Google, Facebook and 20 other brands can’t open shops near first Apple store in Mumbai
thefederal.com/business/rival-brands-cant-ope...Posted Apr 11, 2023, 3:04 PM UTC
Posted Apr 11, 2023, 3:04 PM UTC
As per the agreement accessed by data analytic firm CRE Matrix and assessed by the Economic Times, brands including, Amazon, Facebook, Google, LG, Microsoft, Sony, Twitter, Bose, Dell, Devialet, Foxconn, Garmin, Hitachi, HP, HTC, IBM, Intel, Lenovo, Nest, Panasonic and Toshiba cannot open stores in the “exclusive” Apple zone. The report highlights 21 names, but the missing brand could be Samsung.
Looks like they didn't consider (or maybe just didn't list) Xiaomi, Vivo, and many other competitors that are big in south Asia but not the USA.
And what do Amazon, Twitter, Foxconn, Hitachi, and HTC (that's a brand I haven't seen in a while) sell that could compete with Apple's consumer products?
Some of them are obvious competitors (Amazon offers Kindle, HTC offers a phone), others not so much. Twitter doesn't even have a "store."
Seems to be common, though. Walmart doesn't want to invest time and money into a location, have other stores build up around it, and then Target later comes in right next door. These agreements make sense before a large company decides to break ground.
In this case, Apple is likely concerned about what these companies will do in the next 15-20 years, rather than the next 5-10.
Some of them are obvious competitors (Amazon offers Kindle, HTC offers a phone), others not so much.
Yeah, but the Kindle is low-end, and HTC has no phones that come close to the iPhone.
In this case, Apple is likely concerned about what these companies will do in the next 15-20 years, rather than the next 5-10.
Yeah, that makes more sense.
Looks like they didn't consider (or maybe just didn't list) Xiaomi, Vivo, and many other competitors that are big in south Asia but not the USA.
Who is "they" in this context? Is this restriction at the request of Apple or an incentive from whoever is leasing the space in Jio World Drive Mall?
Either party could use this as a negotiating tactic, and brands may be missing because it wasn't in the leaseholder's favor to restrict them.
Wait, Facebook has a store? Twitter? Wat?
There's a Twitter coffee shop in Hanoi, Vietnam https://www.tripadvisor.com/Restaurant_Review-g293924-d6823116-Reviews-Twitter_Beans_Coffee-Hanoi.html
(Mostly because US trademarks don't apply there, which is hilarious)
Wouldn’t matter anyways the type of people buying a iPhone in India are likely not cross shopping very much.
Well you won’t find Universal soft toys in Disneyland and vice versa for miles and miles.
Most people, yes, but there would be a few people who could be attracted to the Samsung flagships and get that instead, for example, if they initially considered an iPhone.
You must know India very well. What part are you from?
My folks are from there and I’ve been there countless times. The iPhone is a status symbol there and we usually take our old iPhones and gift them to relatives who would never be able to afford them otherwise.
Same with us in Europe, “Save that 3GS for your cousins baby, we will take it back with us and she can use it at daycare”
[removed]
[deleted]
Yes, how could this be a clause...its in your face...
$600k per year to the mall plus revenue sharing. That’s a spicy lease!
I don’t get how they could make money out of this.
It’s not like people are going to buy a Mac or an iPhone just because the next Samsung store is not directly near them. It’s not about convenience or access, it’s about pricing, design, philosophy etc
I don’t see anyone saying « oh well, can’t find a Samsung store, I’ll buy an iPhone instead ». It’s not like the internet didn’t exists, stores are everywhere your phone/computer is
It's because they don't want other brands to benefit from the traffic that an Apple Store would bring. Every Apple Store brings tons of people, even those who are not necessarily thinking about buying a product. And competitors, just by being next door would greatly benefit from that.
By that logic, why does Apple need to store in the first place?
It’s marketing. To answer your question : to add visibility
But do you believe that marketing is more effective if there isn’t any other brand right next to you ? Honestly I don’t think so
Apple's shtick in India is exclusivity. The only people who can afford most apple products are the very wealthy. If that shopping experience seems even more exclusive, then it's an easy way to elevate their brand even more.
Plus corruption is rampant. If you can negotiate this into your lease by slipping some cash in a few people's pockets, then why not?
Damn I stop at the Twitter store every time I see one
Rule 1:
No reposting and/or rehosted content. Please check the /new section of the sub to see if the topic you want to post about has been posted by another user. Also, if your post includes rehosted content (meaning it is summarizing news/information from a different source), please instead post a link to the original source.
If you have any questions about this removal, modmail us.
Thank you for your submission!
As per the agreement accessed by data analytic firm CRE Matrix and assessed by the Economic Times, brands including, Amazon, Facebook, Google, LG, Microsoft, Sony, Twitter, Bose, Dell, Devialet, Foxconn, Garmin, Hitachi, HP, HTC, IBM, Intel, Lenovo, Nest, Panasonic and Toshiba cannot open stores in the “exclusive” Apple zone. The report highlights 21 names, but the missing brand could be Samsung.
Twitter??
India has all the bad parts of democracy.
Edit: Your downvotes mean nothing, I've seen what makes you upvote.
That may be true but I'm not sure what that has to do with the terms of a private lease. Mall tenants are naturally particular about their neighbors, regardless of the electoral system.
Govt permits, red tapes and the bribes associated with them.
Wherever Apple Store is established is the good side of town.
Exactly, Apple did the research to decide where to put a store, so why should every other get to ride on their coattails. Remember when Microsoft opened stores adjacent to a bunch of Apple stores? And then they closed them all anyway, heh.
In the same way having a Starbucks is a sign that your area is affluent as well.
Microsoft failed because Windows isn't a luxury brand. Apple is.
Yes, I will get hate for saying that but in all seriousness the design target of Apple products isn't for the hoi poloi who are willing to pay $50 less so they'd use a high-end TN panel over the cheapest of the cheap IPS panel.
Why would you willingly go to the bad part of town?
Not all. We don't have gerrymandering (unfortunately, we haven't redrawn parliamentary districts in like 50 years partially because of opposition from the southern states*), and we sure as hell don't restrict the poor and minority races from voting by closing poll booths early.
But yeah, we have corruption, bribes, religious politics, and a lot of bad stuff. And unfortunately the "don't restrict the poor and minority races from voting" part is slowly becoming false because India is declaring hundreds of thousands of people to be illegal immigrants simply because they don't have any government-accepted proof of citizenship (it is common for older rural people to not have those).
* According to some stuff I read online (I can't tell whether it is the truth or not), India's southern states oppose new parliamentary districts because they would then get fewer districts due to having fewer people (and the southern states have fewer people because they are more developed and effectively implemented indirect population control measures, so this is like giving less political representation to the states that have done a better job caring for their people).
India is declaring hundreds of thousands of people to be illegal immigrants simply because they don't have any government-accepted proof of citizenship (it is common for older rural people to not have those).
Isn't India doing biometrics scanning to register billions of Indians for the purpose of social services and a national ID system?
Yeah, and that biometric system is pretty much fully set up (it is called Aadhar), but the current government also has a law called the "Citizenship Amendment Law" that means that "anyone who has no proof of citizenship and is not a Hindu/Sikh/Jain/Buddhist/Parsi/Christian from India's Muslim neighbouring countries will be deported". This photo should explain it. There were protests against that 3 years ago, but COVID ended those protests and no one cares about that law.
Citizenship ammendment act provided citizenship to non Muslims refugees from neighboring Muslim countries who are escaping prosecution in those countries. Which provision of it says that it will take citizenship away from people. Do you mind posting a source here?
What countries have the good parts?
What countries have the good parts?
From a Filipino's point of view: Singapore
Within 1 generation he was able to lift a malaria-infested backwater without shit into the richest nation in South East Asia.
Lifting millions out of poverty into upper middle class and even rich.
What he did was all the positives of democracy.
So a city half the size of Delhi and 1/6th the population. What a joke. That’s like saying Bangaluru has a great democracy and the entire population is middle class. Peak Reddit moment here.
These types of restrictive covenants are a very typical practice in the commercial real estate industry, especially in the US. Not much of a story here
[removed]