Do you mind people playing existing characters from fiction?

2E Player

I really didn’t feel like making a brand new character for a new campaign I’m in, and I cleared this with the DM (she was all for it), so I rolled up a skeleton Bard, with a background in sailing and a penchant for panties.

So far it’s been nice to not have to invent a character, and just have fun as an existing person I know. Especially with the plethora of spells and abilities that make it very easy to make him in game.

Does this bother you guys when players do it? Or just roll with it?

Posted May 1, 2023, 7:22 AM UTC

2887
mrsnowplow•

inspired by is where i draw the line. i still expect players to live in the reality of the world we are building

61
CaughttheDarkness•

Same.

Many characters only work in the context of the settings they exist in.

If I had a player who wanted to play Kelsier from Mistborn, it'd be near impossible because he exists in a low-magic setting and is a freedom fighter who resists an empire that controls the whole known world.

In a high magic setting without such an empire, that radically changes multiple aspects of the character.

Would I let someone play a chaotic freedom fighter, magic user and thief who survived and escaped from a prison that's supposed to be inescapable, who wants to tear down a corrupt and powerful institution that practices slave labor, and who is a charming rogue who puts the confidence in confidence man? Absolutely. I love those aspects in Kelsier, and the prospect of someone bringing those qualities to my table is exciting.

Hell, I've built some fun characters off of existing archetypes. But there's always a point of divergence. What if I played Trevor Belmont as he is in the first season of Castlevania, but he learned his family actually were frauds? Now that could be the start of a really cool character arc. Or sometimes it's just as simple as "I want to play a Persona 5/Arsene Lupin style gentleman thief and see where that takes me."

But I think that's always where I'd stop and if you just roll up to my table wanting to just play Kelsier or Lupin, then I'm gonna say no. Make your own character, even if you just put enough effort into it to make the character a little distinct.

15
Cytwytever•

This is the way.

I've played with people who used NFL and boxing athletes names and personas (Mike Tyson - barbarian) SF and anime characters. It was a fun group, but I personally never did that and found it a little jarring to have Arcadia Darell (from Asimov's Foundation) using a vibrio blade and blaster pistol next to my cavalier.

Either be setting specific or at least have a conversation about how this campaign is going to bend, blur, or break the boundaries.

And if the DM is creating a setting with that cast of dozens, hundreds or more, isn't it the least a player can do to create one unique character?

2
CaughttheDarkness•

That's my other thing.

I GM more than I play these days. Not specifically in Pathfinder, but in multiple systems.

I'm constantly creating new characters, monsters, conflicts and secrets. And that's part of GMing. I know that. It's part of the social contract of these games. If I want that kind of agency over the game me and my friends are playing, I need to put in the work to earn that agency.

However, I feel that part of that social contract is that where players are called upon to put in some work and creativity, than they owe it to the effort I've put in to not half-ass it and just say "I'm just going to play a character from my favorite anime." I don't ask you to have a full backstory before the first session, but I want you to actually put in enough effort to create something.

That and you just playing someone else's character puts more work in for me, as I have to bend the world around it to a degree.

2
CyberKiller40•

That's just the tip of the iceberg. Even if the setting matches, there are numerous problems of mechanics, which spells, equipment, etc the character has. And to finish off there's the issue of novel/movie heroes usually not being a part of a team, but a loner type, a problem that whole books can be written about... 🤪

2
Zenith2017the 'other' Zenith•

Lol do you not know Kelsier is from Fortnite ^^^^^^/s

-1
CaughttheDarkness•

Even in jest, this hurts my soul.

4
Zenith2017the 'other' Zenith•

It was hard to even type

2
frolicking_hippies•

Inspiration is such a good starting point. In the 2e campaign I’m playing in my fighter started as inspired by the Onion Knights from Dark Souls. However, over the course of our campaign he’s changed and grown because of the events our party has gone through. Been my favorite character to play so far.

1
mrsnowplow•

right my current character is a take on stingy Jack the guy who the headless horseman is based on. im having a lot of fun

1

So long as they realize it's not actually that character and just an homage, and it still fits in the game, sure. Honestly, there's so little pop culture I'm exposed to, I probably wouldn't know unless you told me.

I have no idea who the character you describe here is supposed to be, for instance.

50
Fauchard1520•

Some of my most successful characters have been based on Taxi era Danny DeVito, Futurama‘s Zapp Brannigan, or Dr. Orpheus from The Venture Bros. These are not subtle characters. They are selfish, or arrogant, or melodramatic. But even though they started out based on stock characters, they grew and changed through the course of play. I’m not a professional actor, and I’m certainly not good enough to nail a perfect DeVito impression for hundreds of hours worth of play. But these characters became their own thing over time, and relying on the DeVito template as a start was vital to its success. My fellow players were able to understand who I was and what I was trying to convey immediately. Strong relationships and a satisfying campaign followed.

Like u/Downtown-Command-295 says thought, there's a world of difference between "ripoff" and "homage."

15
JD-Vaan•

Gotta say this is one of the best explanations for how ot works I've read in a while. Kudos, mate!

2
Ragnar_the_gay•

Brook from one piece is the peak of all skeletons in fiction

8
FlurryOfNos•

Second

2
madsjchic•

Same. I do not know of any panty stealing skeletons.

2
CaughttheDarkness•

And if I did, I would stay far, far away from them.

5
corsair1617•

It's from One Piece.

2
Hollence•

I don't mind players taking heavy inspiration from existing characters, as long as they don't force it too hard or make a meme of it. The key is that it's just inspiration, not an actual reproduction. The name and story must be different.

That said, if you have trouble coming up with stuff and want to use an existing character, I'd suggest using multiple characters as inspiration instead of just one. If you mash up 2 or 3, then even if the aspects you take are exactly a copy from the source material, you still get a new creation. An example of the top of my head would be like Batman's background and skills, but with Spiderman's personality and Aragon's aesthetic.

24
Orenjevellost Immersive Sim enthusiast•

It ruins my immersion longterm, personally. If its not a one-shot or a super short adventure, it's grounds for me dipping. I'm not saying its BAD to do or anything, just doesn't end up working out for me.

24
CaughttheDarkness•

I absolutely would not allow this. The fiction matters a lot to me and knowing that someone's just imported a character from someone else's story into my world would really bug me. Taking inspiration is fine, even a lot of inspiration, but at the end of the day, I'm building something new for you as a GM, and having someone else's creation in it would hamper me creatively and would end up frustrating me on a narrative level.

It would also limit my ability to be creative with your story. If you want to just play Edward Elric, than I can't fuck around with your backstory, the people related to it, or anything like that too much because that's already set in stone. There are already expectations related to it. And depending on where that's coming from, it would make it even harder since we'd have to bend the rules of the world or the character to accommodate. If someone wanted to play Kelsier from Mistborn in a high-magic Pathfinder game, than that instantly undermines a really important aspect of the character - that he's a really powerful person in a low-magic world. You also separate him from the context that shaped him. In a setting that doesn't have the Final Empire, does it make sense to have someone who is the brand of freedom fighter he is?

Since narrative is one of the most important things to me in running the game, I could imagine this doing a lot of really negative things to my ability to do that and almost nothing positive.

21
Cytwytever•

This is the kind of respect that I agree should be brought to the table. I bet you run a great game, friendly redditor.

1
CaughttheDarkness•

Awww, thank you!

1
AeonReign•

It's fine to not allow it, but your reasoning is extremely..... Odd. There's nothing about pre existing characters that stops you from fucking with any aspect you normally would as a GM. Even if the character is supposed to be a carbon copy, it's still a copy that exists in your world to be interacted with.

Powers not fitting makes perfect sense as a reason though, and many of the other reasons given in this thread are fine, I just don't think there's a real argument that it stifles your creativity as a GM.

1
CaughttheDarkness•

For me, it's that the character ceases to be that character if you muck around too much. So therefore, if a player does this and I ok it, the way to respect their vision is to allow them to just copy/paste the backstory and for me to present it intact with no alterations or secrets or twists for them to discover. And I'd be doing that for practically every other character. And then if the character straight up doesn't fit in the world tonally, I kind of have to bend around that without breaking my setting or the character.

Plus, I feel like if I'm going to put in the effort of running a full campaign, it's not unreasonable to ask them to make their own original character.

1
AeonReign•

It's not an unreasonable ask, but I really think you're over estimating the damage of just rolling with it here. Also, I'm assuming good intentions from a player; an intentionally bad player can absolutely fuck this up.

Let's go with Captain America, just as a quick (and imperfect) comparison. There's nothing stopping you (or marvel) from suddenly revealing that Howard Stark is alive, driven mad by contact with a great old one, and working to modify the genome of the next generation to turn their minds fundamentally to the worship of the elder gods and bring Cthulhu and the apocalypse. Just need to figure out why he's alive. Extremely common type of plot in superhero stuff, and you never touch the literal backstory of the character as it's already written.

Now obviously the details will vary with world, character, and how you've made them fit together, but I'm really not seeing how this can cramp your creativity any more than a player writing a deep backstory for their own character normally.

0
CaughttheDarkness•

I'm assuming the same, but with a pre-created character, there's a lot of base assumptions that go into things and less freedom. Howard Stark still has to exist in this world in which he might not belong. His intentions and motivations need to be at least relatively close to what they were in the source material (Which is worse when adapting a Marvel into my setting because there's eleventy billion different versions of Howard Stark and me and my player may not be on the same page as to which one they want). I have to incorporate him into a world where there is no equivalent of SHIELD, where superheroes in general may not exist, and hell, if I get spicy enough, where WWII may never have even happened and the US collapsed as a result of the Civil War (Interesting idea noted, exploring possible campaign setting).

And yes, there is some variation of this with any PC. If a PC wants their mom to be a badass warrior from an order of noble knights who disappeared mysteriously on a quest, that's a character someone else has willed into my setting. But in that case, I am collaborating with the player to create these people, and it doesn't necessarily need to be all laid out at the very beginning. We can build as we go. Not so with an import character. If my player is Captain America, some variation on "Howard Stark gave a plucky patriot a super soldier serum to win WWII" must be the beginning. Some variation of Howard Stark and the Super Soldier Serum must exist. And this will be inherent to the setting from the beginning, before I've likely even fully figured out who my central villains are.

See what I mean?

1
NeferataNox•

In every system I play I strictly try to forbid that kind of stuff, I even don't allow players to reset a character and play from beginning.

Why? If you play an already existing character you kinda limit your own RP to be a mimic and maybe you can't do the cool stuff from it's background.

Rested Characters tend to go like they used to play them so they putting chains on themself, instead of enjoying new stuff they try to keep their old Playstyle.

If a player says I wanna be Gandalf, Guts, Harry Potter etc. it will be always a NO. They can use them as a guideline but make own characters, make them unique.

15
Enk1ndle1e•

I agree it's a crutch for learning good RP, but to a new player I think the hardest part is to get them roleplaying at all. If playing discount Gandalf is what it takes for them to open up then so be it, I hope they move on quickly but at least they're participating.

7
Naoki00•

I sorta disagree on not even using characters they have made in the past since I don’t see how that limits them. That character may have never experienced this adventure, or if they were in a different one with different people it would lead them to make different choices, and if a player wants to really go in depth with role playing being able to express the same person but put in very different, possibly life altering scenarios, is a very good way to do it.

For example I have a recurring character who’s whole shtick is that every time they die they are randomly shoved around the multiverse and reincarnated. They still got a lot of the memories but have to start from square one in skills since they are born from a kid, and remembering things from multiple lifetimes isn’t easy or always relevant to the situation. She said a fun character to pull out for the weirder games or things we’ve never done before because it’s really fun for me to figure out how this would change the character.

1
Asdrodon•

Generally speaking I don't allow it in my games, but that's just because of the games I run, not because there's anything wrong with it.

11
FenrisL0k1•

As long as the player understands that the PC doesn't get special powers or privileges based on a non-canon story or him or her (from the perspective of my game), then I don't care. Be whom you want to be. I'm not adding "copyright attorney" and checking how well the player filed off the serial numbers from some prior work to my list of tasks as DM.

Everything I create in game is cribbed from something else anyway.

7

I want you to build your own character so that you can tell your own story.

6
Luna_trick•

I don't like it if it's a whole copy of the character, background, personality, name (and since I play on vtt, the character art too), at least if it's a character I know exists, it kind of takes me out of the immersion.

But if you just make a very similar character, I have no issue.. Just don't make a carbon copy of a character.

6
314Piepurr•

nope. some have the mind for a purely imagined character. some want to play simon belmont. wherever one gets there inspiration is fine

4
PreferredSelectionGMing The Golden Flea•

Obligatory - I don't mind what people do at their own tables.

At mine, there is a big difference between 'inspired' and canonically playing Brook from One Piece.

Like, I don't want a character who is from an AU, and I'm not about to canonically add The Grand Line to my setting.

I played a character who drew some inspiration from Janet, from The Good Place, among other characters. But I don't think anyone would have noticed without me saying so.

4
YandereYasuo•

You mean characters in media like Batman, Sauron or Robin Hood? Why not, especially if they can nail the character. I had a player play as Guts throughout a campaign and I've played as Swain before.

Some people are able to create characters from scratch, some are great at roleplaying an existenting persona.

3
Enk1ndle1e•

I've played as Swain before.

As far as copying characters goes, choosing something like Swain who doesn't have a crazy amount of development is a pretty decent middle ground. Guts you can basically know what he would do in most situations, Swain would require a lot more creative liberties.

3
MediumOk5423•

Was not expecting Brook when I read this, but hey, a surprise to be sure, but a welcome one.

To answer the question, if you at least are not LITERALLY just that character, go on, inspiration is cool, but don't make a panty obsessed skeleton bard AND call him Brook AND start talking about Luffy and NAMI and what not, make it so that your character fits this world, they are just... Legally Distinct Brook®, not... Brook® transported to the campaign world.

3
Cybermagetx•

No, as eventually I'll hear but the can do this in where ever they are from. I use to allow it but not anymore.

3
Expectnoresponse•

So, it's important to make a distinction here.

When you say playing existing characters, it suggests the player is including character background details that require stuff from the setting that character comes from. Specific npcs, specific locations, specific events that occurred in the original fiction. As if the character was magically transported into the pathfinder world at some point in their story. That would be a hard no for me.

A character that is inspired by, or whose personality is a copy of an existing character is fine. Even similar backgrounds as long as the background is adjusted to fit into the setting/campaign.

In my experience the inspired version of a character inevitably ends up forming into a unique character as the story progresses.

Also a personal preference, but I don't like to see the same player with the same character used in multiple campaigns I'm running. No, don't play level one Zod all over again. Give me someone new to torment play with. A fresh backstory with fresh ways to tie it into the plot.

3
goat_token10•

I would be disappointed if someone tried to do this at the table, honestly. The point of a roleplaying game, imo, is to express personal creativity in storytelling. This method skips all that and grabs from a bucket of premade ideas. It's...lame. Not to mention it's disregarding the integrity of the in-game universe 99% of the time.

If you and your group have fun with it, power to you. I wouldn't allow it as a GM and I'd hate it as a fellow PC.

3
AeonReign•

"Role-playing" -- it's in the definition. Now obviously it's fine to prefer not to have characters from other fictions in your world, to each their own, but there's nothing about roleplaying that requires a custom character. Hell it's often a better exercise in role play to try to portray an existing one

1
goat_token10•

What I said is it's completely missing the point of role-playing. I stick to that. It's the lamest, least inspired and least interesting way to roleplay. Yes it's still technically role-playing. But as I said, I'd be disappointed if anyone I was with in a group actually wanted to go that route. Put simply, it's boring and low effort. And again, unless you're doing a game within a specific IP setting, it's not going to make sense within the world the players are inhabiting.

-1
AeonReign•

You're seriously trying to gatekeep the concept of role-playing on the idea that it's missing the point to roleplay an existing character?

Not to mention you'd be disappointed at anyone in your group even wanting to do so?

Unless you're a teenager, in which case these takes at least make sense and you'll grow out of it, you need to learn about opinions and gatekeeping lol

1
goat_token10•

OP asked for opinions on the subject. I gave mine.

I don't care if it's considering "gatekeeping" to have opinions on subjects that don't respect every option equally. Some people might not want to play with min-maxers, or murder hobos, or heavy roleplayers with minimal combat, or whatever else. I can decide the kind of people I play with and whether or not their play style is enjoyable to me. And if someone asks, I'm happy to tell them why.

You don't have to agree, and I don't care if you do. I said in my original statement that if you want to play like this and your group enjoys it, all power to you. But I don't like it, and I don't have to, and your incessant need to somehow prove my opinion wrong is meaningless.

0
Randalfin•

My forever DM made a world specifically for this, called the Nexus. A place at the center of various planes that would suck up random souls of great importance from everywhere, and every when.

Joan of Arc was a paladin npc! Grown up of course.

2
FlurryOfNos•

The only times it bothers me is the complaints that the system doesn't allow them to be the character at level 1 and they expect it to have plot armour. I did this once the dice hated the character but he survived the jungle adventure. Other time a friend and I made twin fighters but based their personalities and interactions on the Venture Bros. Henry and Dean spanked though. Achievements: beat a gorilla grappling and swam in full plate.

2
BoSheck•

As other have said, there's a difference between an homage and a ripoff. I've had the occasional player come to me with an idea for 'basically this character' from whatever franchise and it's always worked out. Heck, when we played through RotRL I thought "I bet I can make Lina Inverse in Pathfinder." And that's what I did, so spell choices were inspired by the character and my wife jumped in to build a master swordsman bodyguard and there wasn't any problem. It let us kind of inform our roleplaying decisions as well as what sort of vices our characters might have or how they'd react to certain situations. Plus I got to sneak some spell chants into my fireball macros.

Do I always do this? No, of course not. Sometimes characters are whole-cloth original ideas, and other times they might have mannerisms based on a character I liked. There's a whole spectrum of possibilities and each of them is fun in its own way. Much like how starting with a joke concept and really riding it to becoming a proper real character is perfectly valid as well.

2