r/qyldgang•
petataa

How to use Roth IRA tax break to my advantage

I have a portfolio split of 4 different funds with equal weights in DIVO, SCHD, JEPI, and VOO. I am wondering which funds would be most beneficial to own inside my Roth IRA and which funds would be fine in a normal brokerage account. My line of thinking was that since VOO will grow the largest, I should keep that in the Roth IRA so that my gains won't be taxed if I ever sell it all. Of course the other option is to put the higher dividend payers in the Roth IRA so I can save on taxes year in and year out. My only concern with this option is I don't want to have my income generation tied up in a Roth IRA if I want to withdraw prematurely.

Has anyone else ran the math on this and determined what's the smarter option?

Posted Apr 19, 2023, 9:02 PM UTC

95
drumsdm•

My thinking is you want your Roth as big as possible. Swell up the principle as much as you can with growth, and then as you near retirement, switch to income funds that are taxed as income or unqualified payments.

On the other side of the coin, the bogelhead type philosophy would say put the dividends in a Roth now. I guess this is technically a little more efficient, but again you can only put so much in a Roth, so choose wisely.

5
wolfhound1793•

It'll depend on your age and your goals. You want to max out your Roth IRA and if you are under 45 you want to maximize the growth elements of the funds in your Roth. This means DIVO, SCHD, and VOO are best in the Roth. If however you have less time until you start taking IRA withdraws, you want more dividends which starts to pivot more towards JEPI. IMO you should only hold JEPI wherever you are able to use the dividends to pay for current income needs. DIVO is in a nice spot where it provides good growth and decent dividends, though it is still probably best outside of a Roth unless you can draw dividends.

For me, my IRA is 50/50 SCHD and SPLG and I just leave it alone with DRIP on. Each Feb I dump the max allowed contribution based on income and buy more of whichever one is lower at the time.

3

In the Roth you have a hedge vs future tax increases. Trades with in the vehicle are not a taxable event. In this scenario its best to go for best overall historic return. Small cap value, SPX is the best bet. When ready for the income for retirement sell and buy income funds 👍

3
tazedandrefused•

I wouldn't hold qyld or similar products in my Roth because I anticipate capitalizing on accrued losses come retirement and can't do that if they're in my roth

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
DividendSeeker808•

..below is a good article to read on the topic of early withdrawal,

https://www.madfientist.com/how-to-access-retirement-funds-early/

sometimes just need to "bite the bullet" and pay the taxes, according to the article, if plan well, it should be doable,

Cheers!

1