Started throwing in some salts and fermentation is way more aggressive. Is this normL?
I started added a lil CaCl and Gypsum as per some recipes online and noticed immediately how quickly fermentation started and how much foam was created on top
Normally I get 1.010-1.012FG from fermentation, should I expect lower this time? The second one I did started foaming in less then 24 hours which I have yet to see. Is this all to be expected?
Posted Apr 4, 2023, 6:56 PM UTC
Calcium and magnesium are both essential for yeast health, and they help with flocculation as well. If you do not know your water chemistry, and you just want to add some salts, you should be adding some calcium chloride, and magnesium sulfate. What you are doing right now is adding calcium twice as well as some sulfates and some chlorides. If you add magnesium sulfate - epsom salt - you will be adding magnesium as well, and also adding both chlorides and sulfates. It will retain the sulfate to chloride ratio while adding another mineral that is good for yeast health.
If you see a noticeable difference in your fermentation after adding these minerals, there is a good chance your water is deficient in the minerals your yeast needs for good health. You would be best off to get a water report or send your water off to be analyzed so you can add the right salts in the right amounts. Once you have that info, it is very easy to just plug some numbers into a water calculator and it will tell you what to add. It will make a noticeable difference in the quality of your beer.
Since you know what you’re talking about maybe you can shed light on two questions:
My particular municipality utilizes different water sources during summer and winter. In the summer, we have off chances of algae attacks and they go for a third water source. Because of this I haven't bothered with a water analysis.
If you're on a municipal water system, call up the local government and ask for a water analysis report. It should be free and it will be accurate.
It's hard for me to comment on your situation in specific, because I'm in Texas. The consistency of water has a lot to do with the source of your water supply. I used ward labs to have my water analyzed and have found them to be very accurate, and they also lined up very close to what my municipal water report was. I would start with a water report and see how it goes.
Unfortunately Ward Labs does not ship to Canada, but the most important tests/minerals are:
Calcium
Sodium
Magnesium
Sulfate
Chloride
Bicarbonate
As well Iron, Manganese, Nitrate, and Sulfide (not so be confused with sulfate), which impart bad flavors but are probably low unless your water is noticeably terrible. Municipal water is NOT necessarily consistent throughout the year or even location - it really depends on the city and when/where they treat the water. My town regularly tests for heavy metals and biohazards but not the important brewing minerals.
Check out this page, specifically section 2.5 for some great info: https://www.brunwater.com/water-knowledge
Thanks for the reply!
I’m in Canada also and I have my analysis done by CARO Analytical. Our municipal water is pretty consistent through the year but I asked the town office if the can send me their reports when the have them done just to be safe. Once I got my analysis back I used it to build my water for different brews and I get some really good fermentation and FG out of it.
Thanks for the reply! I’ll look into CARO