Narcissists and other "irredeemables" - is there an end goal?

Question

TL:DR: Youtube mental health channels often have certain demonized groups

Watched a Dr. K. video recently and fell down a youtube mental health recommendation rabbit hole.
I see so many channels that focus on specific issues, a common one being dealing with toxic people in your life. And in those videos, certain groups will to varying degrees be treated as bordering inhuman. The most prolific example being narcissists.
Now, disclaimer: In the scenarios being described, these are not the victims, they tend to be the perpetrators. I don't mean to take away from that.
It's like watching a tutorial on how to beat an enemy NPC type. "Narcissists do this, and you should treat them like this." The only "human" is the one suffering under the narcissist, who in turn seems almost dehumanized.

So what's the end goal? What do we do with narcissists/perpetrators/whatevers? I feel like it's part of a greater trend of defining our undesirables, and treat them like an "out of sight, out of mind" kind of deal. But they are people, and they are still here. So what do we do with them? What's the plan? Are they supposed to just figure out how to be "good" people? Is there no redemption?

I'm working to become a teacher and so I'm continuously preparing myself for a life of looking out for both bullies and victims, under- and overachievers, and the generally "unremarkable" average kids. Ensuring that I do right by each of them as best I can, and when it's inevitably not enough then to try equally hard for all of them. To see each of them as a goal onto themselves, is essentially my vow.
And this feels at odds with the kind of content I described.

Posted Apr 11, 2023, 2:37 AM UTC

1811
KiwiKal•

As I understand it, there's no healthy way to deal with a narcissist once they have lost it.

You either stop them with force or you let their irrational tantrum play out by ignoring them.

Anything else, and you're either giving them exactly what they want and enforce future bad behavior or prolong the tantrum.

14
junk_mail_haver•

Your empathy is a narcissist's weapon. They has no such empathy for you, they are empty shells because of the adverse trauma they experienced since childhood leading to grandiose imagery of themselves replaced with actual personality. It's maladaptive, the best you can do is stay away from them, let them go and chase their victim.

There's other kind of narcissists too, like vulnerable narcissist, who is opposite of grandiose narcissist. They play victims often and they are pretty much go under the radar because they are smart enough to use their self esteem issues and cover it up other things or manipulate people into believing something which they are not and gaining sympathy out of their victimhood.

There's other types too.

Basically you have to stay away from toxic people, as far as possible, they will definitely strike you if they see you as a target and that's unavoidable, and there's plenty of people in the world like that.

8
BeornPlush•

I think this hits the nail on the head. The absence of reciprocal empathy and benevolence is a breach of the implicit 'social contract' that unites us, and by them breaching it, you're at no fault steering clear and offering them none of your social capital. Since you're the only one left fending for yourself in that scenario, you do what's best for you.

9
junk_mail_haver•

The one who goes from hot to cold and then again repeating the cycle become Borderline(BPD), and they have empathy towards you and then they withdraw it all and become vicious and it goes on. According to Prof. Sam Vaknin they are failed Narcissists.

Narcissists will do everything to be the centre of things, if they are not, they lose their minds, if they have no supply, they lose their minds, I think a lot of people have become narcissistic because you can clearly see them in social media.

I can also go on controversial topics such as communal narcissism but the reddit lynch mob will tear me apart and ban me(another example of communal narcissism or group think).

3
ccflier•

You can't fix anybody. You cannot help anyone who doesn't want to be helped.

They aren't irredeemable. We just can't redeem them ourselves.

It's not to stop interacting with them forever. It's to only put up with them as much as needed. To not let them ruin your life with how they decide to act.

If you don't need them in your life, don't let them stay in your life.

The first step is admitting you have a problem. If they don't think they have a problem, then they will never feel like they have to change.

6
wingedumbrella•

How their social group treat them will probably exacerbate or reduce how much they lean into the most destructive behavior pattern. In a good group, toxic behavior would also be less impactful to others, because they would have like 3 times good interactions to bad. So an occasional bad interaction wont affect you that much when you're overall treated well where you feel valued. In an empathetic group, chances are more people would understand how the toxic person is treating others because of their own inner turmoil more so than having to do with them personally as well.

If we had a very mentally healthy society, their tendency to lean into their destructive tendencies would probably be drastically reduced, not to mention there'd probably be overall less individuals that became dysfunctional to the point of personality disorders in the first place. Even some psychopaths can lead somewhat normal lives under some circumstances.

Ofc, unless we get some sort of genetic engineering or whatever, there will probably always be a limited amount of people who will be dysfunctional to the point of always causing great harm to others. In such case they would either have to be permanently imprisoned, or well.... killed.

I think the point is that at current date, the only thing we can do is try to reduce the problem. Some treatment of people probably feeds or deincentivize dysfunctional behavior. Probably very difficult and complex to do well. I guess trying to read more about such things could be a start if that's what you feel motivated to do? I'd think in psychology there's probably some literature somewhere about how to meet people without escalating, but at the same time set boundaries.

3
[deleted]•

Y’know, this is a subject I’ve thought about at great depth, so I appreciate you putting it into words.

I feel that personality disorders have become a certain way which we describe certain types of people. Instead of using words like “crazy” we know say “bpd”. Instead of saying “piece of shit” we say “narcissist”.

We shouldn’t treat someone poorly, beca Nobody is a narcissist, but people are labeled as narcissists, because they act like narcissists

At the end of the day, it’s all behaviours that we perceive and tie assumptions too. If we think about the research and scientific basis of these types of disorders, it’s honestly all pretty subjective.

If you tell me you want to be the president, are you a dreamer? Or do you have a grandiose sense of self worth?

Do you lack empathy? Or are you trying to act tough because your afraid?

What does narcissism mean to different cultures? How does a grandiose sense of self worth compare with an American vs with a Mexican?

How do you study a narcissist? And how do you study enough narcissists to name a disorder?

How much of our conceptualization of narcissism is molded by judeo Christian values?

How many times do you have to act as a narcissist to be perceived as a narcissist?

2†

How a behavior or pattern is described is less important than the affects of the behavior

2
[deleted]•

Yeah, that’s part of what I’m saying

0
AutoModeratorMOD•

Thank you for posting on r/Healthygamergg! This subreddit is intended as an online community and resource platform to support people in their journey toward mental wellness. With that said, please be aware that support from other members received on this platform is not a substitute for professional care. Treatment of psychiatric disease requires qualified individuals, and comments that try to diagnose others should be reported under Rule 10 to ensure the safety and wellbeing of the community. If you are in immediate danger, please call emergency services, or go to your nearest emergency room.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1

There's times when they can barely help themselves (victims) How are you expecting them to help their perpetrator then?

1