ITAW for a literary device where the protagonist knows a critical piece of info that other characters don't?
"Protagonists know critical info all the time that other characters don't," you say. "That's not a literary device; that's just characters being characters," you say. I know. Hear me out.
I was reviewing a client's literary essay draft when I saw them describe just this situation. They're analyzing a mystery novel, and the protagonist eventually lays hold of a clue that only he knows, thus allowing him to solve the mystery. But then, my client wrote, "This is anagnorisis, in which only the protagonist is aware of a critical piece of information."
That's not anagnorisis, right? Right?? I thought anagnorisis was when a major character discovers another character's identity. Or they discover the true nature of their own circumstances. Like when Oedipus makes his fateful discovery.
I started to wonder if maybe my client was trying to describe an obscure form of irony (because it kinda sounds like dramatic-irony-once-removed), but then I was like, why is this even a device? Protagonists routinely know critical info that other characters don't. Am I wrong?
Posted Mar 29, 2023, 1:38 AM UTC · edited
It's a type of irony. Dramatic irony is when the audience knows, but the characters don't, but maybe this would fall into situational irony.
I really do feel like it is a kind of irony. But I have yet to find a description of the various forms of situational irony that suits this specific scenario. Very broadly speaking (at least, as I understand it), situational irony arises from a discordance between the expected outcome and actual outcome in a situation. This doesn't seem to apply to the scenario we're dealing with, because our scenario doesn't exactly rely on outcomes; it relies only on knowledge and ignorance. But let me know if I'm misunderstanding something.