Insulating hives… has anyone experimented with insulating your hives on all sides?

What was your results? Worth it?

Have about 12 hives and am experimenting and going to put one hive inside a full insulated hive box. Essentially copying vino farms build which is a super and a deep with longer frames to go the full length of the deep and super.

Posted Apr 6, 2023, 4:26 PM UTC

110
NumCustosApes4th generation beekeeper, zone 6B•

I insulate. I use 2" XPS panels, cut to size. I secure them on the hive with a ratchet strap. In the summer they stack flat on a shelf in my garage. I insulate the hive top as well. My winter top is either 1) a 2 millimeter thick sheet of clear perspex with 2" of XPS above it so there is no thermal break, or 2) a quilt box with XPS panels extended up the side of it so there is minimal thermal break.

3
Wallyboy952-4 Hives Zone 4b Canada•

Vino Farms on YouTube made his Beebarns and has videos on it, along with posting data he collects on his Instagram page for temps, moisture and a few other things.

I've been toying with the idea of making one of his, but they are looking pretty expensive to make

2
Wonderbread003OP•

Oh okay. I didn’t know he had an instagram. Will give it a look.

I used basically the same stuff he used but wooden hives not Lyson boxes.

Wasn’t too bad when it comes to price but it is more than just normal wooden boxes.

2
Wallyboy952-4 Hives Zone 4b Canada•

Wood prices here in Onatrio, Canada are ridiculous again.

2
davidsandbrandZone 2b/3a, data-focused beekeeping•

I put 2” R-10 underneath and on all 4 sides, plus 3 layers (R-30) on top this winter and will never go uninsulated ever again.

I also had the bottom and sides on all last summer and will also do that forever - the interior temperatures were way more stable. I have multiple temperature sensors inside. Maybe I should have started with that.

2
Wonderbread003OP•

What were some of the differences that you noticed? Did they brood earlier? Were you able to put a super on quicker than normal?

Are you still in zone 2b? I am in 4a and wondering if I should keep them insulated during summer.

1
davidsandbrandZone 2b/3a, data-focused beekeeping•

For context of my environment, there’s still snow in front of them, with probably 12-18” deep snow in the shadier areas of my yard that had drifts. Tonight might be the first night that stays above freezing, although the long-range forecast is back below freezing overnight in about a week. It didn’t get below -30°C this winter, which was a nice surprise (not counting the windchill ! !).

There’s 6 sensors inside and because of them, I know they kept a it a balmy 24°C (at the warmest sensor) all winter. I also know that they never went into the upper box (of two deeps). Because of the insulation, they didn’t need as much honey, and so they didn’t have to ‘eat their way up’. At one point there was a 57.4°C difference from the hottest in-hive reading to just outside the hive. (!!!)

I added some pollen patties in almost 3 weeks ago in prep for the spring flow (probably still 3 weeks away) and in doing so I was surprised at (1) how many bees there were, and (2) that they were all over the place. The outside temperature at the time I added the pollen patties was 3.5°C, and about 7 days after adding the patties the internal temps became much more flat with less day/night variation (which is far less that without insulation to begin with), so I sense they’re starting to brood - thought not close enough to any one sensor for me to be sure.

Our summers can get very hot (but very short), and I will keep them insulated all year. Their internal temperature was much more stable once I added the insulation. With the sensors, it was absolutely eye-opening.

Jim and his bee barns are the leading edge of beekeeping. It’s not for commercial operations, but if you’ve got a small enough number of hives, I would absolutely recommend it. I’m working on a version of a barn design that has some changes to suit my particular interests and to fit some conclusions that I have come to by using sensors. I was hoping to be finished later this month, but a death in the family has all progress paused.

On YouTube, be sure to lookup “Bug Farmer” who has a barn design (though I don’t think he needs the heating based on where he is), and absolutely be sure to lookup “Etienne Tardif” who is a data-heavy brilliant and/or mad scientist beekeeper in the Yukon.

3
Wonderbread003OP•

Oh man. Sorry for your loss. :(

I had my zone wrong originally. Not sure what I was looking at before. I am actually in 6a. I have a longer summer than you have. My area can still get cold for a couple weeks at a time unexpectedly. I really like the idea of them staying warm while using little energy along with being able to regulate the temp in the summer better.

What sensors do you buy/use?

Anyway you could send pics of your version or the modifications that you made when you have them done?

I know Jim has some sort of drainage for any kind of moisture for his. I didn’t make one for mine but I feel like I have mine sealed and insulated pretty well. So we will see how that goes.

Thanks for the other resources.

1
davidsandbrandZone 2b/3a, data-focused beekeeping•

I currently use wireless sensors from ruuvi.com, but my new design has hardwired sensors.

Yup, I’ll post a big write up with pics - if I ever get them finished 🤷.

I’m really curious to fully get into my hives to see how the condensation was. A couple times that I checked on the entrance being cleared (in warm periods) there was more water on the bottom board than I had expected - but that could have been because of the warm-snap. Also, water isn’t bad, it’s only bad if it’s uncontrolled or coming from above.

I’m still going back-and-forth between a solid bottom or a screened bottom for the new design - both would be fully insulated though. Moisture is a big part of the decision point. I like Jim’s concept of a drainage system, but I see some opportunities for improvement- I just don’t know if it’s worth the effort, or if I have the time. We’ll see.

1
j2thebees7th year back, 15-30 colonies + bunch of mating nucs•

I use several Lyson 6-frame poly nucs. It's the expanded bead (high density) styrofoam. I dearly love them, but they've gone up to $56. Still a bargain as you can add a 2nd and 3rd box for 24ish.

On my langstroth 10-frames I put a 1" blueboard under the lid. But this in the mountains of TN, not Quebec. I like to raise a few queens late (or keep my last few) and I can put a ridiculously small colony in one of these nucs and have a pretty good shot at overwintering.

2