Okbuddyliberals•

This program would be universal and include no income phase-ins or phase-outs.

Ugh, hell no

The CTC expansion already had income limits that were ridiculously high, and wasn't even work tested. Making it cover even more middle/upper class folks who don't need handouts? No thanks!

Plus they made the proposed payout even higher than the CTC expansion under Biden was. Again, to more people who don't deserve handouts. It would be one thing to suggest significant expansions to the payouts while targeting it more around poor people who actually need help, but that's not all they do with this proposal

3†
jadothOP:paine: Thomas Paine•

and wasn't even work tested.

The money is for the kids, do you want the kids to work?

And if after implanting this we think well off people have too much money than we can raise the rate on high income brackets and possibly capital income slightly.

The difference between that and income phase outs is that income phase outs impose paperwork and opportunities to fall through the cracks on everyone and makes rich people with kids worse off comparatively to rich people without kids. Neither of those things are desirable to me.

3
EmpiricalAnarchism:brown-2: Terrorism and Civil Conflict•

It’s myth to believe that cash transfers to parents are going to be separated into a specific pool used only for child-related expenses when there are no mechanisms put in place to assure this. Rich families don’t need a subsidy to reward them for having children. Every dime spent on subsidies to rich families is taken from the mouths of impoverished children. It’s grift, and should be rejected as such.

1
jadothOP:paine: Thomas Paine•

Every dime spent on subsidies to rich families is taken from the mouths of impoverished children.

No, not if you pay for it by raising taxes on well off people, which is where the majority of tax revenue comes from already.

And why should rich households with children be worse off comparatively to rich households without children than poor households with children are comparatively to poor households without children? Do we want to disincentives our societies most successfully people from having children?

I just see no good reason to introduce this distortion when it can be avoided, even if it isn't the most pressing detail since rich households with children will be fine either way.

1
EmpiricalAnarchism:brown-2: Terrorism and Civil Conflict•

Children cost money. That isn’t a “distortion,” that’s a fact. Changing this isn’t a legitimate function of the state. Trying to castigate opposition to a regressive handout to the wealthy as remedying a distortion is frankly Orwellian doublespeak.

Also, opportunity costs exist no matter how you raise that revenue, because you could still choose to spend the money you’re handing out to the wealthy on the poor instead. My tax dollars should not be spent making the lives of those significantly wealthier than me better off.

2
Okbuddyliberals•

No, I want the parents to work. I'm all for expanding aid to poor parents, but I want it done in a way that incentivizes parents to be productive, rather than just taking the money and using it to replace income from working while choosing to work less

0†
jadothOP:paine: Thomas Paine•

The data shows that giving people money in this way generally doesn't result in people working less, and to the extant it does it is people moving out of wage work into unpaid care work (ie taking care of their children) not into "lazing around".

Also we are currently breaking our low unemployment record month after month and have rising labor force participation so that isn't really a pressing issue we are facing, while childhood poverty is.

(btw i added more to my first comment)

2
Okbuddyliberals•

The data shows that giving people money in this way generally doesn't result in people working less

Then they should be able to pass the work test, yes?

and to the extant it does it is people moving out of wage work into unpaid care work (ie taking care of their children) not into "lazing around".

Poverty causes issues due to not having enough money. Even if it's not lazing around, it could be better to have incentives arranged in such a way as to make these folks more likely to have more money

Also we are currently breaking our low unemployment record month after month and have rising labor force participation so that isn't really a pressing issue we are facing, while childhood poverty is.

We have a labor shortage too. Let's not take action that would add to it. And even a non universal child tax credit expansion would still help fighting childhood poverty

(btw i added more to my first comment)

Ok

The difference between that and income phase outs is that income phase outs impose paperwork and opportunities to fall through the cracks on everyone and makes rich people with kids worse off comparatively to rich people without kids. Neither of those things are desirable to me.

The IRS already has most folks' income info, so it doesn't necessarily need to be done in a way that requires people to fill out more paperwork than they are already filling out to do their taxes

And if after implanting this we think well off people have too much money than we can raise the rate on high income brackets and possibly capital income slightly.

Sounds like the worst of both worlds, politically. You give handouts to the rich, and also raise taxes more than would be necessary if we had more means tested aid? Sounds like a way to get shit on from multiple directions

I fucking love means testing. We've got folks on the left who want to just give free shit to everyone whether or not they need it, and we've folks on the right who want to give nobody shit they need even if they are trying their best in life and just got unlucky. Means testing is a great compromise between the excesses of the left and the heartlessness of the right

1
brucebananaray:george: Henry George•

I prefer Mitt Romney's version

1