Is G-Sync fully supported with Hdmi 2.1?

Discussion

Hi,

I have Samsung's S28AG700 144hz 4k monitor that it is connected with DP. I've been having issues with 2-3 seconds black screens that is similar to a connection lost. I've seen other users with similar issues.

I'd like to try Hdmi 2.1 so it might fix this issue, besides increased bandwith is welcomed, so I should get 4k 144hz without DSC. According to Nvidia G-sync is supported with Hdmi 2.1, but how is your experience? Are there any disadvantages compared to DP like limited range or instability etc. Thanks for any input.

​

Edit:

For people having a similar issue, the hdmi cable that I've ordered has come and I tested it. Black screen issue is still there and feels even less stable. Since other people having similar issues, this is probably not related to my monitor, but a monitor firmware, driver issue.

G-sync works as before, but Nvidia control panel doesn't automatically enable it, but it looks fine for the full range.

Posted Apr 4, 2023, 4:47 PM UTC · edited

17
[deleted]•

https://www.rtings.com/monitor/reviews/samsung/odyssey-g7-s28ag70

"FreeSync works over the entire range with both connections, but the G-SYNC compatibility only works over DisplayPort; over HDMI, the NVIDIA Control Panel recognizes it, but we couldn't enable G-SYNC in the pendulum demo. Let us know if it works on your unit."

The HDMI 2.1 is worth a try since you ordered it but in their review they said it would only work over displayport. If it works for you, you should leave a comment and they may update their review.

When do you get the black screens? Is it when you open games or something or just at random? It could be the displayport cable you are using isn't fit for the full bandwidth or possibly the drivers. Maybe try DDU'ing and install some older nvidia drivers?

If all else fails might just be the monitor or some other windows / nvidia problem.

2
sequence_9OP•

Yes, I've seen that. There was a firmware update after the review and hopefully things are changed with firmware or driver.

Black screens happens in the games and they are random. Goes for a second or two and then it is back, monitor shows displayport is connected message as well. It happend with cable that came with monitor, and I bought a certified cable, but it didn't help.

1
kasakka1•

I think this is some Nvidia or Windows driver issue as I've been having these issues as well on the same model and they started fairly recently.

HDMI 2.1 is exactly the same.

1
sequence_9OP•

Oh, that's really sad to hear. I have hoped that hdmi might fix that. I've already ordered a hdmi 2.1 cable, so how is your g-sync experience, do you have any issues?

1
rayddit519•

This should all depend on the monitor. My G-Sync monitor (with module, AW3821DW) declares HDMI VRR in its EDID infos and it works just as well as via DP, only limited by the reduced HDMI bandwidth of the G-Sync module. Everything else works the same, so I am pretty sure every monitor could support the full range of refresh rates via HDMI on the newer Nvidia GPUs.

1
kkll1234•

Depends on ur monitor and hardware also download newest firmware to be sure. On gigabyte m28u i got mine running with hdmi 2.1 vrr, fixed stutters for me. Dp cable was causing stuttering, some black screen flashign etc.

1
Ajen901•

Hi,

owning this monitor and struggling myself a bit with G-Sync, and DSC and this resulting in black screens (similar to the monitor searching for a new source, displaying e.g. "DisplayPort Connected"), I might have some testing results and what works for me to share.

I tried both via DP and HDMI, but I was not able to get rid of these black screens and I tried several different cables all that were rated for the required bandwidth/DP/HDMI version.

I also was thinking of DSC as a potential problem, so I tried lowering the refresh rate and at a 120 Hz refresh rate it seems that (using DP) DSC is not active anymore as I can select Integer Scaling etc. which should not be possible if DSC is active. I first discovered this when I disabled VRR to be able to lower the refresh rate of the monitor, obviously no G-Sync then anymore which was not to my likings.

My solution now is to have VRR/Gsync active and to make sure that "perform scaling on - Display" is selected, if set to GPU I can not change the refresh rate in the NVCP. Then (so at 120 Hz set in NVCP and G-Sync active) no black screens happen for me.

You of course sacrifice 20% of your potential max. refresh rate and you can not select integer scaling anymore, but at least I have 120 Hz and G-Sync active...

If anyone has a better solution I am happy to take or hear it, but it's the best I came up with until now.

Happy to discuss more.

1