Escalante 2 replacement

Question

This post is by this juncture very out of date, but I'm of the "hoard a few of a favorite shoe" persuasion.

I loved the Escalante 1 and 2s. I didn't get a pair of the 2.5s because I didn't like them as much. Now I'm regretting that because the 3s are criminally bad and my last pair of 2s are hundreds of miles past the replacement point and maybe doing some damage.

I used to run in Five Fingers and, though I loved them when I was younger, I've found I need to move into something ever so slightly less minimal without compromising on the minimal benefits too much. I'm looking for something flexible, low profile, and with plenty of room for toe splay. It seems like Altra customer service is pushing the racers as replacements, but looking at them on the website, it doesn't at all look like they kept the same sole shape. Any experience with the Racers or recommendations for alternate shoes? I've heard not great things about Altra customer service/online purchase return process, and the Racers aren't in stock at any of the usual places I trust so I'm loathe to shell out the money on an unknown product from a company I trust less and less with every model.

Posted Apr 28, 2023, 9:58 PM UTC

520
guilmon999•

I haven't been able to find a replacement. Newer Altras just fit weird (for a company that prides themselves in making wide shoes the midfoot of ALL of their newer shoes are narrow as hell). I tried their torin wide model recently and the midfoot was so narrow that the ball of my foot was hanging over the edge of the sole

I've heard good things about the escalante racer (but like you mentioned I also have my doubts). I think they have free returns so you can order them and send them back if they suck.

Edit: You could try Lems. Their primal 2 and primal zen models are fairly cushioned compared to your vibram 5 fingers.

3
StrungStringBeansOP•

Thanks! I'm looking at the Lems now, and I'm intrigued. It looks like there's a dealer not too far from me so I'll go check them out soon.

I'm still so bummed that they redesigned their shoes. It's so hard to find the perfect running shoe and I was stoked when I found the Altras. It'd be nice if companies wouldn't entirely abandon their designs every couple years--it'sa not like shoe tech changed that quickly--but here we are.

Good luck with finding your dream replacement!

2

What size shoe are you? I have an unused pair of the 1.5 and an unused pair of the 2.5, which I'd gladly send you free of charge, but I fear that my biggish feet would be an obstacle. They're size 13 US. I'd love someone to get some use out of them. I was a massive fan of the Escalante, which is why I bought these. But I then tore my plantar fascia, and during my rehabilitation, I transitioned to shoes with more cushion and a higher drop. 4mm is the absolute lowest drop I can handle these days, and most of my shoes now are 8mm. I can't see myself ever being comfortable in Altras again. They've sat in their boxes for several years now (can't remember when I bought them, but it was definitely pre-Covid).

2
StrungStringBeansOP•

That's such a generous offer! Thanks so much! Unfortunately, my feet are a bit smaller than yours so I can't take you up on it. I hope you're able to find a happy home for them! I know there are a ton of Altra "refugees" out there, and hopefully you'll find one with a similarly sized foot.

I hope your recovery is going well!

1

A pity! But I'm not surprised. Law of averages made it unlikely that it'd be an exact match. One of these days, I should offer them on a general post here, I guess. I definitely don't want them to go to waste and I know how frustrating it is when these manufacturers butcher their models like this. Good luck on your quest for the right shoe!

2
Bernie_s_Mittens•

Maybe Topo? I always hear that they are similar to old school Altra. I just ordered a close-out model from Sierra but I can’t vouch for them yet.

3
ceylonblue•

Have you considered the Superiors? 21mm stack, flexible. It’s marketed as a trail shoe but works fine on both for me. Not as wide as the early Altras, but none of them are anymore.

The Racers are a bit higher, firm, less flexible. I like them, but doesn’t sound like what you’re looking for.

2
runner204431•

Lone peaks are still in the original foot shape, just fyi.

2
ceylonblue•

Lone Peak 7 is narrower than Lone Peak 5/6, even though it’s marketed as Original Footshape. The earlier models (4 and earlier) were even wider. What Altra now calls Original Footshape is the widest of the current lineup, but it isn’t literally their original footshape 🙃

2
runner204431•

Gotta disagree with you there. Narrower in the heel yes, but personally I prefer my heel locked in. The 6 I found to be quite loose in the mid foot, had to really cinch down the upper. I feel little to no difference in the forefoot between models. The 7 has changed in other ways somewhat significantly (the bumper and the stiffener around the heel) but I love it. I’d say the 5 and 6 were probably the worst, but still good. On the 7 I feel locked in (no sliding around inside), with plenty of room to splay, good traction and great ground feel. Best yet.

1
StrungStringBeansOP•

Thanks for this; it confirms my fears vis-a-vis the Racers. But I'll give the Superiors a go. They seem to be on sale at REI at the moment, so it's a good chance to try. I wish Altra would keep at least a few models in the old style, but I guess they have no interest in that.

2
runner204431•

Interesting- in the store I’m involved with the Escalante 3 is extremely popular. Top three for sales. I quite like them myself.

2
StrungStringBeansOP•

At first I was suprised to hear this, but upon further reflection, my sense is that they're going for mass market appeal. The original Altras serve a pretty niche market, and my sense is that a lot of people found the massive toe box to look a bit doofy from an aesthetic perspective. I can understand the desire for a wider market, but I wish they'd left some of the original products in tact too.

2
runner204431•

Maybe, I’ve run in Altras for over a decade and I still like the escalante 3.

I really like the lone peak 7 though, it’s probably the shoe the remains most loyal to the original idea. Not a road shoe but whatever.

2
kk126•

You might try Kinvara 13. Toe box isn’t Altra big but it’s big enough for me (I also need toe splay). 4mm, very flexible, low profile. Note: NOT the latest Kinvara with the big stack midsole.

I tried Topo a few years back and didn’t love it, but have heard good things about the current lineup. Some are zero drop, others low but not zero.

I also had some Skechers a few years back I liked a lot. Similarly, have heard good things about the current performance line. At least one 4mm, minimal option. Speed, I believe it’s called.

And I’ve been curious about Atreyu as a no frills low profile shoe, but haven’t yet tried them.

I never did five fingers, but ran in merrells and then altras. Loved the solstice as a minimalist option. Had the og rivera but that’s a bulkier shoe than escalante.

2
StrungStringBeansOP•

Thanks for this! I'm really looking for zero drop (which I totally overlooked in the original post). But I'll give the Topos and Atreyus a shot. The Atreyus particularly have a really nice aesthetic, which isn't something I usually care about but is a nice bonus. I'm also shocked about the Sketchers; I still think of them as shoes for 1990s teens.

I wore Merrells as an early transitional shoe. They made some weird changes, but ultimately I needed to transition to a bit more shock absorption around my mid-30s. My feet demanded it, which was honestly too bad because my knees and hips love the super minimal.

2
kk126•

I hear you on all fronts :)

I’m slowly giving up the zero drop search in favor of rockered soles that seem to work better for toe pain I sometimes get. Between that and Altra messing with their lasts, it’s harder and harder to find a zero drop that works for me.

2

You can still buy the Escalate 2 online very easy 🤷‍♂️

2
StrungStringBeansOP•

You can still buy the Escalate 2 online very easy 🤷‍♂️

New? And in standard sizes? Where are you finding them? I looked around and found only size 5s or pre-worn, which I'm not okay with for a running shoe specifically.

I have to confess, I'm not a running shoe geek; I'm here because I sought the knowledge of aforementioned geeks. And so far, that's been super successful (thanks everyone!).

1
davebrose•

Nothing similar. Sorry

1
Star_Allele•

I agree - the 3's are criminally bad. I don't have a replacement shoe yet, I thought the 2.5's were okay....I'm on my last pair. I tried Torins which are awful too cushy and have a back heal that travels up my leg in an awful sort of way. I tried some Topos but they have some weird arch support in the most awkward place...I have stockpiled an obscene amount of superior 5s before Altra ruins those too...but I prefer those for trail, not road.

1