Why isn't Giannis in the MVP conversation?

Player Discussion

[removed]

Posted Apr 5, 2023, 4:52 AM UTC

021
SugarHouse666•

Jesus Christ man he’s been in the MVP conversation all year. At no point in the last three months has he not been “in the conversation” (whatever that means). He has consistently been in the top 3 of MVP ladders, at times being #1 and #2. Have you been living under a rock? I don’t mean to be a dick, but his name has been mentioned throughout this whole MVP discussion and this idea he is being forgotten about is pure fantasy.

Also, Jokic is having a better season than his past two seasons, all three of which have been special by any metric.

15
redd5ive•

You’re not wrong but he clearly isn’t going to win it. It’s the same thing we saw when LeBron was in his peak IMO. To me, Giannis is clearly better than Jokic or Embiid.

0
chadbrutalism•

the reason is because its alot easier to make a Most Valuable case when the rest of your team appears lackluster, especially when you arent on the floor. giannis is the best player in the world imo, but his team is also clearly better than the sixers and the nugs

3
redd5ive•

That statement was probably more true in the last two seasons than it has been this season. Are the Bucks overall better? Yeah. I don’t think the gulf in talent is anywhere near large enough for that to be a major factor this season.

0
chadbrutalism•

im not arguing who i would hypothetically vote for, im arguing that the lens of a media voter views embiid/jokic putting these numbers up with inferior squads as more impressive. thats all, not to mention the fact that embiid is the only one of the 3 without 2 already. narrative is a big deal with this award

3
SugarHouse666•

He asked “why isn’t Giannis in the MVP conversation” not “why isn’t Giannis the MVP favorite”.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

0
nbadiscussion-ModTeamMOD•

Please keep your comments civil. This is a subreddit for discussion and debate, not aggressive and argumentative content.

If you think a comment or post doesn’t belong in our sub, report it and move on.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

0
[deleted]•

[removed]

0
[deleted]•

[removed]

0
GSofMindOP•

He's never really been in the top 2. He's securely been third in the MVP conversation (except Tatum had this spot here and there throughout the season) all year and it has only really been down to Jokic and Embiid as the serious contenders for MVP.

Draymond and Steph both weighed in that Embiid should be the MVP. Has any other player this year gave their blessings for Giannis?

-1†
GonnaWinDis•

Well, he just answered you why Giannis has been in the conversation, and why this thread is creating a false narrative that he hasn't lol

6
BrockSmashgood•

He's securely been third in the MVP conversation

This almost makes it sound like he is in the MVP conversation.

2
Elyx117•

he's been in the top 3 conversation for several years going now, so your observation isn't exactly accurate. I think what you meant to imply is, why can't Giannis win another one this year? well if you believe in stats, especially advanced stats, both Jokic and Embiid are having a historical season while Giannis is actually having a bit of a lull vs his own standards.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.espn.com/nba/insider/insider/story/_/id/35805521/nba-mailbag-where-does-giannis-rank-mvp-race%3fplatform=amp (pay wall)

But I'll go back to what I posted on the main NBA sub a while ago (which was downvoted to hell and back) - why should it matter? A regular season MVP is a great honor but really nothing more than a nice to have for players in the top echelon. It doesn't bring you more money (because all superstars are already max players), it doesn't give you more spotlight beyond the First Take shouting match (have you seen any Jokic commercials?), and most importantly it doesn't define your game and the ability to win a championship. That's why Giannis is very chilled about it and Jokic actually sounds like he's bored of hearing this conversation. Embiid is obviously abit insecure about it, because he hasn't won it, but those with bigger fish to fry know what to focus on. Ask yourself this - if you're Jokic, what do you care more right now? finally getting into the WCF, or winning an extra doorstop?

4
QualityVoteMOD•

This is our community moderation bot.


If this post is high quality, UPVOTE this comment.

If this post is NOT high quality, DOWNVOTE this comment.

If this post breaks the rules, DOWNVOTE this comment and REPORT the post!

1
moondog8•

It seems like it’s been a 3 man race all year. You could make a great case for joker, embiid, or Giannis and none of those three would be a bad choice. They all deserve it in my opinion it unfortunately only one will get it

1
nbadiscussion-ModTeamMOD•

We don't allow posts on player rankings or player comparisons on this subreddit.

1
iggymcfly•

Jokic has the best season by far, the highest impact, the best numbers, and is the most valuable. Embiid has that he hasn’t won it before. Giannis has neither. So he’ll get some votes but he can’t win.

-4