Massive Darkness 2 Felt Gimmicky. But I love loot!

Hello,

I got Massive Darkness and really enjoyed the loot grab. It is often compared to Diablo and that makes a lot of sense. But it often felt like you had limited options getting shoved down a hallway. Enemies were pretty random and didn't feel like their AI was well thought through. So naturally I picked up Massive Darkness and while many people on the internet seem to really enjoy the changes I felt the different mechanics for each class type felt gimmicky at best. Does anyone else feel that way?

My spouse really enjoys Zombicide, I think she enjoys the simplicity of the game and the much quicker setup time. I like it fine as I do enjoy a good amerithrash dice-chucker (the part I really loved from the first Massive Darkness).

The two games that have scratched the itch so far for me are Chronicles of Drunagor and Arena the Contest. But it seems as great as both of those games are (with fantastic minis) they both lack the "gear-up" part of the Massive Darkness series. Does anyone else have a lead on a great dungeon crawler that provides lots of loot? Any other discussion points regarding dungeon crawlers? What do you like? What do you not? What do you wish more of them did or didn't do?

Thanks for reading! :)

Posted May 1, 2023, 7:49 PM UTC

413
boredgamer00•

From the games I have played so far, I think Massive Darkness 2 is the best for loots. I hear Shadows of Brimstone and Middara are also good. I haven't played the heavier dungeon crawlers.

I quite like Adventure Tactics too and it has good leveling up system.

6
Quitchy•

Middara is great at providing interesting loot, but it doesn’t provide lots of it. It does have the strongest build system of any dungeon crawler I know of though, but I’m not sure it would suit someone looking for a simple dice chucker.

3
VVarlord•

Nothing is like MD but you may also like: gloomhaven, swords and sorcery, bardsung, warhammer quest, descent 2nd or lotd, oathsworn maybe

3
Jasonred2OP•

Interesting. Looked into most of those over the years. Which is your favorite?

2
svanxxDescent•

I'm not OP, but Descent 2nd edition has been my favorite game since it was released.

The newer games add some interesting stuff but Descent just gives you pure dungeon crawling with enough rules and replayability to keep it fresh.

1
FlashKickinIt•

Tiny Epic Dungeons and Hellbringer would be my recommendations.

TeD is available at retail, and I would recommend the expansion as well. You are exploring a grid-based dungeon, revealing rooms as you go which can spawn enemies, have traps, opportunities for loot, etc. End game is a boss battle.

Hellbringer was just on Kickstarter, but a late pledge is coming soon I believe. The creator has made all the current content available on TTS, which is how I've been playing it. In this game your are constantly battling enemies and drawing cards from a large deck that represent a series of locations your characters are traversing through. The deck has loot, monster spawns, and new location spawns. The game is heavily Diablo (1 I'd say) inspired. No real "crawling" here though. Roll dice, kill enemies, get XP, draw cards/loot, rinse and repeat. End game is defeating a final boss enemy.

While I did enjoy Massive Darkness 2 to an extent, these two games more successfully scratch the loot itch for me and I've played them both a bunch. One of the issues I had with MD2, and also with Gloomhaven:JotL, is that I just didn't find the loot in either game very exciting. For whatever reason the loot in TeD and Hellbringer resonates with me more.

3
Jasonred2OP•

Thanks I'll have to check those out

1
throwaway__rnd•

Definitely try tiny epic dungeons.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
tallkidinashortworldMansions Of Madness•

If you want to complete the CMOM trifecta of dice chucking dungeon crawlers you could always look at Cthulhu: Death May Die. I love this game.

It doesn't offer a ton of loot (I think 15ish cards per scenario). But the minis are fantastic and the theme is great. It is basically the finale of an 80s action movie where you just punch an elder god in the face.

2
Jasonred2OP•

Ah yes, C:DMD is a great game but as you state not very loot centered as Zombicide and Massive Darkness are...

1
TinCrud1•

I'm really enjoying Skyrim. Although not a traditional dungeon crawl as you primarily move about the world of skyrim, you do enter dungeons. The dungeons consist of fighting one enemy after another in a pretty unique way that doesn't involve moving miniatures around the dungeon.

The game has a great level up system and plenty of loot and ways to upgrade that loot. Also, you have hundreds and hundreds of quests and can play coop. It really is a fantastic game.

1
Jasonred2OP•

Thanks for that mini-review, I've been eyeing the game but the reviews seem to be a bit all over the map.

1
jafrank88•

Do Drunagor and/or Tanares have in-game buffs, or are they mostly between games/episodes? I am looking for a one-off that is Zero-to-Hero.

1