Should I use this plot twist, or play it straight?

DMing

Hey everybody.

First off, if any of the members of Astral Echo are reading this, fuck off, or I’m deleting all the loot in the next monster lair.

Have they gone? Good.

I’m running a session tonight that may or may not reach the next planned storyline, which will feature the party being hired as the personal security of locally famous traveling bard, who fears that they are being stalked.

Now, I’m of two minds about this plot. On one hand, I came up with a plot twist where the bard is actually a demon in disguise using the show to find attract victims for brutal murders, and the “stalker” is a demon hunter trying to stop them. Would likely feature the demon seducing a member of the party before trying to eat them. Recipe for mistaken identity into “Oh shit, we gotta save X from getting praying mantis’d!”You know the drill.

Alternatively, I could just play it straight and have the bard be a genuine well liked performer under real threat from some monstrous thing or other that is fixated on them for…I dunno, song magic reasons, I’ll improvise. Save the singer, slay the monster, optionally unironically do the “my hero!” thing and fade to black if it seems like somebody’d be into that. Classic damsel in distress routine.

My main concerns/some context:

A) It’s early in the campaign/characters’ career, and I don’t want to set the tone of all future NPC romantic advances with “make sure they’re not secretly plotting your murder.”

B) As stated, since its early, I’m trying to build up a catalog of “classic” memories for the party to share to make them feel like storied heroes who’ve done all the shit you’d expect of adventures: raid some ruins, fight some big monsters, save some innocents, have a few romantic flings. This would either be “remember that time X slept with a demon? It was ONE TIME!” or “remember that popstar we saved? Oh yeah, they still send us concert tickets.”

C) I’m not sure feel which approach, if either, would feel too “tired.” Both Damsel in Distress and Honeypot Demon Seduction have been done, but is there one that would feel particularly boring or unsatisfying?

So. Thoughts?

View Poll

Posted Apr 28, 2023, 8:12 PM UTC

016
TimothyOfTheWoods•

The problem with plot twists and betrayals early on is that your players may latch on to them and expect every single NPC to betray them. It's actually a pretty common problem for Dms to have conditioned their players to suspect tricks then get upset when the players act in the way they've been trained to.

8
itsfunhavingfun•

¿Porque no Los dos?

Demon kidnaps bard and disguises as bard to attract victims. Keeps bard around because demon can’t play/sing like the bard.

Real bard had hired the party because of stalker (who really is the demon). Demon keeps the party on and tricks them into thinking the demon Hunter is the stalker.

Party can still figure out what is going on, sleep with the demon, save the pop star, befriend the demon Hunter. Or it could all go tits up and they’ll still have great stories to tell.

4
PhoenixAgent003OPThief•

You genius.

3
itsfunhavingfun•

I gotta warn you, it’s probably going to go tits up.

3
C47manDM•

I like this one

2
itsfunhavingfun•

I think I saw it on Scooby Doo.

1
QaptainHammer•

Does it have to be a demon? Make it a fey creature that does harm people, just not permanently or something a little bit lighter than demon killing innocents. Make the monster hunter also equally morally dubious. A more chaotic ending could be achieved this way and you might be surprised at the end. My general advice: when in doubt, make everyone else doubt everything too.

Edit: Also, if you don't make a habit of these twists, it wouldn't make a pattern.

3
darkpower467DM•

Early NPC betrayals are a good way to make your party very hesitant to trust. Early into a campaign, I'd lean more toward having the party's allies and employers be genuine.

2
Mad_Dauwg•

If you have the time, prepare them both. In the beginning your would maybe suspect the plot twist, so you go for the straight option. If they don't suspect anything, all you have to do is pick the plot twist....

1
No_Log8932•

Or the stalker could be like the dude who shot John Lennon. A crazy fan stalker.

1
C47manDM•

Bard is a demon. The stalker is a demon hunter. But the demon feeds off adulation and causes no harm. They are an outcast because they are nonviolent and actually likes people. The demon hunter is a rigid minded person who can't allow for nuance, and wants to kill the demon simply because of their "evil blood" or something. Give the party a choice of who to side with.

1
Stoneathan•

Love both ideas but would keep the twist saved away for a later date. You are right it would make for an incredible story. However, too early in the game and you will have the players questioning everything which is what I think you are trying to avoid here. That said I would definitely modify the twist a little and use it later as that will give them a story to tell for years to come.

1
Snekfroggo•

I like the plot twist, but I would skip the seduction betrayal in favor of dropping hints from the start that something is off about the bard - so it's less of a surprise but more of a fun mystery. It might reduce the risk of conditioning your players to doubt every future genuine interest from an NPC.

1
Illustrious-Leader•

Keep the plot twist, but do they have to find out now?

The party thwarts the demon hunter, who is ranting like a madman. The Bard is grateful and recommends them to others / rehires them, getting them work. Lay some hints, which the bard dismisses by saying he's actually tiefling but has hidden it because of the stigma.

In effect, he becomes their patron and reveals his true self much later.

1
Asmos159•

if it is early in the campaign, play it straight. that way your players are expecting straight when they is a plot twist.

1
No-Suggest1on•

Curve ball, make the PC's think there's gonna be lots of plot twist and give them none, then when they least expect it... BAM

1