What's the best stain for my deck in this climate?

Our deck is a bit of a mess. Lots of spots are down to the bare wood. Some spots have stain, and I think paint was used in some areas.

I'm planning on pressure washing it, sanding it, and putting a solid stain on it.

Any recommendations on what stain works best in this climate? I heard I should get an oil based one. Is that true?

Posted Apr 22, 2023, 8:53 PM UTC

312
Shakenbakess•

I have a water based out front and an oil based in back.

I would say do oil. The water base just chips away and you can't really just stain over it. I think with a little prep, restraining oil is easier, but happens more frequently.

Oil fades more in direct sunlight too.

But after watching my dad have to pressure wash and sand every two years for water stain I don't think I'd ever want to do that

6
PonyboyJake•

When I run out to the shed and see what I used on my southern exposure facing back deck, I'll tell you what NOT to use.

I pressure washed, scrubbed with a chemical cleaner, and belt sanded (to raise the wood fibres to soak up the paint), and it still didn't make it 2 years. Comes off in strips now and looks shit.

This time I'm just pressure washing it and going with a different product and see how it holds up. Can't turn out any worse than last time

4
Thelionmachinist•

Gotta do it every year my buddy. Unless you wanna shell out for pressure treated or composite. No way around it.

3
titanpitbull•

Any oil product, or get that plastic stuff. Name escapes me. Not my name the name of the product.

2
katesweets•

Following.. I’m in the same boat.. I’m southern exposure.. a lot of sun.. and a big deck… it’s a mess now and this summer I have to tackle it.. but no idea what to put on it that will be the least about of long term work…

1
Giveme1time•

You’ll have to re stain every year in our climate regardless. Especially a solid stain. Oil based is the best.

After sanding, spritz a light touch of water with a bottle or pump style sprayer, allow it to dry and then gently sand with the last grit you used (or higher) before then applying the stain. It’s called raising the grain or “water popping”. Helps adhesion and reduces raised grains after liquid contact

1
hamcakeOP•

Every year?! Ugh!

1
Giveme1time•

Unfortunately yes. How large of a deck? It’s not as painful as it seems, with a roller and long handle, and maybe $120 in stain?

Some years it may not deteriorate, but best case scenario, unless the deck is new and it’s prepped perfectly, and low foot traffic, it’ll last 2 years.

1
hamcakeOP•

Maybe 20x40 with lots of stairs and balusters. But I guess it's mostly the decking and stairs that will deteriorate the most.

1
BrianFromNLNewfoundlander :NL:•

Go with a semi-transparent penetrating stain. Oil is probably best for a longer life.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
hamcakeOP•

Thanks - do you know where I can find that brand?

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
AtlanticCanadians•

Don’t use a water-based sealant (like thompson’s water seal - it just gets tacky and wears off within a season or two). Your best bet is an oil-based stain with proper deck prep beforehand. Realistically, with our climate, you’re going to have to re-stain every few years anyways.

I’ve seen good results from Behr’s Deckover on quite a few decks, but it’s not cheap.

0