How are ww2 veterans perceived?

Discussion

In the U S they are regarded as heros and often celebrated. In Germany I was told that they aren't acknowledged and or respected. How are the veterans of the military and resistance of WW2 treated in France? Have you met any? Tell me about it?

Posted Apr 16, 2023, 1:13 PM UTC

1586
nampa_69•

We don't have a lot of ww2 veterans anymore I think for the majority of French people, we don't think about them, so we won't critizise them but they aren't particularly honored too

But maybe some people will know better

42
Remarkable_Option660OP•

Aww:(

-1†
RaZZeR_9351•

They are honoured, its just that there are so few of them that its not something that we talk often about, plus most veterans will not want to talk about it anyway, my grandfather fought in the 1st DB and went all to the way to germany but he never ever talked about it and we had to wait for 20 years after his death to get a hold of his journal before we knew what had happened there

33
XLeyz•

Yeah, it almost feels like there's this "taboo" atmosphere around anything related to WWII times here (understandably so, considering the horrific events that took place in France back then). I wouldn't even ask my great-grandparents about it, personally.

6
Remarkable_Option660OP•

I see that's where the differences in culture meet.

-2†
[deleted]•

They are just old people in the population, but if I learned for example by talking with one of them that he was a veteran I think I would thank him.

Afterwards, of course, they are honored in the various commemorations and events.

37
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-6
[deleted]•

I don't think the youth of the 1960s/1970s would have gone to these commemorations either. You need some maturity and interest to go to these, which is often received when you reach an older age.

12
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
theold777•

We have 2 types of WW2 veterans: those who fougjt the campaign of France (may/June, 1940) in the regular French army, and the free French who fought for De Gaulle. The latter are regarded as the true French heroes. The first ones have been forgotten, as no one wants to remember a looser.

Both my grandfathers fought as officers in 1940, and fought well (I've checked their military records) then were demobilised after the defeat. They never talked to me about this period of their lives. An uncle of my mother's was a crew member in a free French bomber squadron, flew missions over Germany, got shot down and bailed in 1943, ended up as a POW. He told the story, and was decorated as "hero of the liberation". And, of course, members of the resistance, and the "French forces of the interior ".

25
Remarkable_Option660OP•

Aww that sad, I feel like both should be celebrated. They did their best

7

Well the first ones are well known for their excess of enthusiasm, servility even, for Nazi occupation. Not quite celebrating worthy.

-3
Banger7•

It's more than the first ones, and what happened in 1940, is badly known, and has a lot of associated preconceived ideas.

4
_Azyrheim•

in history and with how much it is talked about, the battle of France is mostly forgotten "the German attacked and then France loose that's it" that's mostly like that

2
hukaat•

Well, veterans in France and in the US are very different things - from what I've seen online, US veterans are almost worshipped (exagerating a bit, but still) and that's true for every war they fought in (... and even regular guys that enlisted and never really fought anything are "veterans" and not just ex-military, and "worshipped", and "thank you for your service"-d). We don't have the same relationship with our military, and that's maybe not such a bad thing !

About WWII especially, well, a good part of them didn't really fight, even if others definitely were in battles. We have an expression for that, those few months of expecting a fight, waiting, moving from one place to another expecting a fight that for some never came : the period is called "la drôle de guerre" (the weird war, basically). The resistants are more celebrated, yes, but most of them are dead nowadays so there's less people to represent this era : they're more historical figures now.

But you have to understand that this period of our history is a strange one, with many factors and events, and people that lived through the war don't talk about it very much. It's a mix of "shame", of privacy, of hard memories. For the US soldiers, they went to other countries and help fight "the big bad" to free them. For French people, it's all of the population that suffered for years, and people are very much more reserved because of that - you'll have trouble finding someone boasting their wartime prowesses.

16
Remarkable_Option660OP•

Yes, I understand the difference in culture. My nation is very military focused. And yes veterans are the term we used for ex military. They even get free benefits, like free healthcare. I understand where it stands now in France. But it's a bit odd considering in the U.S the us veterans are celebrated and those are informed on the french resistance also celebrate the french. Because without the french resistance DDay may not have been so successful

2
hukaat•

Oh, we also name them veterans - it’s really the same word with accents : vétérans. However it is only used for soldiers who fought in a war, if someone enlisted and served in the army without fighting, they would only be ex-soldiers. Veterans is a term that would be used for old and experimented ex-soldiers, like a honorific title. I believe military personel can have additional help from the state, including healthcare, but you’ll never have a discount at a restaurant or something like this

Well, thank you for not forgetting them - the resistance played a major role along the war, providing a lot of intel but not only ! A lot of people on the internet seem to only be able to repeat the same three old "haha french surrender"/"white flag"/"tank with rear mirror" """jokes""" and it’s a bit frustrating when you know how the entire country was affected and how ordinary people rose to fight !

3
Remarkable_Option660OP•

That's makes more sense to be honest. The veterans here get insane benefits. Makes me wish I signed up. Yes I I'll continue to remember them. I also know that France had no choice but to surrender given the circumstances and didn't do it out of cowardness. The Germans were no joke and the french were not prepared for it.

3
LazyAssInspector•

It's a bit more complex than that. France was prepared in a lot of ways. But the general staff and tactics weren't.

4
Remarkable_Option660OP•

But also most ww2 u.s vets do not brag about their experiences. Most people like family will do it for them. They don't really like to talk about it much. Especially the ones who fought in japan

2
Alarow•

I don't think there are many WW2 veterans left (it's been 80 years after all), but veterans are not worshipped like in the US, they're just normal people

14
Remarkable_Option660OP•

That's so strange, we are losing ours too we have about 200,000 left

-12
[deleted]•

Not really strange, they are just normal people who sadly lived a really difficult situation, and I think that most of them prefer to live peacefully than to be constantly reminded of what happened during the war. A lot of them were/are traumatized even 80 years later.

14
Remarkable_Option660OP•

I mean its strange for me, veterans are always regarded as heros in my nation no matter how little they contributed. We are a very military bases nation. But the ones from the World war are held in very high regard and labeled as the best generation of Americans ever existed. So for me it's Abit sad to hear other nations don't really do the same but I understand it's different for everyone

-4
Alarow•

Do you guys count your soliders in a different way ? Seems insane to me that you have that many left, almost all of them must be 100yo or older

10
Nitneroc2544•

I could be saying complete bs but can it have to do with the conscription age ? Seems like it was 20 in France and 16 in the US (idk if that’s correct, I just read it online…)

1
OURE14•

Young people don't know them/care about them because it was a long time ago. They are respected and seen during some ceremonial for ww2 but most of them are dead of really old. When i used to work in a ww2 museum i went to a ww2 ceremonial and saw some of them + british veterans (i live near omaha beach and all).

It's not that we don't care but past is past, veteran and resistant are honorable but ww2 has ended long time ago.

I had a grand uncle that was a resistant, he got caught by the nzi and executed at Caen prison during dday. Lot of resistants were executed that day at the prison and nzi bring the corpses with them and burrowed them at an unknown location till these days. here for more infos

5
Remarkable_Option660OP•

That's so sad

1
LucasThePatator•

You can't expect the general population to go out of their way to celebrate veterans from an 80yo war. Especially when the impact of the war was overwhelmingly on the civilian population. I don't know where you're from but I suspect you are from the U.S. There the only people who experienced the war were the veterans. Here in France the war is thought as a 6y occupation period by a genocidal power and that's the part that's remembered and memorialized the most. Including the resistance. The battle of France is not as important to us as the following period. We're talking not even a month in a 6y war.

4
Remarkable_Option660OP•

I can see that from your pov. But most people in the u.s who fought did not have a choice with a total of 400k deaths. Those who are informed well in ww2 in the U.S also hold the resistance In high regard. I just thought France would be more involved in remembering them considering how patriotic they can be. But I understand it isn't such a great time for France back then

0
Gordfang•

You must understand that WW2 was after WW1 and how brutal and horrible it was for France.

WW1 cost so much that entire generation of French people where lost on the battlefield (The so called lost generation), I don't think there is any village in France whitout a Death monument.

Everyone suffer greatly during this war and as such nobody speak about it, not the veteran who saw a place worst than hell nor the civilian who lost their close one. It was no different for WW2.

In France we don't idolize war because war left a lasting trauma over all our older generation. Everyone want to forget about it, even the veteran.

0
OURE14•

If you like history of WW2 there are a lot of infos on the internet about dday and other battles. There are crazy shit stories about like a calvary charge vs tanks, etc...

2
Remarkable_Option660OP•

Oh yeah I'm well informed on ww2 . I hear they have Dday events in Normandy

2
Pimko_•

Army often celebrates its veterans especially at anniversaries and when they pass away oc, but not that much by the people sadly...

5
Remarkable_Option660OP•

:(

1
HanhnaH•

Glad to answer this one.

I met several WW2 veterans in Normandy back in 1994. I was a teenager and was so happy to interview them. One of them even sent me a postcard and a Chicago Bulls t-shirt that I still have and shown recently to my kids recently.

We, as 1990s teenager, had a lot of respect for the US veterans. And I still have. It was a huge sacrifice and we were very thankfull.

My grand parents saw them contributing to Paris liberation.

In Normandy we have a large culture about WWII and the D Day, so I think it'a a place were American soldiers are still percieved as real heroes.

Edit: several typos

5
Remarkable_Option660OP•

This is so nice to read. I wish I was you. I met a Dday veteran 2 years ago. He fought on the beach and met General patton. I wish to visit Normandy soon. Tell me more

2
HanhnaH•

It was the 50th anniversary of D day so in Normandy it was a big thing. We talked about it a lot with our history teacher, English teacher and so on.

The veterans who were invited were very kind and seemed happy to see that we, young Frenchies, aknowledged their sacrifice and battles.

We also visited the Mémorial in Caen which is a large museum mainly dedicated to WW2 (but not only).

Nowadays I brought my kids to several different museum such as Airborne Museum.

Moreover my family counts jewish and resistants (some both) who died in the death camps and we know more of them would have been murdered wouldn't have America intervene. So... very thankful, yes!

I firmly believe that this is the last really great victory for the US Army.

And I'm sorry for bad grammar. I do try to improve my English but I don't practice enough.

3
Remarkable_Option660OP•

Your English is great do not worry, and I'm glad to hear that. I plan to visit Normandy soon and see first hand where it all happened. Such incredible history took place there. And I'm glad the people of Normandy have not forgotten. Thank you for sharing

1
UnstableEmpire•

The last French WW2 veteran died in 2021 :(

3
SirBaguette•

Non, c'est le dernier compagnon de la libération qui est mort (Hubert Germain), mais nous avons encore des résistants en vie : pour n'en citer qu'en d'entre eux, l'Amiral de Gaulle.

5
UnstableEmpire•

Au temps pour moi, J’ai été induit en erreur par ce site

2

No. Leon Gauthier turned 100 in October 2022. He is the last French survivor of the D-Day landings of June 6, 1944 and the last surviving member of the Kieffer Commandos. https://www.francebleu.fr/infos/societe/temoignage-leon-gautier-le-dernier-survivant-francais-du-debarquement-fete-ses-100-ans-1666259326

2
Remarkable_Option660OP•

Really???? We are losing ours too really fast. We have I think about 200,000 left or less

1
DudBreaK•

No, it was the last "Compagnion de la Libération" (Fellow Liberator)

1
Remarkable_Option660OP•

What's that?

1
n_abh•

It’s a title created during the war by De Gaulle to reward civilians and members of the military who took part in the liberation of France.

3
DudBreaK•

It was a decoration created by General De Gaulle to thank the people who participated in a significant way to the liberation of the country, about 1000 people received it

2
[deleted]•

Come in normandy in june you'll see

3
Remarkable_Option660OP•

What happens in June??

1

…6th June 1944? Also 18th of June is a very important date for France’s WW2 history

1
Remarkable_Option660OP•

Ah D-Day. We just call it D Day. Very cool

1

My grampa was one, he's a god for the whole family. There is a picture of him in uniform above the chimney, just below Jesus lmao. We're all very proud of his fight, even if he wasn't always a good person apart that.

I also know his oldest son received a reward in his memory from the mairie some years ago, at the occasion of some ceremony, or the anniversary of something, I forgot.

People are usually very interested into his story when I mention him. I've met one other WW2 veteran and several victims in my life and it was very interesting... and some of the most moving most moving moments of my life. Maybe my opinion is a little bit biased, but I think they're very respected by the whole society.

3
Remarkable_Option660OP•

It seems like the people of France , at least from what I tell from here is that they remember them but they aren't really regarded highly and see as just old people. But here in the U.S we hold the resistance to a high regard. Glad to hear this!

2
zelani06•

My great-grandfather was in the resistance. I never knew him, but he did survive the war, and I'm honestly very proud of that. It kind of is a flex for me. I like to think other people are impressed or something but mostly I think they don't care too much

2
Remarkable_Option660OP•

Well, at least you can say an American online is very impressed. Very cool to hear that man🤘

1

Both my grandparents were veterans, my grandma was a nurse on a hospital ship, and my grandpa was head of the local veterans union. I’ve been to a TON of events with them when I was younger, and so did my parents when they were children. According to them, being veterans also helped them a lot in their professional life and there was a real respect from the rest of the population. Ww2 veterans were very much celebrated and paid hommage to, but it’s just that they’ve simply passed of old age for the vast majority so it’s less visible as before… Like, if you were a 20yo soldier in 1939 when the war began you would be more than 100yo today…

2
Remarkable_Option660OP•

That's really cool to hear. Glad they got the respect that they deserve! And yeah I know unfortunately they are dying at really fast speeds. Last one I met was 102 and that was 2 years ago

1
LabriciussLocal•

Sadly most of them are dead, my grandpa was 15 when they bombed his school, he got jailed twice before turning 18 and almost got executed for his behaviour. No need to say that this is not a good recipe for a long life, he died in '06 or '07.

My grandma was a little kid when teh war started, one of her greatest memory is an english soldier (parachutiste) endind up in her family's garden that they had to hide for several days. she also died few years ago so not much to say about that either..

He wrote a little book while in prison, i used to read it from time to time but it is beyond heartbreaking.

​

Worst part is that these people were from another time and were often not that much respected cause of they take on today's world.

​

Anyway they still live in our memory and are honored every year for what they did.

​

Btw : OFC german people dont celebrate their W2 Veterans..

2
Remarkable_Option660OP•

Very interesting to read. And yes, of course the Germans do not. But considering how much they care for their dark history and their will to teach it heavily, I figured these people would be mentioned. But it seems they are not even acknowledged

1
Verlenn•

My mother used to take me to commemorative ceremonies to sing the national anthem. The veterans would come dressed in their dress uniforms to be thanked and give a speech.

​

But I'm from Normandy so the history of WW2 is very engrained. There are D-Day museums, memorials ...

2
Remarkable_Option660OP•

I will visit one day

1

Members of the resistance wich weren't many are still glorified and hailed as heroes.

The many that served during the occupation regime are most often not talked about. Or from time to time vilified.

The French troops that participated in D day and the liberation are not that numerous but viewed positively, as heroes and veterans that should be honoured.

But keep in mind that the respect and glorification of the veterans is very different in France that what it is the United States.

2
yeekko•

The feelings are a bit awkward since there was a lot of propaganda and a lot of shame about what happened during ww2,wich mean those people arent that well remembered since the majority of the population that would tell kids who they are and what they did well,don't really want them to know lol.

It's a decently common joke to say that you found your grandfather SS uniform so I think you get the idea.

They're no't shamed they're just...forgotten,since once again,ww2 and what came after brought a lot of shame to french people,between the majority that did nothing,those that sided with the nazis and those who collaborated to gain something out of it. And after the liberation with all the people that got beat,the girl that got their head shaved etc,everyone just wanted to forget about it,so we forgot about them

2
Remarkable_Option660OP•

Understandable! Don't worry, I'll still remember the resistance

1
littlecow888•

I worked for the french armed forces for a while and then wrote obituaries for local newspapers. I am also a big history fan. I was always a bit sad when I saw WWII veterans' obituaries. I once met american veterans on Omaha beach and it was an unforgettable experience for me.

But as you see most french people do not really care, and veterans from other french wars (Indochina, Algeria) are seen in a pretty bad light.

2
Remarkable_Option660OP•

That's depressing to hear but I'm glad you appreciate them. If you saw them on Omaha beach there's a big chance they fought on DDay! I met one guy who was on the beaches in that day. We are losing our American veterans at an alarming speed.

1
littlecow888•

Most people that do care/are proud of their country are seen in a pretty bad light nowadays there, as it is seen as a far-right trait.

1
Shiriru00•

I would say, exactly the same as WW1 vets (some were still around when I was a kid). FFLs and resistance are celebrated in ceremonies and the press on anniversaries, but you don't meet them often and they certainly don't wear it on their sleeve.

My grandfather fought at the beginning of the war, got captured by the Germans, was freed in 1944 then fought in the Ardennes and Germany with the FFL until the end of the war. He would never talk about it. Most veterans didn't. Lots of untreated PTSD I believe.

My grandma would only tell us about how sick he got in the prison camps. My other grandma told us about the streams of corpses she saw floating downriver for days in a row, after an American bombing in Normandy missed the mark and hit a busy market (to her credit, she was still a staunch pro-American after that). No heroic war stories to be had, just an altogether horrible time for everyone involved.

I think in America it's different, because it's the last major military engagement that was decisively won and it wasn't fought on the mainland, so it's easier to remember only the glory (although it also came at such a cost in blood). In Europe the memory of the war was much bleaker, so people would rather soon forget about it.

So the attitude is not "Wow, you fought in the war? We thank you for your service, you're a hero." and more "So you fought in the war? Damn, it sucks, I'm sorry for you.".

2
Remarkable_Option660OP•

This response was the most grounded I believe. Thank you for your detailed response. I now understand

2
MerbleuxxLocal•

They were already old when I was a kid.

1
Remarkable_Option660OP•

Now they are even older

1
MerbleuxxLocal•

Now they’re dead actually

1
Remarkable_Option660OP•

Really? All the french veterans are all dead?

1
MerbleuxxLocal•

Not all of them if I’m not wrong but for the vast majority haha.

Those in my family who fought in 1940 and/or joined the resistance died 40 years ago honestly.

1