r/rpg•
Hadrius

Do you think less of games without a setting?

Basic Questions

It always seemed obvious to me that the inclusion of a setting in a RPG was unnecessary, and any such setting was generally an indulgence for the creator. I don't hate games with settings, far from it! But I always think a game is better without baked in worldbuilding. However, I've learned over time that more than a few people seem to prefer systems with a setting- even a very strong setting- and I'm not sure I understand why.

There are exceptions, of course: the Dune RPG, Alien, Star Trek, etc are built around the setting with the express purpose of exhibiting their worlds, but I'm really only talking about games without a preexisting setting adding one in to an otherwise independent system.

No one needs to justify their reasoning of course, but as I'm working on a few different RPG projects it's probably important I understand more about what value settings bring to any potential audience.

Alternatively: if you also don't like the inclusion of settings, I'm also interested in those reasons; Strongly "set" systems tend to get in the way of whatever it is I want to use them for at the table, and usually require more modding than systems without, but your reasons may differ!

If it helps:

Games I generally consider setting-dominant:

Stars Without Number (the Scream, Tech classifications, historical assumptions)

Blades in the Dark (Duskvol, and Dishonored theming)

Games without strong settings:

The Burning Wheel

Apocalypse / Dungeon World

(both games explicitly direct you to create your own setting)

Posted Mar 26, 2023, 12:10 AM UTC

22165
PorterPirateFate, Cepheus Engine•

Personally I use the implied or explicit setting to gauge the tone of the game, which is much more important to me than the actual setting. That tells me how to run the game, versus just giving me a bunch of lore.

89
HadriusOP•

Ooo that's a good point. I realized shortly after posting that I should've differentiated between setting and theme, but there's definitely at least one more axis for tone.

Do you think that purpose could be served by play examples some games include (which I've always hated for other reasons)?:P

7
PorterPirateFate, Cepheus Engine•

Maybe? I don't like play examples myself, but they can be helpful.

6
HadriusOP•

I'm trying to think of alternatives to play examples (which are universally terrible, in my experience) and setting documents; I'm almost wondering if more simple things like references to outside media that inspired the system might help, sort of like Fabula Ultima. It uses very little in the way of explicit text to convey its tone, but still manages to get "dramatic, heroic, romantic" across to the reader through visual rhymes with Final Fantasy tropes.

More to ponder :)

4
Erraticmatt•

There are many different types of DMs - and they are the people you are selling your system to - but you could make broad subgroups:

People who buy systems based on the mechanical nuances, the things that are mechanically unique or how tight the math is.

People who buy systems based on how much the flavour, setting - and to an extent, the reviews - inspire them to run a game in that system.

It's a broad pair of categories - and there are going to be exceptions - but you can cover nearly everyone you are going to try to sell your system to in one of those two hoppers. Given that's the case, your system will do best if it can cater to both groups, and that is especially important when you are competing in a market that contains a product like 5e that has (had?) 90% market share...

I have a friend who is wholly in the first camp, who could not care a jot for the setting that a system comes with. I also have several others who are much more in the second group, and I have gradually moved from the second to the first as my experience has grown. I think that especially for new GMs, a system setting is a safety net.

3
dsheroh•

Do you think that purpose could be served by play examples some games include (which I've always hated for other reasons)?:P

Probably not, IMO. Aside from them being universally loathed (you, I, and PorterPirate are unanimous on that point, at least) they also tend to be too short to really serve that purpose. They're typically no more than a page in my experience, maybe two, and include enough "this is how the table works" filler (reading off die rolls, "this is something a rookie reader would wonder, not something an experienced player would really ask"-type questions, etc.) that there's not really room to also convey tone unless you greatly increase their length.

6
HadriusOP•

I think play examples may even beat out "What is an RPG?" for my most loathed section of every book ever published :D

I'm wondering if, instead of either play examples or long bouts of prose, the layout of the system- including graphical elements and the like- should be the primary method of tone conveyance. I mentioned this previously, but Fabula Ultima does a fantastic job here: from items having tiny pixelated sprites, to an entire chapter just being called "Press Start". You immediately know what they're going for, and they never really have to tell you anything. There's certainly no lore or worldbuilding happening, but you don't really… need it.

6
Runningdice•

But still people have differents view of what is an RPG. Or at least how to play an RPG. Play examples can be good for the creator to tell the reader that this game is about

Graphical elements, layout, is good for setting a feeling about the game!

5

I think play examples in text would not be effective and nobody is going to read them. I was thinking of using QR codes instead (clickable in the PDF) that pull up short video examples.

As for tone, I think the GM is going to determine most of that. The setting has a lot to do with it as well. Once you pull the setting and change GMs, what's left ...

Well, what some might call a "heroic" game I would consider "pointless because you can't die". There can't be heroism without danger! You aren't much of a hero without the insurmountable odds to oppose you, so the real heroic games are the ones where rescuing your friends puts you in real danger.

And GMs are always going to house-rule or ignore stuff they don't care about. I could have chapters full of rules for intense hex-crawl, gritty survivalism, rules for sickness from stagnant water and infections and the GM can just say "you make it to the next town in 3 days, mark off rations". And neither style or tone is wrong, so I fully support runnings things both ways.

4
HadriusOP•

Yeah! Video examples would definitely help a looot more. That's probably the best idea I've heard on this front.

2
Cl3arlyConfus3d•

I prefer games with no setting. I feel like it gets in the way since I'd rather homebrew my own stuff.

27
PicklePinata2•

Agree. I've even tried sticking with their setting but always, without fail, throw it out part way through and sub my own

5
Durugar•

I find games like Dungeon World and Butning Wheel has enough strong setting thematics that you end up with a clear idea of the setting. I like both types if your examples. The one I get turned off by is the ones that tries to be a million settings and thus the clear idea of direction falls apart, Thirsty Sword Lesbians is to be a big offender in this category. The game looks and sounds so cool, but it just.. falls over when you try to picture what the setting looks like.

26
Mister_Dink•

Unless I'm misunderstanding you....

Thirsty sword lesbians has a series of settings for you to use. They're very minimal, giving you the bones so that you and the players can tailor them to your liking. They're almost like the pitch of a TV show:

In this school of magic and treachery, can your disaster lesbian survive? With a page explaining how to set the pitch/setting together.

There's no unified settings, but the tools to create 12 different ones are included.

I found that sufficient, but I inderstand why others totally wouldn't.

2
Durugar•

Yeah like I think a few of the settings are really cool but I think the way they present them is.. Detrimental to the design. The problem we ran in to was at session 0 everyone kinda had very different ideas of the settings. It created this space where everyone came to the table with very different ideas of setting and it was basically impossible to unify for us.

It's just a very important place for me when running games where the game kinda failed me. I wanted a bit more focus.

2
Mister_Dink•

Totally fair.

My friends and I run a new system every 8 months or so, but we always vote on the system, and then discuss setting, before session zero / creating character. So I see that the way we run things totally, accidentally, subverted the issue you ended up experiencing.

2
Durugar•

Yeah I think what we ran in to was that everyone was in to the idea of TSL and I offered to run but none of them really came with much idea and I just could not direct that group properly, it was not my regular group and it was people I have had problem with running for before.

TSL just didn't land for me, there is a bunch of cool ideas in it that I think are great but it just... I can't get a feel for it in my head, and one of the big factors is that setting can be anything kinda vibe. I can't get a clear mental picture.

Glad you liked it though!

2
CalamitousArdour•

What inspired TSL? Are there any touchstones? I'm having the same issue, I've never really seen the type of story that it could represent. And it IS a narrative game so surely there is some predecessor somewhere.

0
HadriusOP•

I haven't read that yet! But I'm definitely in agreement. I have this issue with D&D too, naturally, but the folk culture around it makes it a lot easier to handwave away all the ridiculous, nonsensical, directly contradictory setting stuff. I think because so many people have issues with the setting, it's a lot easier to walk away from it.

But an indie title like TSL would be much more difficult to handwave, because most customers probably bought it for its novelty; who would be willing to handwave a baked in setting for a system that only has the setting as its differentiator?

-1†
Durugar•

Going to break my rule of replying to a post that pointlessly snipes at D&D 5e on this sub. I get it, you all hate it.

I have this issue with D&D too, naturally

Honestly I think D&D 5e has a really good mix of setting in Forgotten Realms but with enough freedom to let GMs add things they think are cool. All the small inserts and lore bits in even the PHB is all focused around creating a feeling of setting but has their root in Forgotten Realms. Hell the example character they use is fucking Bruenor Battlehammer. All the lore parts of the races and classes at the start of each of them is specifically based in Forgotten Realms. I wouldn't say D&D is any more contradictory or nonsensical than most other games when you start digging in to them either. However, the game is not so attached to the Forgotten Realms that if you move outside it or change things it falls apart.

I think this is a place where D&D is massively succeeding and where, honestly, Pathfinder or Warhammer is failing for me. It is too specific in all it's regions and areas. There is too little presented in the core book to give me a feeling of what setting is like, but then it is immediately a deep dive in to hard lore for every damn location in that setting. A game like Blades in the Dark is up there for me as a gold standard for this kind of stuff. It is a small contained setting that is hard baked in to the game.

But an indie title like TSL would be much more difficult to handwave, because most customers probably bought it for its novelty; who would be willing to handwave a baked in setting for a system that only has the setting as its differentiator?

You clearly have not read TSL? It has multiple suggested settings. Which was part of their Kickstarter goals. That is the problem. It wants to both be Scifi, and Artdeco, and 1920s noire, and Medieval Fantasy - on the same skeleton of a game. You are supposed to pick one of the settings or make your own at the start of the game as a group but because the game has no focus what so ever we have no place to come at it from.

They are also published under Evil Hat, it is not an indie game. We need to stop calling every game that isn't Pathfinder, D&D or CoC indie.

9
HadriusOP•

That wasn't an attempt to snipe at D&D- that's been the complaint more than a few of my players have had with 5e, and it's been repeated often over the 8 years I've been running it. That doesn't mean I haven't had fun playing it, I have. It means the game isn't perfect, and some people have issues with it. I'm not attacking your personal experience with it.

​

I wouldn't say D&D is any more contradictory or nonsensical than most other games when you start digging in to them either.

Perhaps not when compared to Golarion, but when compared to Duskvol or similar, smaller settings, the cracks start to show, and it can become a problem at the table. Things like "The Weave" have been of exceedingly high import at some tables I've played at, and nothing so related has ever been intuitive to me, nor seemingly to any others at the table.

​

I think this is a place where D&D is massively succeeding and where, honestly, Pathfinder or Warhammer is failing for me

I definitely agree with you here, as above.

​

You clearly have not read TSL?

I explicitly said as much in my last comment; I have not read it, no. My point was that any-given-indie-title is going to have higher expectations placed on its contents from beginning to end than something like D&D will be, because the latter is a must-buy for most of us. I have my issues with 5e, as above, but I would buy another Player's Handbook same-day if something happened to mine. There are several other games I feel that way about too, but more than a few that have rules that I like more than 5e that I wouldn't bother with, because they don't offer as much utility to me as what D&D does, generally.

​

We need to stop calling every game that isn't Pathfinder, D&D or CoC indie.

There is no "we" here. You're free to do as you please.

0†
Durugar•

I'm tired, it's fuck in the morning here, but good discussion! One last reply.

I'm not attacking your personal experience with it.

Oh I know. I just am kinda done with everyone in this sub needing to be "D&D bad" when discussing anything at all. In the larger context of this sub it gets extremely exhausting that every conversation has to go there.

Things like "The Weave" have been of exceedingly high import at some tables I've played at

But that is one of the things I think is so great about the game. They give the GM and the group enough space to make their own answers and take the game in their own direction without having that lore nerd "um, ackshually" things. They can with Forgotten Realms, don't get me wrong, there is plenty of books out there, but it is not baked in to the core.

but when compared to Duskvol or similar, smaller settings

Honestly, comparing Duskvol, a single city that only has to work for one very specific narrative setup to the entirety of the Forgotten Realms and it's several decades of writing and retcons when it comes to consistency is, well, unfair. You don't have to go far before Blades also starts to fall apart.

I explicitly said as much in my last comment; I have not read it, no

I just wasn't entirely sure which game "it" referred to so just wanted to be sure that my assumption was clear.

My point was that any-given-indie-title is going to have higher expectations placed on its contents from beginning to end than something like D&D

That is not my expectations going in to them or assumption though. If a game is made by one person out of their own pocket and I picked it up for €5 at a Pay What You Want, then I have WAAAAY lower expectations than I do of "The Worlds Greatest Roleplaying Game" that is designed by big teams and play tested by thousand of fans over years, and you have to shill out $50 for and is on it's 5th edition and literally dominates the market.

If I can find one cool thing in an indie game that I like I am more than happy, it can be a single mechanic or world building detail, or hell, something in the GM section that just inspires.

There is no "we" here. You're free to do as you please.

Literally missing the point here. TSL is not "indie". It has a publishing house behind it. It is not "independent".

Good talking, have a good one!

5†
Ytilee•

A lot of games without setting also do not know what they want to be, or loose themselves in trying to be realist (which is dumb when you do not have a specific reality to emulate in mind). Having a setting is often proof enough the creator has a clear vision of what they're trying to accomplish and let at least something on the cutting board. It's obviously not always true, but it's at least often corelated.

Also it's way, WAY, easier to parse and judge a setting than a system, which will hopefully give you a good enough idea of what the system will try to aim for. Something doubly true when you're in the stage of deciding if you want to read/buy the game in the first place.

22
HadriusOP•

Especially given this point:

Having a setting is often proof enough the creator has a clear vision of what they're trying to accomplish

…how integrated should the setting and system be? Does there have to be overlap, or could the system be a separate object in the document, not at all required to play the game?

2
Ytilee•

As I said, it's not about what it should be, this is only a heuristic I personnaly use to judge a game. There are unfocused messes with very specific universes in mind (just take a look at 90% of heartbreakers that gets posted on the TTRPG design subreddit) and very focused and interesting games with no universe in mind (FATE is controversial, but it knows what it wants to be even though there is no setting packed with it).

If you want actual guidance from a design perspective, I'll say that any game system should have a precise aim, and this aim can be to emulate a specific world or fictional genre/tone, to create interesting choices, to self express... Anything basically that you feel worthy of your time and attention. But it has to try to achieve something specific.

But, from a marketing perspective, you better be prepared to be able to sell this vision to your target audience in a way that will make it appealing and (that's where the catch is) distinct from the others. And when you're trying to get the attention of someone, you have very little "attention bandwith" to work with, and can you actually sell the specificities of your game system in this limited space? It might be way easier to sell the universe that this system emulates even if in the end, once the attention is grabbed, the player ignores/replaces/modifies this universe.

6
WilderWhim•

I think the best way is to have them be one and the same. Troika has so little hard lore on it's setting it's kind of silly, but the game text is written in such a masterful tone that it's setting is almost completely implied. Even still, I feel it has one of the strongest settings in TTRPGs period. The way of Troika might not work for everyone, but finding a way to illustrate setting through mechanical design will feel most cohesive, and grant the best experience learning and playing a system.

2
Hoagie-Of-Sin•

Yes.

If I'm looking for one thing to play that takes hours of my time and requires organizing a social event I want to see that the creative behind it cared about it enough to have on opinion on how it should he used and what ideas it contained, even if I disagree

13
HadriusOP•

So if you want every system to have something in place as its setting, how deeply incorporated does that setting need to be? Should you, given your "Yes.", have to know how the lore of a particular world to be able to play the game?

I think that's perfectly fine if that's your answer, and there're games out there that are really really good that do precisely that, but I find the concept reflexively offputting.

1
Cwest5538•

Honestly I don't think it's an unfair opinion (mostly) but I think that "the creative cared enough about how it should be used and what ideas it contained" corresponding to setting" is just... not really that correct overall. There are plenty of universal games and things with a lot of heart put into them that don't have a setting for a reason- not having a default setting doesn't inherently mean they just didn't care enough to write a setting, it can absolutely be a stylistic choice or because they just felt like it didn't need a setting.

4
HadriusOP•

Perhaps I wasn't clear, because I completely agree! I don't really understand where the "the designer didn't care about this game they spent years on because there isn't a setting included" comes from. The two things are very separate in my mind.

3
Cwest5538•

Ah! I was agreeing with you, mostly. It's just a... interesting take that I don't agree with. And I tend to answer lower down in the reply chain. To clarify, I don't think that "I want to see the ideas contained behind it and the tone" are unfair answers- I think the tone is a very fair one- but yeah, "they just didn't care" is just a wild answer.

2
Hoagie-Of-Sin•

I'm more so saying that the care that is evident, and the care that occured are two different things.

I can be a very passionate accountant, my work doesnt look any different from an accountant that absolutely hates thier job as long as we both do it right. The sheet is still balanced either way.

This is why I'm fairly against designers ultra engineering thier statistics before they have anything that visibly looks good like prose, setting, tone, page layout, images, etc.

You could have the most balanced tactical combat bellcurves for all of your math and best written abilities and best organized page structure in existance. If you have no style, you have no appeal.

Because I cant see any of the fruits of your labor, and frankly people dont care if you care, if it never convinces them to take it off the shelf or open the pdf and read the meat of the rules.

0
aurumae•

I think the discussion around RPGs with and without settings is often very confused, because the assumption tends to be that there are two types of RPGs (those with settings and those without them). However like most things the truth is that RPGs fall along a spectrum, which can be grouped into three broad categories:

  1. Strong setting RPGs: These RPGs are designed with the assumption (implicit or explicit) that you will be playing in a particular setting. Most of the best examples in this class are licensed RPGs, like The One Ring RPG, Avatar Legends: The Roleplaying Game, or Warhammer Fantasy Roleplay. However many other RPGs also qualify for this category such as Legend of the Five Rings, Vampire: the Masquerade, or Shadowrun. The important distinction about these RPGs is not whether or not you can use them to play in another setting (this is possible with almost any game provided you are willing to do some work) but what the designers expect you to do, and all of the above are games where the expectation is that you are playing in the setting associated with the game.
  2. Games with implied settings: This category is very broad and contains, among other things, most editions of Dungeons and Dragons. Again the distinction here is not whether there is a core setting - most editions of D&D have had an assumed core setting (mostly Greyhawk until 4th edition where it was the Points of Light/Nentir Vale setting, and 5th edition where it is The Forgotten Realms) but whether the game is designed with the assumption that players will play in other settings or create their own. D&D and Pathfinder both very explicitly support this in their Dungeon Master/Game Mastery Guides, and implicitly support it by keeping the monsters in their main Monster Manual/Bestiary books fairly generic without too many references to specific characters or locations from their settings. Most D&D clones or retro clones fall into this category. 13th Age, Worlds Without Number, and other games in this category often have much stronger implied settings than D&D itself (and often come out with a world book to expand on it) but the flexibility is there to run games set in Greyhawk, or Dark Sun, or your homebrew setting using these systems.
  3. Games with no setting: There are actually few real examples in this category for games that have absolutely no setting attached to them. Typically, these games are created as a kind of framework that the publisher later attaches specific settings to. The classic example here is GURPS where you can pick up any of hundreds of expansion books depending on what genre of RPG you want to play in. Another example is the Cypher System from Monte Cook Games, which originally appeared as part of Numenera, but was later released as a generic system with all the Numenera bits removed from it, and Chaosium's Basic Roleplaying is another example of a setting-less system that is used by the publisher to power several specific settings.

My preference is for games with strong implied settings over those with no setting or with overly-detailed settings. I don't really like having to worry about tripping over named characters, or being corrected by a player who's read more books/comics/whatever than I have, but I do want the game to have a strong identity that I can build upon. Something like Legend of the Five Rings is the sweet spot for me - the game has a very strong identity and lots of worldbuilding is done to support a particular style of play, but you don't have to worry about running into named characters around every corner.

13
HadriusOP•

All excellent points! I've already learned a lot from the comments, and this differentiation helps even more. I think, in addition to your categories, it's useful to not conflate "setting" and "theme", or either with "tone".

Do you ever feel stifled by even those implied settings you like? I like and play D&D a fair amount, despite my design issues with it, but even as a player I find myself running face first into a lot of default setting assumptions that are both poorly thought out and difficult to route around. Things like- until recently- alignment fall squarely in both, and while I don't hate alignment, sometimes I don't feel like worrying about it even though the game thinks I should.

0
solandras•

Regarding alignment in DnD, it very rarely ever comes up game mechanically, so it's extremely easy to just remove entirely without it effecting the game.

1
LaFlibuste•

I used to think like this. I used to think I was all about the mechanics...

... but after trying to unsuccessfully read some generic systems that genuinely interested me for months, failing to feel any hype about them, I realised I was wrong. A good setting hooks me up, gets me through the book, supplies me with plenty of story seeds and I love seeing how the mechanics interact with it. IMO games are just so much richer and interesting when they include a setting.

12
HadriusOP•

That's actually good to hear! I'm open to being talked down on this point, but up to now, I've felt the almost entirely the opposite.

What elements of a setting excite you, then?

2
LaFlibuste•

I've tried thinking about it a bit and it's hard to say for sure. I've liked settings as varied as Wanderhome, Blades in the Dark, Red Markets, Spire, Ironsworn, Agon, Mouseguard and Brindlewood Bay. The following are green flags:

  • Something unique, in some way. I've had enough kitchen sink DnD-esque high fantasy.

  • Well thought out and cohesive.

  • Goes for a clear theme/feel. Is ideally reflected in the mechanics.

  • Rich enough to provide plenty of story seeds and plot hooks.

  • Broad strokes with plenty of blank space to fill in at the table. Pre-existing settings like Dune, Star Wars, Glorantha, Rokugaj (Legend of 5 Rings) or whatever attract me less because I only have passing familiarity with them and I'm not interested in having lore lawyering drbates at the table. Having to adhere to a very comprehensive and strict cannon does not sound fun to me.

Bottom line, mechanics in a vacuum seldom hook me. But mechanics are what is going to keep me playing the game once I'm hooked.

I also want to say we're all different and that's OK. Creativity is a complex process, some models for it split in like 6 or 7 stages/types, IIRC, and not everyone is equally good at them. Some people are very good at stage 1 idea generation. I have a friend like that, he can pull crap out of his ass all day long. But making sonething out of that? Very hard. I'm more stage 2: I'm bad at coming up with stuff but I can have a lot of fun and do great things once I have some raw materials. Others shine in later stages when all that's left is bringing stuff together with a defined method, like artisans. It's actually a very interesting topic.

1
HadriusOP•

Everyone is different of course; the primary reason I wanted to ask this question is because I'm pretty far to one side, and I'm interested in figuring to find some middle ground between pro- and anti-setting to design around.

I think I've mostly landed on "games should include a setting, but it shouldn't be integrated into the mechanics in any way, and shouldn't be required reading". I think having something for GMs to start out with is probably wise, but forcing people to read through lore seems… very bad:P

1
LaFlibuste•

Well there are different levels of lore. I don't know if you've ever read it, but one I really enjoyed for this was Red Market. I read through the lore chapter first, it conveyed the tone of the game pretty well without overdoing it, and when I got to the mechanics nothing was really surprising, it all already made sense because it fit the lore and tone. It was kind of instinctive for the setting and I feel it helps learn thr system too. I think it's a great piece of game design. Someone could very well have skipped over the lore and just delved in the mechanics to play a more generic zombie game, mind you, the lore wasn't jecessary to be able to play by any means.

Anyway, you do you, but personally I don't wany to play one system for ever and ever. When I've finished a 4-6 months campaign, I want to play something different. And mechanics tying in with the lore helps give them personality, makes them stand out more and be more memorable.

1
ExoticAsparagus333•

How does burning wheel not have a strong setting? You have setting religion, races, life paths, magic systems. There is no written out setting with lists of characters like world of darkness, but there’s is a very strong setting in the game.

I’d go further that every game has a setting. Even agnostic systems like gurps or savage worlds or genesys have settings that are implied because of the way the mechanics work. A game run in gurps will be much more lethal and dangerous than genesys or savage world for example.

12
HadriusOP•

> Burning Wheel

Conflating "rules" and "setting" when the two can be differentiated is to say nothing in an RPG can be analyzed or picked apart, especially if your metric is "this game has humans in it". I think it's worthwhile to think about what makes RPGs tick, and if we can't agree that "this system has magic in it" isn't a setting unto itself, I'm not sure there's much to talk about on this subject.

-5
bluesam3•

The rules in BW do a lot more setting-building than that: they tell you what fantasy races exist, what careers people have, to what degree social mobility is a thing (in great detail), what the economic realities of the setting are, etc., etc.

6
ExoticAsparagus333•

Look at burning wheel settings. You can go through the elf lifepaths and you know how elves live, what kind of magic they do, what their lives are like, hell you know that elves are immortal but they may eventually die of sadness. Humans are in a medieval feudal society with peasants, nobles, villages, etc.

Funnily enough there was a talk at pax east like 5 years ago where Luke crane the author of burning wheel argued that no rpg is setting-less because the rules inherently say something about the world and how it works.

3
HadriusOP•

I love Luke and his work, but I think people are rounding-up too much here. I'll return to my comment above: there are differences between "lore", "theme", "tone", "mechanisms", and "setting", and to ignore those differences is counterproductive to- at a minimum my own- efforts at better game design. Clearly, doing so must work for Luke, who is undoubtedly a better designer than I, but to the extent that's the case it's incomprehensible to me.

For example: what you've described about elves would, to my eye, into several different camps:

How elves live: this is probably the strongest point in favor of "setting", and it's good you led with it. To the extent that it is "setting", I've never particularly lifepath specificity; this is a "you're right, and it's bad" for me

What kind of magic they do: I think "Grief" is general enough that you could, ceteris paribus, throw BW elves into the Forgotten Realms, Eberron, or Dark Sun and it wouldn't catch anyone off guard. This is like unto "tone"; when you perform magic, grief is part of your reality. What does that have to do with "setting"?

What their lives are like: I think you get a rough idea of this, yes, but I don't think it's so specific that you couldn't transplant them between what might less controversially be called "settings", like the Forgotten Realms and others above.

Dying of sadness: Tone, through and through

None of this is to say there isn't some overlap between the definitions of lore, theme, tone, mechanisms, and setting- there's bound to be. But I can't abide acting like all words mean the same thing, or that it isn't worthwhile to think about how changes to a system affect each of those attributes in their own way. RPG design is more than just an intuitive process, as you likely know- it necessarily involves a lot of introspection and analysis, and handwaving definitions away helps neither.

1
Danielmbg•

For me it doesn't really matter the setting that much, since I usually like to homebrew stuff. The important part is that the game knows what it wants to do, and give me the necessary tools to achieve that.

11
MagnusCthulhu•

I don't buy setting agnostic games. Period. I will only buy a game if you have an interesting and unique world that it takes place in and if it looks like the mechanics are designed to help me play in that world.

I don't like world building at all. I just like playing.

11
HadriusOP•

I'm happy to hear that! I've mostly heard the opposite so far, but "I don't like worldbuilding" is a perfectly legitimate reason to want a setting in place. Part of the reason I asked this question is because I'm so far in the opposite direction that it's difficult for me to tell where everyone else is at.

Thanks for the feedback :)

1
Ananiujithamore history + more disability representation•

If your rules include a lot of setting-specific assumptions, then they should include a setting which fits them, and ideally one which uses them well.

7
HadriusOP•

What kinds of assumptions do you have in mind?

1
Ananiujithamore history + more disability representation•

If a book includes a number of ancestries or types as examples, that can be generic.

If it has the assumption that all these ancestries will exist, and each of them has various setting info attached, that's more setting-specific.

If a book includes a number of power systems so the gamemaster can decide which ones fit, that's generic.

If a book includes a number of power systems and explains that a more Vancian one is from study and a less Vancian one is from pacts with certain powers, and both co-exist, that's more setting-specific.

5
HadriusOP•

That's a very good explanation! Thank you for that. I'll keep that in mind.

1
Vanity-Press•

I don’t think less of a game without a setting because I like to make up my own stuff. However, sometimes when a game is too generic, or even genre agnostic, it’s just too difficult for me to find the right “footing” to make sense of anything/hold my attention.

Sometimes you need a little balance in regards to system reading.

6
HadriusOP•

Do you think the overly-generic systems are perhaps lacking theme rather than setting?

0
amodrenman•

I always make my own setting anyway, so it’s not something I look for.

5
SwiftOneSpeaks•

I want both.

Often I have a setting or setting concept and adapting a game with a different setting is swimming upstream, regularly fighting those assumptions instead of being able to focus on getting things done with mechanics and leaving the setting as flavor and reactions.

Other times I have a plot or an NPC or an item, or I want my players to come up with the same, and having a system with all the other details worked out and other factions and setting details to interact with what we bring to make it more interesting and rich.

If I had to have only one, I'd take the setting less systems, but it'd be a loss. My world is better when both are available.

5
Vanity-Press•

I also want both. Sometimes, a system or setting feels like it has “too much” or “too little” for doing your own game. For instance, I was super interested in the Shadow of the Demon Lord system, but I knew it would be too grim for my casual players. Fans of the game recognize this and often suggest how easy it is to “cut out” the darker details (especially the controversial spells about shitting to death). But that’s a hard sell to players when I plop down a book in front of them with a giant, gross demon on the cover and they want to play plucky gnome adventurers.

3

Yeah, depending on the game I want to run I may want to run in a specific setting that a particular RPG is set in, there are many games with very inspirational themes and details to them and I love mechanics that are highly idiosyncratic to a setting. Other times I have my own ideas of what kind of setting I want to run in and just want a system I think I can do that well in. Often this means I want setting neutral, but not genre neutral, game for my “general play”, while games with a very specific setting I’ll run whenever I get inspired and want to run the specific thing they are designed for.

2
HadriusOP•

Do you think settings should ever be incorporated into a system's mechanics? That is: should "pretech is of TL5 because precursor technology is better than any of our own, also here's rules about technology levels" be included in games with settings, or is something like Masks' approach with Halcyon city acceptable?

1
SwiftOneSpeaks•

Funny you mention that. I'm trying a Masks game now and annoyed that Halcyon is so baked in despite there being no apparent need for it.

However, Duskvol in Blades in the Dark or Star Wars, or the setting of Deadlines, or World of Darkness, or Earthdawn, or Court of Blades, or the setting of Swashbucklers of the 7 Skies, or Cyberpunk Red, or Traveller are all cases where the setting is beneficial in my opinion.

These don't stop me from appreciating GURPS or Fate or Savage Worlds as well, thus my answer that I want both.

3
HadriusOP•

Halcyon is so baked in

Oh really? That's interesting! I'll admit it's been a while since I read my copy, but I don't remember it being that important to the game. In what ways is it baked in?

​

all cases where the setting is beneficial

Maybe this is exactly what you're saying already, but is that maybe because you like the settings they provide, rather than the settings themselves being beneficial to the system?

1
SwiftOneSpeaks•

I don't remember it being that important to the game

It isn't. The book just tells you it must be halcyon city. There must be 4 generations of superheroes. It doesn't need to.

maybe because you like the settings they provide,

I like most of those, but I'd argue that Blades in the Dark NEEDS a setting that supports a level of poverty, corruption, low level gangs, etc. It doesn't have to be Duskvol, but without a setting it has too many oddly specific details to be generic, and the game without a setting would suffer.

Earthdawn has a reason the magic works the way it does. Without the setting with its history it is much harder to understand. Asking a GM to create an appropriate setting is just an unreasonable ask. Similar with the other examples - you can of course have different settings, but you can't have ANY setting.

3

I suppose I prefer games with a setting that is an "add-on" to the existing mechanic, instead of central to it. Allows for more homebrew or customization towards a specific use case.

Fate is a great example of this, since you can technically play it straight out of the box, but some customization doesn't hurt and can turn it into almost an entirely new game (for example, Dresden Files Accelerated, versus Fate Condensed).

Forged in the Dark is one where the base rules are universal, but it *needs* a setting tacked on to fill out the details.

5
HadriusOP•

Yeah Fate is a good example, and someone else pointed out Masks as a system with a "bonus" setting. I think that's probably the right way to approach setting in whatever situation you're including it, outside the media franchise examples like Dune, Lord of the Rings, or Star Trek. Or at least, that seems like the kind of compromise all parties are comfortable with.

2
TheLoneTentacle•

I certainly don't think less of games without a setting, but when a game is built with a specific focus, it makes sense that a setting could be a big part of that, too.

In general, I prefer to run games which include some level of shared world building during play. My current groups are creative, but have limited time to prep and plan, so this is a clear "everybody wins" situation for us.

The players get to roam around a world they feel invested in, both as players, and as characters; setting elements can be brought into focus as required, offering opportunities for group creativity; and we're not shackled to reading centuries of setting lore, for the sake of versimillitude.

As a result, we most often play some form of generic ruleset with a homebrewed setting: or genre-focused games that lean into the "play to find out" style of narrative, as per Powered by the Apocalypse.

That said, two of my most favourite games right now, are Blades in the Dark, and Heart. Both lean heavily into their settings for the experiences they deliver. When the mechanics, the world, and the narrative, are all inextricably intertwined, for me, this is what makes for a truly great RPG.

I'd probably enjoy more games with settings, if the settings added something unique or integral to the experience; rather than just being another generic world with different terminology.

4
HadriusOP•

If you regularly collaborate on worldbuilding before playing, during those times when you use an existing setting, do you do so because you think the setting is better than what would have otherwise been created? That would make sense to me, especially for a game no one at the table has played before, as it's likely no one would have a strong enough feel for the system to know what to pitch for world creation anyway.

That's an interesting line of thought. I'll add that to my list of things to ponder.

2
TheLoneTentacle•

If I understand your question correctly, I think the answer will be different depending on the type of game we're discussing.

The root of this opinion being, that different games all present different priorities for players, and the depth of setting detail can be far less crucial for some than in others.

You could argue, for example, that some narrative games prioritise genre over setting, by design. That's not to say the setting is inconsequential, or unimportant; but the game premise, the mechanics, and the character options, all guide you towards a play style where the setting becomes somewhat negotiatlble.

So to answer your question more directly, no, I don't think that using an existing setting necessarily makes for a better game. It certainly can, but its going to depend on what the game wants from its players, and what the players want from the game.

Sometimes an existing setting just gets in the way of the stories you want to tell. Others, it's absolutely integral to the game itself.

2
HadriusOP•

Sometimes an existing setting just gets in the way of the stories you want to tell

This is always my concern! And far more often than not, that seems to be the result at the table. I suppose I'm wondering how much setting substrate is helpful to grow the game at an otherwise inexperienced table, and how much is too much. Or perhaps, what kinds of settings and presentations of settings would help people who have no experience with a particular genre, like cyberpunk or psionic fugitives, etc.

Again, it might just take me a bit to marinate in that question. Always interested in more thoughts though, of course!

2
TheLoneTentacle•

Given that perspective, perhaps what would be helpful is creating an appropriate setting framework, rather than a setting in and of itself?

As in, a system where the most important parts of a world can be prompted, or generated, as required; and with as much or little depth as the table prefers?

1
NopenGrave•

I generally care less about having a "setting" the more toolboxy a system is.

For settings trying to create a very specific combination of genre, though, it definitely helps to have a setting. Even if the GM tosses it completely, the benefit comes from further illustrating the themes the game is designed to explore with practical examples.

Like, baseline Call of Cthulhu has a very loose "setting" and a ton of bolt-on options, but it does carry the basic conceit of 1920s cosmic horror, featuring mortal investigators as the protagonists, and a lot of its setting material is very well-crafted both from a practical standpoint, and for the purposes of showing a potential GM how to replicate it.

3
HadriusOP•

It's been a while since I read through any CoC stuff, but that's an interesting thought. I kind of wonder how much of CoC is worldbuilding vs thematics too, since it seems like it would overlap quite a bit, given the nature of the system.

1
rodrigo_i•

Yes. In a good RPG the crunch and the f!uff are complementary. There are a few exceptions. Dread, for example, is a phenomenal RPG without an explicit setting, but it's intended for one-offs and the rules are essentially the questionnaire.

3
HadriusOP•

To the extent that the "fluff" is informative to the process a player goes through to interface with the game, I don't know that that's really fluff, and that's where I start having an issue. If it's flat out impossible for me to extricate the specific names of the evil generals in Band of Blades, that takes a huge part of the fun out of the system.

I guess I'm wondering how much of this is zero sum, and whether or not those who are pro-setting would accept a setting document presented as its own entity, entirely divorced from the mechanics of the game.

1
jackparsonsproject•

It depends on the genre/game.

OSR fantasy games need no setting. We all have our own way ae like our fantasy and OSR cross compatibility means they all work just fine out of the box even with a different system. Id rather have a skinny rule book than one bloated by a setting...unless its a really good setting.

Other genres kind of need something though. SciFi isnt monolithic...you have to know things like how advanced the androids are and if there are known alien species. Some games, like Vampire or Nights Black Agents, are so defined by its setting that there wouldn't even be a game without it.

3
HadriusOP•

That's a good point, and opens up even more questions for me. For something like a hypothetical generic scifi game, I have to wonder if the system shouldn't account for a lot of those differences between settings. That is, if the game you play is going to have androids, the system might should provide mechanics for all levels of sophistication, so if you decide to play with them (I think it's important that it not be assumed), you at least have somewhere to start, and may not need to work on the rules at all.

2
Zaorish9Low-power Immersivist•

I prefer good rule sets without settings because I prefer to make my own settings.

3