Help me choose an itinerary!

Hello!

Me and my husband want to do our first Virgin Voyages cruise but I am having doubts on which itinerary to choose. Both are the same length, price and depart from San Juan.

Option 1: San Juan- Tortola - Guadeloupe - St. Lucia - Barbados - Antigua.

Option 2: San Juan - Aruba - Curacao - Martinique - St. Kitts

We've been to a few of these ports before: St. Lucia, Barbados, Curacao and St. Kitts. We did not like St. Lucia that much, but would give it another try and look for something else to do. The other ports we loved.

For those who have visited Aruba, Guadeloupe, Antigua, Tortola and/or Martinique. Did you enjoy these ports? Which one did you enjoy more?

Thank you for your help!