r/Seahawks•
FtpApoc

Zach Charbonnet Player comparisons?

Discussion

Id love to hear who Charbonnet reminds them of.

To be clear I dont think he's NEARLY as good as my comparison, this is not what i expect him to do statistics wise

but every time i see him, its like looking at a regen of his style.

for me, it has to be Adrian Peterson. he looks like he's re-using animations, and just his approach to game, his build, how and when he wants a cut or contact.

looking forward to seeing what he can do, and what anybody else thinks about his style.

here's some senior highlights if you haven't had a chance to see him run

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AcBoK-ydc9I

Posted Apr 30, 2023, 4:02 AM UTC · edited

1345
kleenkong•

Shaun Alexander near the endzone.

23
Sylli17•

Shaun actually is a really good comp. Stylistically... Pretty similar. Shuan was a few inches shorter so he had a bit lower center of gravity but was still a similarly upright runner like Charbs. Both very strong but not especially violent. Both have good body control. Similar speed. Similar quickness and agility. Both very good at getting defenders off balance and not able to make direct contact. They'd each expend a lot of energy, make a lot of movements to achieve a comparatively small juke goal haha. But then keep going like the energizer bunny. Both are high steppers. Like the comp actually.

10
FtpApocOP•

shaun alexander... now thats a unique style.

he looked like his upper body was perfectly still and his legs would be leaning so far to the left or right you'd think he'd be falling over, so smoothly switching from one to the other it looked like skiing.

8
kleenkong•

Ya, Shaun had some good lateral movement while running near full speed. Zach looks quicker but Shaun was faster.

7
Underpantz_Ninja•

This is exactly what I see when I look at ZC's tape.

He has that identical change of direction wiggle that SA had when running full speed downhill that caused defenders to hit him at bad angles that kept SA upright.

Since SA left I've never really seen an RB in the entire league who had that same skillset as SA; Kamera was close and so was Marshawn, but ML made way more people miss than SA ever did and would bowl dudes over anyway.

SA was like silk in how upright he ran and how hard it was to wrap him up.

3
MrMooc•

Demarco Murray

17
FtpApocOP•

great comparison. those break down cuts, handles and exploits contact all the way, very steady but fluid approach to running the football

im gonna be cheeky and say Murray was also inspired or interested by Peterson, at least in part, but I think Murray is easily the best comparison in this discussion

4
mickey_kneecaps•

Might seem lazy since he’s a Seahawk, but he reminds me of Chris Carson. Kind of upright but very strong, thick legs, can push through contact.

9
Sylli17•

Carson was violent. Charbonnet is strong but not violent.

9
PayAltruistic8546•

He is very violent...He's smoother but dude is constantly rolling forward or running people over.

4
Sylli17•

Not like Carson. There is a distinct difference. Carson was attacking guys. Charbs is actively trying to not get tackled. Carson was trying to destroy the guy in front of him. Carson looked to maximize contact and win by being the more powerful force. Charbonnet tries to minimize contact so he can use his strength to break weaker tackle attempts. What Charbonnet does is smarter. What Carson did was more fun... If you're the "run through a MFers face" type of fan.

Just watch Charbonnet then watch Carson. How often do guys get a solid, dead on, squared up tackle hit on Charbonnet vs how often do they do that to Carson? That's your difference. Carson invites guys to square up. Charbonnet doesn't let defenders do that.

7

Good synopsis. Carson was Beastmode 2.0 really. Hit people enough times they start to dread trying to tackle you as they game goes on.

5
PayAltruistic8546•

Well yeah...not many RBs are violent and reckless like Lynch and Carson.

1
FtpApocOP•

yes he is a very similar profile. he looks for a cut a little bit more, but in 3rd and anything less than 5 i think they are very very similar

1

2 minute drill is a great YouTube channel that gives a 2 minute synopsis of a draft prospect and an NFL comp. They compared him to Royce Freeman

6
FtpApocOP•

thanks for the channel info, you trust their research? i assume yes but i always like to know how much stake to give someone else's view

any which way, I've got some catchup to do

2

They’re fairly new, but I’m not sure how much you can trust anyone’s content, considering even the best NFL GM get things wrong.

But I like their format. 2 minutes per player, highlights, lowlights, and NFL comp is about how much effort I’m willing to put in during draft season. So I’ll roll with it.

2
FtpApocOP•

I was very impressed with his content, thank you for the recommendation

1
ElbisCochuelo1•

Chris Carson.

5
beatzwellington•

He's like a power Austin Ekeler

5
FtpApocOP•

ekeler loves his parallel jump cut, but he definitely does have that diagonal that is exactly one of those staple 'animation' moves of peterson and the like, so i see the comparison

however their builds are, for me, very different as well as the approach to the carry, ekeler will avoid all contact including re-direction until he makes 1 big contact and end his rush, whereas charbonnet looks to maintain a low to medium level of contact all the way through the wash and then turn the jets on, which part of his game i also think looks a good amount like ekelers

1

His injuries derailed him massively, but I think Jay Ajayi is a good comp. Big bruiser, can break tackles, quick but not fast, good feet. If Charbonnet can hold up and avoid big hits better (He actually seemed good on tape in avoiding DBs and LBs who tried to use the hit stick on him), he could be Ajayi if he met his potential.

I seem to remember injuries being a concern for Ajayi, largely because he tried to truck everyone on every play. He also had 100 more carries in college than Charbonnet, despite playing one fewer season.

3
FtpApocOP•

i was just linked a video where he was compared to royce freeman, the denver back.

​

he also had an injury problem. seems to be an obvious problem with these big power back bruisers. here's hoping that smart instinct to pick his battles can preserve his health to and well beyond his tenure with the hawks

1

There are many powerful backs who have long careers. Lynch, AD, Dickerson, Henry, Gore. They just have to be smart about how they use their bodies.

1
Stevo2008:sea1:​•

Alstott had a long career too if I recall.

2
danthebiker1981•

In our system he will maybe be out there 30-40 percent of the time as long as Walker stays healthy. That should be good for him. With the addition of JSN too I think we will see less heavy boxes to run against a good portion of the time.

1
Tacoma25Tree•

He looks like Arian Foster to me, not as smooth but more rugged

2
Sylli17•

Pass catching James Conner.

1†
FtpApocOP•

i think thats quite a good comparison. for me the biggest difference is how aggressively corner moves laterally, as opposed to charbonnets less dramatic and therefore probably less useful but more fluid lateral movements.

i think the rest of his game is really similar, but there was some change in fluidity and aggressiveness and im not sure what it is, but i think its how much energy is put into the lateral aspect of his cuts and how that affects his downhill running and power in good and bad ways

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
JackIbach•

Was not good enough to start at Michigan before transferring to UCLA?

1
TooMuchWood90•

“Old School” Comparison

Deuce McAllister

  • Great size

  • runs with urgency. They don’t have a lot of wasted movement. They know where they want to go and they attack

  • contact balance is tremendous

  • good but not great long speed

  • better receivers than you might expect for guys who someone will lump in as “power backs”

Other comparisons I thought of: MJD’s running mate Fred Taylor (not my favorite comp - Taylor was faster with a little more wiggle. Both aggressive one cut guys), Frank Gore, Fred Jackson

1
JaeTheOne•

Chris Carson

1
mekkaniks•

Arian Foster for me. North South runner with the ability to make people miss. Tough runner too

1
Grunge206•

Maurice Jones-Drew.

0†
FtpApocOP•

man Jones-Drew was such a strange player, looked like was absolutely floating until he made contact with somebody and then it looked like he had granite blocks keeping him rooted upright.

in a strange way he seems almost lighter AND heavier than charbonnet, but he was just such a weird player to watch idek what was going on with him

2
Sylli17•

MJD was a short guy and ran like it. Duece Vaughn is closer to MJD than Charbs, although MJD was a bit more stout. MJD tried to get low and power into the gut of tacklers to get them off balance and duck the tackle. Charbs tries to use his body control to get guys to make indirect contact, and slide through arm tackles. Charbs uses great upper body strength to get through tackles. Very, very different style.

1
Mawfk•

Marshawn Lynch. Runs similar but a little more upright. Near impossible to bring down sometime. Wears the same number. I'm not saying he's going to be Beast Mode but he's as close as I've seen a prospect

-2†
Sylli17•

He absolutely doesn't run like Shawn. He's an upright runner. Shawn gets very, very low. Shawn is much more powerful. Charbs is good through arm tackles. But it's because he has great strength in the upper half. Lynch was a low, wide base with powerful legs.

4
FtpApocOP•

i hadnt thought of it that way*, unless you mean very early Marshawn, like college and the start of his buffalo stint. after that i think he became much much more contact aggressive, and sure he did use the juke and so on, his power, over his agility, speed or technique was his bread and butter which i dont think is the same profile of charbonnet.

but hey, if they were similar in college you could very well be right and maybe he will end up going that way, but he loves the redirection style juke and stiff arm rather than just using it to set up the whole 'run through a mf face' thing Marshawn rolled with

1
Mawfk•

Hey I said he isn't Beast Mode just reminds me of him. Watch his tape and tell me he doesn't run in a similar fashion. High knees, contact balance, power through contact, etc. Yes he is different because player comps are stupid. No one is the same. Just reminds me of Marshawn is all

1
FtpApocOP•

jeez man, i said i think you could be right, and i still do.

im sorry that i sounded like i negated your opinion, i was saying what i thought about the comparison in terms of my thoughts of his style. i didn't think you were saying they are the same player or anything like that.

like you say there are aspects that are similar, especially your listed points, i think my question in itself was framed badly for not asking for the closest fit, rather than general similarities to players.

2
Mawfk•

Player comps are dumb in general Imo. No two people are the same. Just watch the tape and look at his play style. He is a scary playmaker and no one in this class has the same same height, weight, big play potential, and receiving for his size (bijan included). I think we got a fuckin steal with Charbonnet and I couldn't be more excited

2
riedmae•

Since I don't know if the response before me are legit or cheeky, I'm gonna say Barry Sanders. You can tell by the way he is.

-3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-6