly everyone you are going to try to sell your system to in one of those two hoppers. Given that's the case, your system will do best if it can cater to both groups, and that is especially important when you are competing in a market that contains a product like 5e that has (had?) 90% market share...
I have a friend who is wholly in the first camp, who could not care a jot for the setting that a system comes with. I also have several others who are much more in the second group, and I have gradually moved from the second to the first as my experience has grown. I think that especially for new GMs, a system setting is a safety net.
Probably not, IMO. Aside from them being universally loathed (you, I, and PorterPirate are unanimous on that point, at least) they also tend to be too short to really serve that purpose. They're typically no more than a page in my experience, maybe two, and include enough "this is how the table works" filler (reading off die rolls, "this is something a rookie reader would wonder, not something an experienced player would really ask"-type questions, etc.) that there's not really room to also convey tone unless you greatly increase their length.
I think play examples may even beat out "What is an RPG?" for my most loathed section of every book ever published :D
I'm wondering if, instead of either play examples or long bouts of prose, the layout of the system- including graphical elements and the like- should be the primary method of tone conveyance. I mentioned this previously, but Fabula Ultima does a fantastic job here: from items having tiny pixelated sprites, to an entire chapter just being called "Press Start". You immediately know what they're going for, and they never really have to tell you anything. There's certainly no lore or worldbuilding happening, but you don't really… need it.
But still people have differents view of what is an RPG. Or at least how to play an RPG. Play examples can be good for the creator to tell the reader that this game is about
Graphical elements, layout, is good for setting a feeling about the game!
I think play examples in text would not be effective and nobody is going to read them. I was thinking of using QR codes instead (clickable in the PDF) that pull up short video examples.
As for tone, I think the GM is going to determine most of that. The setting has a lot to do with it as well. Once you pull the setting and change GMs, what's left ...
Well, what some might call a "heroic" game I would consider "pointless because you can't die". There can't be heroism without danger! You aren't much of a hero without the insurmountable odds to oppose you, so the real heroic games are the ones where rescuing your friends puts you in real danger.
And GMs are always going to house-rule or ignore stuff they don't care about. I could have chapters full of rules for intense hex-crawl, gritty survivalism, rules for sickness from stagnant water and infections and the GM can just say "you make it to the next town in 3 days, mark off rations". And neither style or tone is wrong, so I fully support runnings things both ways.
Yeah! Video examples would definitely help a looot more. That's probably the best idea I've heard on this front.