Help! WHEAs after changing motherboards.

Hello, I upgraded my mobo from an Asus b550 prime to a Crosshair viii Hero x570 and cannot run the same memory frequency/FCLK without Whea errors now. I was able to run 4000/2000 on the prime without errors on the prime, now I'm getting wheas unless I drop the frequency to 3800/1900 on the Crosshair board.

Seems crazy to me, I know the CPU can handle it as it comes run those settings on the cheaper board, what could cause something like this? I've mirrored my voltage and DRAM settings over, and tried a bunch of different combinations. On the latest BIOS, tried reseating ram and CPU, no change. The Crosshair has a ton more settings I can adjust, maybe something else on the board causing issues?

Posted Apr 7, 2023, 12:16 PM UTC

118
Regular-Mechanic-1505800X3D -30 all Core / 3800CL16 / 6900XT 2.7ghz•

I was able to push my DDR4 further on my old B350 too, now on B550.

B350 could handle 4000/2000 now in B550 3800/1900

B350 was a Strix F Gaming B550 is a Rog Strix B550 F Gaming

CPU 5800X3D

2
dev044OP•

Honestly I bought this mobo hoping to push my memory OC further.. I mean 2.5gb lan and a twice the USB ports are nice but I'm debating on returning here as I lost performance, just blows my mind that the cheap 4 layer prime board performs better than this expensive mobo

1
Regular-Mechanic-1505800X3D -30 all Core / 3800CL16 / 6900XT 2.7ghz•

I kept the B550 because of the PCI E 4.0, but I feel you.

Have you tried other voltages VDIMM, SOC etc? For me nothing worked tho 4000/2000 never booted once on my B550.

1
dev044OP•

Yeah still trying various things.. hoping I can find the magical setting somewhere.. SOC, dram voltage, vddg, vddp, nothing seems to resolve it, I can speed up and slow down the Whea errors but they still come

1
Shadowdane•

You can't really directly copy voltages from one board to another one. Even if they are identical boards. Hell sometimes even BIOS updates will change things slightly needing tweaks to voltages.

It's entirely possible you got a bad board too. Different platform but I found my Asus Z790-E just flat out won't do above DDR5-6400 with running into stability issues. I purchased DDR5-7200 kit and never got it 100% stable. I didn't consider the motherboard when I first got it and went through 3 CPUs & 5 memory kits over the course of a few months. At this point I'd have to RMA the board with Asus and I honestly don't want to go through that. There is even that possibility they deny my RMA claim and I end up sending it back for nothing.

At the moment I just settled on DDR5-6000 with pretty tight timings and I'm happy with it. But there is still a small performance hit compared to the DDR5-7200 kit I had before.

1
dev044OP•

Yeah I'm still trying to get rid of the wheas and I've tried tons of combinations of voltages, nothing seems to help. I'm just blown away the $100 board is a better memory overclocking than the high end hero. I guess I need to figure out if I'd rather have all the perks of the hero IO or go back the prime for better ram performance, even if it's just marginal

1
Shadowdane•

If you can still return it.. try a 2nd board and see if it's better. My friend bought the same Asus Z790-E board as me as well as the same DDR5-7200 kit. He had zero issues with it.

I wish I had figured out the issues myself while I was in the return window. Would have saved myself months of troubleshooting and CPU & memory swaps.

1
dev044OP•

So I got the board used off ebay, I could probably push for a return saying the board didn't work properly but I wouldn't get a replacement board and seems like a skeezy as the board does work at lower frequency.

Which you would think if the board works fine at a slightly lower frequency it wouldn't be bad hardware but I guess things aren't that black and white.

1
TheWolfLoki☄️[email protected] 1.365vCore 32GB B-Die@4300c16•

I would try using training settings, its very likely the two boards have tried different subtimings, OR that voltage is not the same between them. Even CPU voltages matter so you will have to experiment some, even a tiny bump in voltage can probably stabilize it.

1
dev044OP•

I've set the sub timings, even if I loosen everything out it's still wheas, I'm going to keep wacking at it but I just don't think the board can do it which seems crazy to me

1
Antzuuuu•

Have you verified actual performance? It's possible your old board set something looser, and was stable at a higher frequency because of that.

1
dev044OP•

What do you mean by verify actual performance? I've ran OCCT memory benchmark and it scored about the same with those same settings, just throwing wheas at the same time. It's weird cause the PC doesn't crash or showing any signs of instability, just throwing wheas on the same routine schedule, 1 Whea about 2 minutes after boot, and then steady 8-10 errors at time but PC continues to act normal.

I've got a zen timing screenshot from before and everything looks the same as far as things I can control, there's a few other items on there I cannot adjust tho

1
Antzuuuu•

Well, something just like OCCT bench. Maybe you could run AIDA too, to check on the latency. Are your tPHY timings identical?

1
dev044OP•

I had aida but trial ran out, benching isn't my issue, I have pretty identical performance with the same settings applied, it's just spitting wheas constantly, system seems completely normal but consistent stream of bus/interconnect errors that go away if I drop mhz

1
Antzuuuu•

Pretty identical isn't identical tho. I can easily run 4266Mhz with 1:1 on my 13900K, even tighten the subs and terts a little bit. But if I go full blast on the subtimings, RTL's etc my IMC can't handle 4266Mhz anymore, but 4133Mhz with everything cranked is just as fast in real performance.

1