ITAW for a literary device where the protagonist knows a critical piece of info that other characters don't?

Solved

"Protagonists know critical info all the time that other characters don't," you say. "That's not a literary device; that's just characters being characters," you say. I know. Hear me out.

I was reviewing a client's literary essay draft when I saw them describe just this situation. They're analyzing a mystery novel, and the protagonist eventually lays hold of a clue that only he knows, thus allowing him to solve the mystery. But then, my client wrote, "This is anagnorisis, in which only the protagonist is aware of a critical piece of information."

That's not anagnorisis, right? Right?? I thought anagnorisis was when a major character discovers another character's identity. Or they discover the true nature of their own circumstances. Like when Oedipus makes his fateful discovery.

I started to wonder if maybe my client was trying to describe an obscure form of irony (because it kinda sounds like dramatic-irony-once-removed), but then I was like, why is this even a device? Protagonists routinely know critical info that other characters don't. Am I wrong?

Posted Mar 29, 2023, 1:38 AM UTC · edited

76
Mashakaraka•

It's a type of irony. Dramatic irony is when the audience knows, but the characters don't, but maybe this would fall into situational irony.

3
ElementRage17OP:karma: Points: 4•

I really do feel like it is a kind of irony. But I have yet to find a description of the various forms of situational irony that suits this specific scenario. Very broadly speaking (at least, as I understand it), situational irony arises from a discordance between the expected outcome and actual outcome in a situation. This doesn't seem to apply to the scenario we're dealing with, because our scenario doesn't exactly rely on outcomes; it relies only on knowledge and ignorance. But let me know if I'm misunderstanding something.

2
SagebrushandSeafoam:karma: Points: 10•

I may not be completely following you, but perhaps your client meant that discovering the clue then revealed the identity of the culprit, and thus anagnorisis.

But as for your main question, I think that would still be called dramatic irony, since the reader knows it with the character. For example, Odysseus disguising his identity at the end of the Odyssey is often cited as dramatic irony, but it would also qualify for what you're describing.

3
ElementRage17OP:karma: Points: 4•

Thank you! I didn't know that about Odysseus--it solves everything. Thanks also for the link to mystery-specific anagnorisis, super helpful.

!solved

2
AutoModeratorMOD•

u/ElementRage17 - Thank you for your submission.
Please reply with "!solved" to the first comment that gives you the correct answer to automatically flair it accordingly.
Please do not delete your post once/if it is solved.

Please remember to reply to comments indicating whether they are not correct, partially correct, or if they solve your post.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
WhatsTheWordBotMOD•

Click this link to be notified when this post is done.

1