Battles stink.
[removed]
Posted Mar 29, 2023, 4:43 PM UTC
[removed]
Posted Mar 29, 2023, 4:43 PM UTC
Well, I liked it.
🤓
You stink
#gottem
Magic is a fantasy table top game about combat. The game, especially in Limited and Standard formats has been very creature centric and has rewarded combat for decades.
Maybe you should at least try playing with the card type before dismissing it or saying it stinks. We all know that players, including veterans, are notoriously bad at miscalculating the power and playability of certain mechanics and cards when they are initially previewed.
Magic is about magic. Just cause two formats out of billion are more creature based doesn't mean anything
The game IS the battle! It’s weird making a permanent card that represents a sub-game within that game.
I didn’t say a single thing about the power level. I’m talking about the mechanic itself and its implications.
I don't know who shat in your breakfast, but they should do it again.
r/magicthecirclejerking material
If you don't like them, don't play them.
They're no different than Planeswalkers when they were first released in terms of what can or can't interact with them.
Wizards: Creates the first new card type in several years, designs intricate front-and-back side interactions, creates a new ruleset to seamlessly integrate the card type into existing formats without needing massive rules alterations or erratas, launches the cardtype during the hyped climax of a multi-set story arc.
This guy: Ugh they only did this to make my Naturalizes worse. It's so, so lazy.
[deleted]
Oh goodie, another moronic post hating on mechanic before anyone has even played it
When you conclude the battle. You earn an ally.
If they were enchantments you would have even less ways to interact with them….
Making a whole new card type to get around enchantment destruction is so, so lazy, especially since they all need ETB abilities to not be essentially unplayable in the first place.
You and I have very different definitions of "Lazy".
Heaven forbid WotC try something new. I, for one, actually like these cards.
Sounds like it isn't for you
Yeah? Well, you know, that's just, like, your opinion, man.
Quit magic then nerd
You can interact with it if you don’t have creatures, you can still destroy or deal damage to them.
Planeswalkers were one of the best innovations because they want the game to be about attacking, and it should be about attacking. Battles do the same thing and punish the right people. While none seem overly powerful, you get a freebie if your opponent isn't engaging in the creature game, which as I mentioned, is what the game should be about.
In conclusion, battles are good.
It's easily ignorable If you don't like them, you don't have to play them If your opponent plays one on you, you don't have to interact with the Battle, just interact with them trying to get rid of it. If you do like them, you'll build to play them. They aren't looking OP so far, so it won't give you a super big advantage (unless one later on makes me eat my words).
And so it begins