Unfair_Finger5531•

Hate to say this, but the cdp looks the best imo. Of course the one that will bankrupt you is the standout one….

42
PracticalMind9OP•

Yep. A few days ago, I did post a picture here in AB with me wearing it because I felt confident enough wearing it to put my face on here. Which says a lot. For me, that is not something I do willy-nilly.

The idea of doing it for all of them in this review/swatch thread was exhausting though, and while none of these (except the Chancantaille, really disliked this one) were bad, none looked quite as good as the CdP.

22
Unfair_Finger5531•

I agree with other commenter that the Kanebo looks nice too. It’s just hard to stand up to that cdp.

5
PracticalMind9OP•

Reposting my impressions as a comment since i messed up my formatting and can't figure out how to edit without deleting the whole post.

Hello, I decided to buy some cream and gel-cream foundations as I've developed a recent obsession with them, am a very stressed vet student and cope by overeating and spending money I can't afford.

I was going to apply each to my face and take pictures, but honestly, I don't love my skin and foundation wear is so YMMV that I didn't think it would really add that much value. We are all different, all use different skin care, sunscreens, etc etc. For general information, I will say I am in my mid thirties, have moderate sun damage (speckles, fine lines), I do have hormonal acne, sensitive skin, enlarged pores on my cheeks as well as a couple stretched pores and two small ice pick scars above my lip. I have generally dry skin that gets extremely oily around my period. Occasional perioral dermatitis. Some redness around my nose.

Also, I did put some info in the picture captions, so check that out too. I hope these swatches and insights will be valuable to some!

Cle De Peau "The Foundation" shade B10

Price: Retails at $270 USD (I did not pay this much.)

Formulation: Gel-cream hybrid, more gel than cream.

Oxidation: Yes. Probably about 1/2 a shade to 3/4.

Finish: Radiant.

Coverage: Light up to strong medium coverage.

Self-setting?: No. Will never set by itself.

SPF/PA: SPF 25 (mine is an international version), unsure of PA as it isn't the Japanese specific version

Shade range: Poor

Additional comments: This is a really, really nice product. It applied best with fingers. Of all the formulas, I found it the most flattering even though it was not the most full coverage of all of the products. It seemed to have a really nice mixture of actual coverage and pearlescent/radiant effects that seemed to blur imperfections in a very pleasing way. It sat in my lines the least of any of the products I tried (read: pretty much NO line-sitting), and even made my under eye concealer act better (usually will slightly emphasize fine lines, it did so less with CdP as a base).

Kanebo "The Cream Foundation" shade Pink Ochre B

Price: Right around 200 USD, depending on the retailer.

Formulation: Cream.

Oxidation: Yes, about 1/2 a shade.

Finish: Satin

Coverage: Medium to full.

Self-setting?: I'd call it "semi"-setting. It's not like if you swipe your finger all of it will come off, but it isn't transfer proof either.

SPF/PA: SPF 15 PA +++

Shade range: Poor

Additional comments: This stuff is thicc and potent. A little goes a LONG way. Applies beautifully with a flat foundation brush and a beauty blender to get hard to reach spots/fix brush lines. The coverage can be medium but it's hard not to end up full. It is beautiful, but more satin and less luminous than expected. I did find this sat in my lines a touch more than the CdP, but not a lot. It's simple to just pat it away and it gets out of the lines. It did play nice with my pores, although not quite as well as CdP. It didn't seem to make my under eye concealer play any better with it as a base, but didn't make it worse either. I actually really enjoyed this one, but for the price I'd just pony up and get the CdP unless you are looking for satin and fuller coverage.

Kanebo "Lively Wear" foundation shade Pink Ochre B

Price: Around 70 USD

Formulation: Gel-cream hybrid, more gelly than creamy.

Oxidation: Maybe about 1/4-1/2 a shade.

Finish: Radiant

Coverage: Light to medium.

Self-setting?: No. Not ever.

SPF: SPF 5 PA ++

Shade range: Poor

Additional comments: I anticipated that I would enjoy the more luxury Kanebo formulation over this one and actually, it's the other way around. I enjoy that this is more of a gel-cream hybrid and that it gives a dewy natural finish. Applied best with fingers. I actually LIKE that you can see a little bit of my skin through this. It just feels more natural. Of the products I tested out, this felt the closest to the CdP formulation. However, CdP seems to have a bit more of a flattering, optical-blurring sort of thing going on. This one also sat it the lines a bit and tapping took away a bit of coverage. But for the price, this was very enjoyable, and something I would consider repurchasing!

Chancantaille "Future Skin" foundation (Non-AB) shade Aura

Formulation: Pretty much 100% gel texture.

Price: Around 90 USD

Oxidation: About 1/2 shade

Finish: M-A-T-T-E, omg, so much more matte than anticipated.

Coverage: Sheer. Like skin tint sheer. Layering does not bring this to what I would consider light coverage.

Self-setting?: darn near. Minimal transfer.

SPF: No.

Shade range: Poor

Additional comments: The ONLY one of these that did NOT come with a spatula. I'm sorry but I feel for the price and the fact that it is in a jar, it should come with a spatula. Fortunately, I have a lot of extra spatulas. But still. Now this formula was a bit weird to me. I will say it applied best with fingers. I thought it would be dewy, and it was not. It was actually matte! Which makes it unusual as a sheer-matte. I would say of all the products, this had the most natural skin-like finish. You really cannot tell you are wearing it. However, this comes with a big caveat: it doesn't look like anything. All my speckles and freckles and acne showed right through this, even with multiple coats. It was my least favorite and not one I would purchase again. This product would be good for someone who prefers matte, and has skin so good they don't really need foundation anyway. IMHO, overhyped.

TLDR: My favorites: CdP "The Foundation" > Kanebo Lively Wear > Kanebo The Cream Foundation > Chancantaille "Future Skin"

CdP: Radiant, medium cover, optical blurring

Kanebo The Cream Foundation: Satin, Med-to-Full, a little thick

Kanebo Lively Wear: Radiant, medium, not as much optical blur but very natural, closest to CdP formula

Chancantaille: No spatula. No. Just no.

Another note Kanebo has a TON of cream formulas under not only Kanebo but other related companies like Sensai, etc. I am very interested in trying some more of these, as I found this brand very promising. I am thankful to an AB-er whose /u/ is escaping me for recommending this brand.

24
Hot_Mention_9337•

Yeah. Annoyingly, CdP is easily the best foundation I’ve ever put on my face. Because of course it is, lol. The finish, the coverage, the way it perfects, how it sits over my lines and dehydrated spots, how it sits so flawlessly on the skin in general.. I’ve been able to get a few generous samples from the Saks in my area and one of these days I’ll pick up a jar of this madness. I do want to try Shiseido’s Future Solution XL foundation and see how they compare. Hoping it’s similar with them being the parent company of CdP. And also because CdP discontinued the shade I loved :(

And I’m surprised at Chantecaille! Always interesting to hear how different products behave on different people, even people with similar skin types. I have dry skin, large pores (especially around the cheeks and nose), prone to acne and flaking, and I love this one. Very glowy, but somehow doesn’t enhance my pores, very perfecting, very much undetectable, and easily a medium coverage. But even one light layer still blurs out my busted capillaries. I will say that I didn’t find it to be hydrating enough until more recently when I made some skincare changes. Wasn’t a “love” the first couple times I sampled it, but it’s definitely working beautifully where my skin is currently at

6
PracticalMind9OP•

I really wanted to try the Shiseido one, too! I scoured the dept and I was told by one of the Shiseido managers at a dept store that they are phasing it out on the east coast of US. No one had any samples of it, which was a bummer. I really did want to try that. I may eventually try blind buying it once my finances recover 😅

And yeah, everything can be so YMMV. I bought the chacantaille direct from the chacantaille counter, so I am sure mine is legit. It just didn't do anything for me at all and sat so matte. I tried adding more moisture underneath as well and had no appreciable difference. I'm probably going to end up giving it to a friend with nicer skin who will be able to appreciate it more.

2
StandardKey9182•

I think the Kanebo Cream looks gorgeous.

5
PracticalMind9OP•

It really is very, very nice. It's definitely a preference thing. For me, I actually preferred their cheaper "Lively wear" because I am currently looking for more medium/natural looks. I would consider the Kanebo "The Cream Foundation" to be ultra high-end just like the CdP, but with different utility-- more full, more satin. I do think it's worth every bit of it's price tag. I could definitely see myself using it for fancy evening events. It just felt too heavy for day time for me personally.

11
StandardKey9182•

I understand, I don’t usually wear much more than a little translucent powder on a daily basis, unless I’m having a breakout or something.

1

Very helpful, thank you! Congrats on becoming a vet!

2
scarletofmagic•

Wow, it looks like you pulled the trigger for the CDP one. I have to agree that the CDP The Foundation is so good. I always want to try Kanebo foundation but I have not tried yet. I might try the Lively Wear you mentioned. Thank your for the review.

5
PracticalMind9OP•

Yeah, I did lol. I purchased it online and got it for considerably cheaper, but still not cheap by any means. The kanebo did surprise me. I will say that it doesn't have quite as much of that optical blurring effect though, but for 70 bucks, I think it's worth trying out.

3

Love the nail color 😍 can I ask what it is thanks!

2
PracticalMind9OP•

Eek! I wish I could tell you. I got my nails done with my mom when I was visiting her. It's a basic nail polish, not gel or anything. I can say that the brand is OPI! I hope that helps 😅

4

Thanks will check out the OPI shade range!

2
yakisobagurlJapan•

This was really interesting, thank you for doing it!

2
PracticalMind9OP•

No problem! It was fun!

2
llemondrop23•

Thank you for the reviews! After using CDP foundation, it's so hard to go back to using a different brand. I find that it's the most natural looking and no matter the formula, it always looks beautiful on the skin. Their concealers are amazing too. My fave foundation from them was the cream to powder, like no joke, I wore it to a concert, it rained and I cried and it still looked amazing at the end of the night. 😂 Unfortunately, it has been discontinued and I'm wanting to try their new version of The Foundation. My wallet is just not ready for that yet. 🥲

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
lickityboo•

Thanks for this amazing review!

At least you got a Cdp shade match… none of it is pale enough for me even if I am willing to pay the full price sighhhh

1
PracticalMind9OP•

No prob!! Yeah the shade range is definitely poor. B10 is actually even a touch dark, I need to put it down my neck a bit. I think I10 would have been better for me. Ah well, next time!

If you found that CdP was too dark, I'd encourage you to look into the Kanebo. I found that Pink Ochre B was a touch pale on me. For reference, when I wear Lancome Teint Idole (Non-AB) I wear 90N, their palest color.

Also, Japanese CdP foundation made for the Japanese clients seems to have lighter shades from what I could tell? I thought I saw B00, for example. That might be something to look into!

2
lickityboo•

Just out of curiosity, what other non Japanese foundations have you tried?

Are Japanese foundations really a different league from others? Because that seems to be a popular opinion... supposedly more finely milled, better texture etc? I personally believe it's true .... but also don't want to believe so cause Jap foundations tend to run dark...darker than Korean/American brands sigh....

1
PracticalMind9OP•

So I really have just tried Japanese, so I don't really have much input there. Sorry:(

2
yabeautyxo•

I have the Cdp and it really is super gorgeous! But the $$$ 😩😅

1
PracticalMind9OP•

Yeah I'm going to be babying it 😅

1
bigbootycorgis•

I wonder have you ever tried the L’Oréal age perfect tinted face balm? It’s the cheapest product in the same style as these other pot foundations. I’ve been using it and really like it. I’d LOVE to know how they compare

1
PracticalMind9OP•

I can't say I have tried it, but if I do, I will let you know!

1
bigbootycorgis•

If you see it definitely pick it up. I got mine for maybe €7 ? Do it for science

1
skindevotion•

...are cle de peau and chantecaille AB?

-2†
PracticalMind9OP•

Cle De Peau, despite having a French name, is, in fact, a Japanese brand. I did not know it myself until not too long ago. Their parent company is Shiseido. Three of the four foundations reviewed are Japanese cream or gel cream foundations.

Chancantaille, of the four brands I reviewed, is not AB, which I thought I indicated somewhere. This was included as I have seen this brand hyped to death in America, and I found it quite disappointing. I wanted to share this and show how well the AB products performed against this very over-hyped product.

18
skindevotion•

good to know CdP is, i had no idea!

maybe i missed it, but i didn't see any mention of a non-AB brand...

-6
PracticalMind9OP•

There's kind of a huge wall of text, so it is probably easy to miss! I put it in the comment where I kind of went over all the brands. It says Chancantaille (Non-AB). There's a chance I missed labeling it in the original post, and if so, my apologies. I can't seem to edit the original post, or I would go through and change anywhere where it wasn't indicated.

11
skindevotion•

i did see and respond, like, *right* after you posted, so maybe that was the original post. but also i miss shit all the time, i'm not perfect!

1