r/gamedev•
Zweistar

Oh my god shut up about AI

I've seen the same question asked in different ways several times a day, every day, for the last few months. Please just stop asking if AI will replace anybody any time soon, it won't. If a hypothetical robot is enough to dissuade you from making something, you didn't really want to make it.

Posted Apr 15, 2023, 4:29 PM UTC · locked

2K177
TouGamedev•

I agree and love this quote: " If a hypothetical robot is enough to dissuade you from making something, you didn't really want to make it."

1.3K
innercityFPV•

To be fair, most of my coworkers could probably qualify as hypothetical robots.

232
Vizerdrixx•

Or put the effort in making it unique. As a pixel artist, AI can make things with prompts atm sure, but it can’t maintain consistent styles or actually design.

At this point it’s just a glorified reference generator for an actual artist to create.

177
CheezeyCheeze•

It can if you make a LoRA.

https://www.reddit.com/r/StableDiffusion/comments/126uhny/my_first_lora_gravity_falls_style/

And you can do different poses of characters that you black out the surrounding image. You can also mark out things and put your image ON top of another image.

So if you ask for a forest. Then take that Image and ask for Zelda it can do it.

Then you can use something similar to cutouts to fix things that are wrong. Like say you have a cube floating in the sky. You can select around that cube and ask the AI to fill in that gap with your prompt.

https://stable-diffusion-art.com/inpainting_basics/

This is very similar to photoshop and cutting together an image. But instead of having existing images to paste in you just ask for it to generate that image.

You can use textual inversion to teach it a concept.

https://huggingface.co/docs/diffusers/training/text_inversion

My point is. You can make 2D art with it. And make it consistent.

It takes a lot more work than just asking it to make it perfect first go.

147
aStoveAbove•

If a hypothetical robot is enough to dissuade you from making something, you didn't really want to make it.

I love this sentiment, but I want to add:

It shouldn't dissuade you, it should encourage you.

AI being able to do game dev stuff lowers the barrier of entry. Lower barriers of entry means more people can join us in game dev, and means its easier to accomplish your goals when making a game.

Access to newer and better tools should never discourage you. It should inspire you to utilize them and make even better games.

89
MyPunsSuckCommercial (Other)•

Well, to be fair, there is a huge barrier to entry into professional game dev, which automation tools might exacerbate. A lot of people are competing for entry level jobs, and it would suck if there's suddenly just as many people competing for half as many jobs

62
LesbianCommander•

I didn't mind it at first, but yeah after like 2 weeks, 2 threads minimum per day about AI, it does get kind of obnoxious.

280
DuskEalain•

Agreed. I suspect with the recent law changes (at least in the US) there will be a decline in it. Like how Crypto was all the craze until legislations got involved and people were getting hung for scams, AI will likely go silent outside of its niche now that it can't be used/peddled as a "get rich quick/easy" scheme.

40
Goochregent•

I haven't been keeping up with recent developments but i agree.

You look on Open AI discord and everyone is praising it as the future, then immediately trying to get it to produce monetised content like books without skill or effort. The moment it doesn't work too well they give up lol.

The moment the get rich quick element dissipates, it should return to normality.

79
DuskEalain•

Yep, we've been here before and we'll be here again.

then immediately trying to get it to produce monetised content like books without skill or effort. The moment it doesn't work too well they give up lol.

It's the same reason you see people go "I'm gonna be a game developer!" until they actually open up an engine and try to program something, then all of a sudden they're silent on the matter. People want the success, romance, and clout that comes with being a successful game dev, artist, author, whatever without actually putting the work in.

38
mattgrum•

AI will likely go silent outside of its niche

I feel this comment is going to look hilariously short sighted in a few years. AI is already disrupting industries, fashion houses are replacing models, it's only just getting started.

65
DuskEalain•

And AI is already being regulated by law, which is the same thing that lead to the crypto crash that was also supposed to disrupt and revolutionize everything. I'm not saying it won't be used, just that it's going to find its place in the world and not be the "TECHNOLOGICAL REVOLUTION!!!1!1!" techbros praise it as.

US lawmakers have already added to copyright and IP laws stating that unless significant modification is made to products generated with AI tools, the end product lacks human authorship and is thus invalid for copyright protection. This has huge ramifications for its place in creative fields like illustration, film, and - as this sub is about - game development where brand is king and anything that risks weakening that brand's legal strength as an IP is seen as an immediate threat.

Do you really think Activision is going to risk their multibillion franchise just to avoid paying a few writers to script a CoD campaign? Or that Disney is going to risk the MCU just to avoid paying a graphic designer to make a poster for Iron Man 42?

17†
piedamon•

It’s too bad the wrong questions are being asked. AI tools are a significant advancement for game design and development, and there isn’t enough education about optimal or proper use.

223

And you don't even know if you should be using them yet, for copyright reasons. I'd personally wait for the courts to deal with the lawsuits, and the regulations to be put into place before I would touch AI for any project :)

70
piedamon•

Yeah, data security is a high risk across the board, especially with generative models.

Local LLMs are the safest bet at the moment.

16
burros_killer•

Idk dude. Chat gpt could help me with rather a simple refactoring issue that I wanted it to do while I was in a meeting. It just went into an infinite loop after a short while. Not sure it is really a helpful tool for anything other than finding a recipe for a common simple dish or something like that. Maybe I'm missing something tho

-21
Keesual•

The term ai gets thrown around alot but its basically means applied machine learning, which basically mean really fancy schmancy statistics and algorithms.

But practically it depends what you want out of it and which tool you use. There isnt a one size fits all.

You already have people using GPT for dialogue/fluff-writing and programming assistance, ludo.ai as a ideation/research tool. eleven.ai for the voices, cassadeur for ai-assisted animation, one of the many image models to make concept art/image assets/textures, ai-assisted photogrammetry tools for 3d assets.

Hell, tools that assist with uv mapping/npc-pathing/etc have existed before the whole ai-hype but could arguably be categorized under such (you see lots of companies recently rebranding certain features/tools as “ai” or “ai-assisted” even though nothing changed)

17
android_queenCommercial (AAA/Indie)•

ChatGPT is also working off old data, so, for example, if you want to know anything about Unreal 5, you’re out of luck.

16
MyPunsSuckCommercial (Other)•

It also has absolutely no sense of logic, so it's garbage at generating code it doesn't have a 1:1 exact reference for

27
themoregames•

I've seen the same question asked in different ways several times a day, every day, for the last few months

You must be new here - a very warm welcome! Speaking of frequent questions, I wanted to take the opportunity to ask you...

  1. "What programming language should I learn to make games?"
  2. "How do I get started in game development?"
  3. "What game engines should I use for my game?"
  4. "What skills do I need to become a game developer?"
  5. "How do I create art and graphics for my game?"
  6. "How do I market my game and get it noticed?"
  7. "How do I get funding for my game?"
  8. "What are some common mistakes to avoid when making a game?"
  9. "How do I find a team to work on a game with?"
  10. "What are some good resources for learning game development?"

Fun fact: Yes, I just asked ChatGPT for this list.

Question 11 might just be

  • Which laptop should I buy?

And by the way, I am in a special situation: I'm 21m/f, I'm still in college AND I DON'T KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT CODING!!!=!!! YOU MUST REALLY LEARN THAT I DON'T KNOW ANYTHING THAT'S WHY I WRITE IN ALL CAPS!!!!=!=!!! To give you a little bit more background, ...

Wait, why do I need to come up with this nonsense, I am sure ChatGPT knows all about these "special situations". ChatGPT, please go finish this comment:

And by the way, I am in a special situation: I'm 21m/f, I'm still in college AND I DON'T KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT CODING!!!=!!! YOU MUST REALLY LEARN THAT I DON'T KNOW ANYTHING THAT'S WHY I WRITE IN ALL CAPS!!!!=!=!!! To give you a little bit more background, I have been playing games my entire life and have always been fascinated by game development. I have a great idea for a game that I think could be the next big thing, but I have no idea how to make it a reality. I've been researching game development for weeks now and have watched countless YouTube tutorials, but I just can't seem to wrap my head around the coding aspect.

I'm wondering if there are any resources out there that can teach me how to code without making it too complicated. I've tried reading books and taking online courses, but they all seem to assume that I have some sort of coding background. I really need something that starts from the basics and doesn't assume any prior knowledge.

I know that I'm in a tough spot, but I'm willing to put in the work to learn how to code and make my game a reality. I just need a little bit of guidance to get started. Thank you so much for your help!"


My goodness, ChatGPT basically nailed it. This part is so unbelievably true to reality, I just have to copy and paste this pure gem a 2nd time:

To give you a little bit more background, I have been playing games my entire life and have always been fascinated by game development. I have a great idea for a game that I think could be the next big thing, but I have no idea how to make it a reality. I've been researching game development for weeks now and have watched countless YouTube tutorials, but I just can't seem to wrap my head around the coding aspect.

162
PioneerSpecies•

Also “am I too old to start programming/game design?”

93
caesium23•

More specifically, “I'm turning 7 next year, am I too old to start programming/game design?”

(Yes, obviously I'm exaggerating (slightly), but now that I'm ahem-years-old, these types of posts just particularly stick in my craw. (Yes, I'm so old I have a craw now.))

80
android_queenCommercial (AAA/Indie)•

But I’m 27, and I just think it’s too late for me to do something new with my life!

20
[deleted]•

[deleted]

43
MyPunsSuckCommercial (Other)•

Aw, I want a craw. Am I too young to get one?

3
dethb0y•

Yeah if you don't like constant, repetitive questions, /gamedev is not a great sub for you.

My least favorite are "argue with me why i should/should not do <thing>" where <thing> is literally anything from using a given game engine to quitting their job to do full time development to god knows what else.

Or the fucking idiots who are like "guyzzzzz 100$ is WAY TO MUCH to list on steammmmmmmm why cant it be freeeeeee"

32
NeverComments•

My least favorite are the "how do I run a business?" questions that are barely related to game development.

"How do I do taxes?"

"How do I market a product?"

"How do I sell goods in exchange for money?"

16
dethb0y•

oh man yeah those are awful!!!

5
Hotchillipeppa•

100$ is too much to be fair

-9
ledat•

It's really not. You get all of it back if you make $1000 in sales. If you don't expect to make that much in sales, Steam is not the right place. Itch exists for that niche.

32
Hotchillipeppa•

I suppose you are right

3
_KoingWolf_Commercial (AAA)•

It forgot about schools and if going one is helpful or not to your perspective career. (The answer is it depends)

10
stewsters•

Wow, that's spot on.

8
HammyTruth•

AI has already replaced many, many Reddit users. The only problem? all these GPT-driven users are interested in is asking people on tech-related boards about the upcoming AI-takeover of the world.

71
crilen•

ChatGPT: "sooo I'm just talking hypotheticals here but if you were an AI how would YOU take over the world?"

22
Army165•

Idk about Ai, but definitely more bots. I've gotten 25 followers in the past week. I didn't even know you could be followed on here.

7
Calneon•

Please just stop asking if AI will replace anybody any time soon, it won't.

I like the sentiment of your post but unfortunately you're plain wrong about this. If anybody thinks AI isn't going to replace jobs in the near future, or isn't already reducing the amount of jobs, they're being naive.

50
denisbotev•

Care to provide some examples? And no, bloated article writers don’t count.

9
Calneon•

This is based on critical thinking and common sense, not articles or evidence, it's too early for that because as you alude to most of that is sensationalised.

Is a game development company going to immediately fire all of their artists and get AI do do the work instead? No, of course not. But, lets say they experiment with including some AI generated UI art in their pipeline. So some of the artists working on the project create some style guides and work on writing prompts to generate the art they need. It works well, and some of the AI art is integrated into the project.

The next project comes along, it's ambitious and the company wants to grow. They know the AI generated art was successful in the previous project so now, even though the project is larger in scope, they don't hire more artists or replace the ones that churn, because they know they can generate 50% of their art with AI. There are still UI artists on the team, but there are fewer of them.

The same can be said for 3D artists (obviously AI will be able to generate 3D models in the near future), writers, even engineers.

Now you might say, this is the same as with any new tool that's introduced. When SpeedTree was released, we probably saw a decrease in the amount of artists required to populate game worlds with foliage. Unreal 5 makes it much easier to generate procedural geometry from existing geometry, Lumen reduces the burden on lighting artists, etc. Is that any different? In a way, no it's not. But it's on a different scale, and those tools often create opportunities for expertise in other ways or allow increased scope to compensate. AI has the potential to create orders of magnitude of efficiency gains in all disciplines over a very short timeframe, and the industry simply isn't prepared for that.

30
Kallory•

I truly think some customer service jobs are on the way out. Otherwise, not a whole lot.

22
denisbotev•

While I agree that many companies will initially try to switch to AI based customer support, I still think the majority of users (at least those with more complex problems that can’t be solved with “have you tried turning it off and on again?”) would much rather speak to a human.

Current inplementations of LLMs are not capable of improvisation. At least I haven’t seen one

11
PSMF_Canuck•

Look…the reality is most artists and programmers are mediocre. They’ll never create anything compellingly unique or irreplaceable. Those are the people who will get replaced in the asset pipelines.

Genuine talent, as usual, will be fine. And they will leverage the new tech to widen even further the gap between actual talent and the unwashed masses.

14
denisbotev•

I agree to a certain point.

Even mediocre programmers are able to build a somewhat functioning system. Take a simple e-commerce website, for example. You need back end logic, a database, front end, which itself is one big intertwined pile of HTML, CSS and JS, nginx/apache server, hosting, payments, the list goes on. GPT will not be able to do a functioning combination of all that on its own anytime soon.

Art is another matter tho.

9
InfamousSabre•

Oh my god shut up about "Oh my god shut up about AI"

48
XtremeTurnip•

Omg shut up about shut up about shut up about ai! ^^ <3

26

Omg shut up about "shut up about 'shut up about 'shut up about ai!''"

4†
InterfaceBE•

GOTO :1

17
BellyDancerUrgot•

Funny note: I research in ML (diffusion models mainly for now) and used to be an SDE. The people who think AI is replacing anybody soon are either a) people who don’t have any business talking about AI (AI “influencers”) or b) people who are on the hype train. There is an equally useless third category c) AI doomers who think AI is about to take over the world.

The only place where current SoTA models are deployable without any human supervision are creative work like Art and creative writing.

LLMs are dogshit because they hallucinate all the time. Makes them super unreliable. Most of the time their hallucinations line up with reality but a significant but lower number of times it doesn’t and it’s still convincing enough that without a domain expert supervising it’s output , it could lead to a host of problems.

Diffusion is amazing at art but has a fck ton of legal ramifications.

Conditional GANs or other architectures for animations are the only place where there is a decent likelihood of an industry shift to intelligent algorithms. But where one job demand decreases another increases ie: people with the capabilities to harness this knowledge and make even better systems.

Personally something I found amazing and might revolutionize video games is this (although it is unlikely it actually takes away any jobs, might make ML a more core component of game dev tho which is exciting!) :

https://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03442

42
TrainsDontHunt•

Any tool built to replace programmers is so complicated you need a programmer to run it.

41
wutface0001•

yeah people don't really think about that for some reason

someone will need to debug that shit if it goes wrong, it can quickly become a nightmare

9
DrJamgo•

I think it will boost productivity more and more over time, but not replace entire jobs.

1
android_queenCommercial (AAA/Indie)•

Nope, any tool built to replace programmers is so complicated that you need someone who can direct programmers to run it. Subtle but very significant difference. There are a whole lot of programmers who don’t fit that.

-9
keldpxowjwsn•

I feel like the people the most worried about it are the people that know the least about it. Its just a magical black box that does everything like the movies when the reality is far different

The biggest downfall for chatgpt (currently) is the fact that it's incredibly naïve (security issues) as well as the fact it will always produce something. Even if the answer is wrong, itll produce something that sounds and looks true. If youre using it to do something you dont know about (like coding!) that obviously would be a very bad thing

Too many people treat it like a sentient AI from the movies instead of realizing its just a very complicated mesh of probabilities producing things that sound like what you want to hear.

40
PSMF_Canuck•

I mean…you basically just described the vast majority of humans, too…

26
PlebianStudio•

Im definitely loving chatgpt as a solo dev for doing a fuck ton of the boring coding for me. Like for an RPG with an elemental wheel system that uses traditional RPG stats. I just say make me like health str int mnd crit critdmg 8 element dmg and res, etc and make them all floats. Then add comments to them all.

Also being able to say make me an A* pathfinding script that will work for this game type. Basically it does a lot of the entry level programmer work for you. That is a godsend for independent developers especially solo devs. Me personally i love it and see it as another massive step in independence in the field. Arguably will be as huge of a step as the commercial game engine was so everyone doesnt have to spend years making their own niche engine.

27

AI won't eliminate gamedev for the same reason that photography didn't eliminate painters.

25
burros_killer•

AI won't eliminate gamedev for the same reason it won't eliminate anything - it's mostly useless. And also it is not AI - just an algorithm that stacks words or pixels together in a way that people see as appealing at this moment in human history. Art is complex and modern "AIs" are rather limited instruments for producing it. Make it more agile and it will become a picture\text editor

-22
iLiveWithBatman•

Except it will, because unlike photography it can produce literally anything, not just what exists in the world.

Bad analogy.

-41

That's not at all how ML/AI works, even with unsupervised algorithms, because output is always a reflection or derivation of the input data. If its not, then it's not Machine Learning, by definition.

Besides, look at the work of painters like Dali, Picasso, Pollock, Warhol, Whistler, Hopper, or Magritte. Did they only make things that just 'exist in the world'?

6†
CrypticXSystem•

because output is always a reflection or derivation of the input data.

Not to dive too much into philosophy, but I would have to agree with the other guy here "iLiveWithBatman". Note that I have no sort of certification to back up my claims and this is all just my thoughts and opinions.

Humans are the same thing as what you said, they get fed inputs. Anything "new" they create is based upon those inputs. You can't make a painting without having the inputs of colors. Actually, following from the monkey theorem. If you have millions of AI generating random images or even plotting random pixels on the screen from colors, it is fed. With enough time it will create every existing painting and any new paintings humans can ever hope of making. My point is, I think your idea of restricting something's output to only being able to make things that are related to its input, and you using that to compare humans to robots is a flawed idea. Again, this is just my opinion.

2

I see the comparison, but its worth pointing out that the difference between a human's sensory input/output and the most advanced large-language/image processing model is roughly similar to the gap between a graphing calculator and a supercomputer.

You're right that the base function is the same, in some cases ML tools were modeled on what we understand about reinforcement learning in people, but the complexity of the systems is vastly different, which means the Time requirement of our typewriting monkeys getting to shakespeare is astronomical

8
iLiveWithBatman•

AI even currently produces images of things that do not exist in the real world and cannot possibly be photographed.

-10
cinnamonbrook•

And factories can churn out canned soup, people still go to restaurants.

Art isn't going to disappear just because a machine can make a facsimile of it, the only people who think that are people who fuckin' sucked at making art and never cared about it in the first place.

4†

All those "impossible" things you see started as artwork or photo manipulation done by actual people, which was classified and fed into a ML tool, which is why dream/view/scape/etc can create a picture of Jesus and St. John in fursuits baptizing each-other in a river of orange fanta, because multiple iterations of all of those separate details exist in its data set, and the algorithm has been reinforced (trained) to combine them together as seamlessly as possible (except apparently for their fingers)

-3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-8

I guess it's also important to decide if you want to do it to make money, or if you want it to be your hobby :)

Although if they go too far and flood the market with AI games I'll probably get paraylzed by choice and go back to Fallout, lol

5
iLiveWithBatman•

Yeah, that's the point - the first option will become increasingly more difficult if not impossible for most people.

5
android_queenCommercial (AAA/Indie)•

I mean, a lot of us already made that choice, and it’s our career.

3
walachey•

By posting this, you became one of these AI posters you so disdain.

23
saxbophone•

Became the very thing you swore to destroy!

9
GeneralGom•

Nice try, AI.

21
GibTreaty•

This is how they take over. First, they try to silence us, and then they become us.

7
towcar•

The bigger problem isn't, "why are people continuing to ask this", it's why aren't we teaching people to Google/search better.

Most subs have this issue of generic questions being asked a million times. The fact that so many people are either too lazy or too incompetent to attempt to check for previous results, is a much bigger concern.

Imo

15
[deleted]•

I agree with your latter point, it’s frustrating but what your experiencing is just “game dev Twitter” imo.

Unfortunately I don’t agree with what you say about AI. AI is at the point that it’s good enough and accessible enough for it to shake up our industry. Voice actors for example in cases are now being paid for the rights to use there voices to train data sets. Admittedly it’s not a direct replacement but it will certainly effect those working on smaller studios as it’s simply more cost effective to by a trained data set then it is to hire a voice actor and a studio.

13
CBSuperHobbyist•

Will AI replace my wife? Asking for a friend.

12
TryCatchOverflow•

Circa 1990: Does what they calls "Internet" will replace humans jobs?

Yeah same story, different time!

11
android_queenCommercial (AAA/Indie)•

The internet did replace a lot of human jobs, though. We used to have these things called bookstores, for example.

At the same time, it created a lot of new jobs. For a long time, the response to having your job become obsolete was to say “learn to code.”

20
LogicOverEmotion_•

Someone posted in another thread about how computers replaced computers. Yes, there was a job called computer that humans once did.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_(occupation)

10
PSMF_Canuck•

It did.

It also created many new ones.

15
AskMoreQuestionsOk•

Yeah. But this time will be different! Lol

2
agathirmas•

I can understand why people keep emoting about it -- maybe folks just keep putting these fears out there hoping that someone would do just this, tell them they're wrong! carry on and keep doing what you love, you can't predict the future.

8
our_trip_will_pass•

Hey traditional animators of 1980's don't worry about computer graphics. It can barely render a 2D image after weeks of processing. It's impossible to get replaced by VFX. Have you seen the crappy images it makes? it can't even complex things like body movement. you're safe. Don't think about it.

8