Do you mind people playing existing characters from fiction?
I really didn’t feel like making a brand new character for a new campaign I’m in, and I cleared this with the DM (she was all for it), so I rolled up a skeleton Bard, with a background in sailing and a penchant for panties.
So far it’s been nice to not have to invent a character, and just have fun as an existing person I know. Especially with the plethora of spells and abilities that make it very easy to make him in game.
Does this bother you guys when players do it? Or just roll with it?
Posted May 1, 2023, 7:22 AM UTC
inspired by is where i draw the line. i still expect players to live in the reality of the world we are building
Same.
Many characters only work in the context of the settings they exist in.
If I had a player who wanted to play Kelsier from Mistborn, it'd be near impossible because he exists in a low-magic setting and is a freedom fighter who resists an empire that controls the whole known world.
In a high magic setting without such an empire, that radically changes multiple aspects of the character.
Would I let someone play a chaotic freedom fighter, magic user and thief who survived and escaped from a prison that's supposed to be inescapable, who wants to tear down a corrupt and powerful institution that practices slave labor, and who is a charming rogue who puts the confidence in confidence man? Absolutely. I love those aspects in Kelsier, and the prospect of someone bringing those qualities to my table is exciting.
Hell, I've built some fun characters off of existing archetypes. But there's always a point of divergence. What if I played Trevor Belmont as he is in the first season of Castlevania, but he learned his family actually were frauds? Now that could be the start of a really cool character arc. Or sometimes it's just as simple as "I want to play a Persona 5/Arsene Lupin style gentleman thief and see where that takes me."
But I think that's always where I'd stop and if you just roll up to my table wanting to just play Kelsier or Lupin, then I'm gonna say no. Make your own character, even if you just put enough effort into it to make the character a little distinct.
This is the way.
I've played with people who used NFL and boxing athletes names and personas (Mike Tyson - barbarian) SF and anime characters. It was a fun group, but I personally never did that and found it a little jarring to have Arcadia Darell (from Asimov's Foundation) using a vibrio blade and blaster pistol next to my cavalier.
Either be setting specific or at least have a conversation about how this campaign is going to bend, blur, or break the boundaries.
And if the DM is creating a setting with that cast of dozens, hundreds or more, isn't it the least a player can do to create one unique character?
That's my other thing.
I GM more than I play these days. Not specifically in Pathfinder, but in multiple systems.
I'm constantly creating new characters, monsters, conflicts and secrets. And that's part of GMing. I know that. It's part of the social contract of these games. If I want that kind of agency over the game me and my friends are playing, I need to put in the work to earn that agency.
However, I feel that part of that social contract is that where players are called upon to put in some work and creativity, than they owe it to the effort I've put in to not half-ass it and just say "I'm just going to play a character from my favorite anime." I don't ask you to have a full backstory before the first session, but I want you to actually put in enough effort to create something.
That and you just playing someone else's character puts more work in for me, as I have to bend the world around it to a degree.
That's just the tip of the iceberg. Even if the setting matches, there are numerous problems of mechanics, which spells, equipment, etc the character has. And to finish off there's the issue of novel/movie heroes usually not being a part of a team, but a loner type, a problem that whole books can be written about... 🤪
Lol do you not know Kelsier is from Fortnite ^^^^^^/s
Even in jest, this hurts my soul.
It was hard to even type
Inspiration is such a good starting point. In the 2e campaign I’m playing in my fighter started as inspired by the Onion Knights from Dark Souls. However, over the course of our campaign he’s changed and grown because of the events our party has gone through. Been my favorite character to play so far.
right my current character is a take on stingy Jack the guy who the headless horseman is based on. im having a lot of fun